Best Metal Vocalist Replacements

ryanrimmel
When a Metal frontman leaves, its hard to find a good replacement. Vote for the frontman replacements that worked out the best.

The Top Ten

1 Iron Maiden (Bruce Dickinson replaces Paul Di'Anno)

Who knows how far Maiden would have gotten if Bruce never joined - ryanrimmel

Reply to Ryan: "Who knows how far Maiden would have gotten if Bruce never joined".
I know the answer - not far, East London max. Haha, Paul was fired because he didn't want to tour/travel!
And it was when Iron Maiden were cracking the mainstream and were asked to tour the world. Some other reasons were Paul's drug/alcohol problems, combined with violence problems, but refusing to tour was the crucial element. I like his voice though.
Ironically, later Paul left the UK and has been living in Brazil for many years. - Metal_Treasure

2 Pantera (Phil Anselmo replaces Terry Glaze)

To me this is the most significant replacement, with a long-term influence on the band career and metal in general - thanks to that they invented a cool metal subgenre (groove metal). Yes, Phil Anselmo was the driving force of this genre change. Uncle Phil rocks! - Metal_Treasure

Pantera was a really bad Glam band before Phil showed up. He turned them from a really bad band into one of the best ever. - ryanrimmel

This should be number 1, as some singers (such as paul di'anno) were still brilliant. - gemcloben

3 Black Sabbath (Ronnie James Dio replaces Ozzy Osbourne)

The 2 most legendary frontmen in Metal history. As good as Dio is, he didn't fit the Dark Sabbath theme very well, but he released some killer albums with sabbath. - ryanrimmel

4 Cannibal Corpse (Corpsegrinder replaces Chris Barnes)

At least 90% of Cannibal Corpse fans agree that Corpsegrinder is much better than Banres, from vocals to stage presence. - ryanrimmel

@billyv there is no source, just most cc fans I've talked to prefer Corpsegrinder - ryanrimmel

5 Anthrax (Joey Belladonna replaces Neil Turbin)

Joey joined Anthrax after their debut album, and turned them into a legendary Big 4 band! - ryanrimmel

6 Helloween (Michael Kiske replaces Kai Hansen)

Kai Hansen decided he couldn't sing and play guitar at the same time, so the band found an even better singer: Michael Kiske - ryanrimmel

7 Helloween (Andi Deris replaces Michael Kiske)

Michael Kiske is probably the most talented vocalist in Metal, and when he left Helloween, they unbelievably found a vocalist who is almost as good as he is. They replaced the best power metal vocalist with one of the best power metal vocalists. - ryanrimmel

8 Candlemass (Messiah Marcolin replaces Johan Längquist)

They released the most legendary Doom Metal album (epicus doomicus metallicus) and then the frontman leaves. Messiah was the perfect replacement - ryanrimmel

Lämgquist left Candlemass after their legendary debut album, 'Epicus Doomicus Metallicus', and he proved himself to be a perfect replacement and one of the best Doom Metal frontmen ever - ryanrimmel

9 Dream Theater (James LaBrie replaces Charlie Dominici)

The clearest, sweetest, strongest voice with an octave range unrivalled by any other rock singer I have heard. The opera training paid off. James LaBrie played a huge role in bringing Dream Theater to the level of popularity and success it enjoys today.

Dominici wasn't bad. When Dream and Day Unite is a decent album. But he wasn't right for the band overall. But check out his solo work! THAT is better than Labrie's. - IronSabbathPriest

That sounds impressive - I have to check out this guy's solo albums. - Metal_Treasure

Dream Theater fired Dominici cause he wasn't talented, and LaBrie auditioned, won, and now he's a legend - ryanrimmel

10 Arch Enemy (Angela Gossow replaces Johan Liiva)

Yep, Arch Enemy went from male to female as vocalist. - ryanrimmel

The Contenders

11 Iced Earth (Matt Barlow replaces John Greely)

John Greely wasn't a bad singer but Matt Barlow is Oh My God - Iced Earth discovered one of the top 10 metal singers of all time (Matt was a policeman before that). Matt's voice is probably the most powerful/loud clean voice in metal - he can compete with opera singers. And his voice is easily recognizable - very unique tone full of emotion, and overall - amazing. - Metal_Treasure

12 Metallica (Cliff Burton replaces Ron McGovney)
13 Meshuggah (Tomas Haake replaces Niklas Lundgren) Meshuggah (Tomas Haake replaces Niklas Lundgren) Meshuggah is a Swedish progressive metal band from Umeå, formed in 1987. They are credited with crafting the Djent subgenre. Meshuggah's line-up consists of founding members vocalist Jens Kidman and lead guitarist Fredrik Thordendal, drummer Tomas Haake, who joined in 1990, rhythm guitarist Mårten ...read more.
14 Mastodon (Pete Townsend replaces Rick Wakeman) Mastodon (Pete Townsend replaces Rick Wakeman) Mastodon is an American heavy metal band from Atlanta, Georgia, formed in early 2000 and composed of bassist Troy Sanders, guitarists Brent Hinds and Bill Kelliher and drummer Brann Dailor.
15 Ghost (Pope Emeritus III replaces Pope Emeritus II) Ghost (Pope Emeritus III replaces Pope Emeritus II) Ghost is a Swedish heavy metal band that was formed in Linköping in 2008. Ghost consists of 5 masked instrumentalists, known as The Nameless Ghouls, and a demonic anti-pope known as Papa Emeritus. They have released 3 studio albums and 2 EPs . Each album brings in a new version of Papa Emeritus. Ghost ...read more.
16 Judas Priest (Woody Allen replaces Ricky Gervais) Judas Priest (Woody Allen replaces Ricky Gervais) Judas Priest are a British heavy metal band formed in Birmingham, England, in 1969. The band has sold over 45 million albums to date. They received a lot of popularity due to their big hits Breaking The Law, You've Got Another Thing Comin', and Living after Midnight which were played on the radio a ...read more.
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Rock and Metal Songs that Would Sound Great If They Rerecorded It with a Different Vocalist Top 10 Metal Songs Where the Vocalist Provides Both Growls and Clean Vocals Best Vocalist of the Big 4 of Thrash Metal Best Metal Vocalist/Guitarists Best Metal Bands

List StatsUpdated 17 Oct 2017

16 listings
1 year, 361 days old

Top Remixes

1. Pantera (Phil Anselmo replaces Terry Glaze)
2. Iron Maiden (Bruce Dickinson replaces Paul Di'Anno)
3. Iced Earth (Matt Barlow replaces John Greely)
Metal_Treasure
1. Pantera (Phil Anselmo replaces Terry Glaze)
2. Iron Maiden (Bruce Dickinson replaces Paul Di'Anno)
3. Anthrax (Joey Belladonna replaces Neil Turbin)
Rambles
1. Cannibal Corpse (Corpsegrinder replaces Chris Barnes)
2. Iron Maiden (Bruce Dickinson replaces Paul Di'Anno)
3. Black Sabbath (Ronnie James Dio replaces Ozzy Osbourne)
ryanrimmel

WRemix

Posts

Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P