Top 10 Most Evil Warrior Cats

The Top Ten
1 Tigerstar Tigerstar is a villain in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. Son of Leopardfoot and Pinestar, former mate of Goldenflower and Sasha, and father of Bramblestar, Tawnypelt, Mothwing, Hawkfrost, and Tadpole. This brown tabby cat almost causes the downfall of the clans. But is killed, firstly by Scourge, who strips all his lives away. And then by Firestar, who moves on to StarClan when they meet again... read more

Tigerstar's parents should have killed him in the first place. He was bribing Leopardstar so he could take over her clan. He tried to kill Firestar, Bluestar, Redtail, Graypool, Ravenpaw, Swiftpaw, and Scourge. I HATE this cat (although he was a great villain).

He killed Redtail, tried to kill Ravenpaw and Bluestar (he technically succeeded the second time), and also he made TigerClan (RiverClan and ShadowClan united). And he told Darkstripe and Blackfoot to kill Stonefur! He was one of my favorite characters! I hated him. The fact how he told BloodClan to attack and Scourge said, "You can't order my clan around!" Like... lol! And then Scourge killed him. "Happy happy happy!" funny music playing. He made Hawkfrost evil because he gave him evil dreams!

Hm. He would have been a great warrior, but no, he got greedy and craved power. He went down a dark path, murdering and lying just to have more power. Countless died at his claws, staining them red with blood. This cat was merciless. He successfully became deputy, but it wasn't enough. He cheated, killed, and lied, only to be exiled. He should have given up and left them alone. Life as a rogue would have suited him well, but it was never enough.

Even when death claimed him, he continued to terrorize the clans by haunting his sons. This was a cat who was never satisfied. This was a bad cat.

Feather Frost of SkyClan.

2 Brokenstar Brokenstar is a villain character from the Warrior Cats series. Brokenstar is a matted, dark brown tabby tom with a broad, flat face, a bent tail, and orange eyes. Brokenstar was a former Shadowclan leader and a member of the Dark Forest. His mother is Yellowfang and his father is Raggedstar.

He is so evil! He killed kits from his clan and made Yellowfang take the blame. He had the ambition of becoming deputy, and as soon as he achieved it, he killed his own father, Raggedstar, to become leader. Yellowfang hates him, and she fed him death berries to kill him. He prowled in the Dark Forest, waiting for someone like him to join. That's just like Tigerstar.

Look, he killed two kits by breaking the warrior code by making kits fight! What type of cat does that? And even worse, he took them to his mother, Yellowfang, and then exiled her! That's not alright! Not to mention that he killed his own FATHER! He deserves to go to a place worse than the dark forest! He is just so evil. Like, what made him evil? Change my mind.

- Sunnyheart of Frostclan.

Rejected, pushed, and overshadowed, Brokenpaw sought attention and respect. By killing his father, he achieved this. But yet, he felt insecure and paranoid. He needed to be stronger, and his clan needed to be stronger. He sent the young to fight, refused to see their needs, and even when it was brought to his attention, he turned away and pushed the blame onto someone else. This was a cat who stopped at nothing and cared for nothing but power. This was a bad cat.

Featherfrost of SkyClan

3 Scourge Scourge is a villain the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of BloodClan. He was bullied by his siblings, Socks and Ruby, in the past because he was the smallest out of his kin. One of his most notable features is his collar of dog teeth. Scourge is a small black tom with one white paw, ice-blue eyes, glossy fur, and a torn left ear. He has a purple collar studded with teeth from dogs and cats,... read more

Scourge was an amazing, well-developed villain. However, him basically smiting Tigerstar, the very well-developed character and main antagonist of the whole series, was just too OP and unsatisfying. He was still a great villain, though.

Okay, Scourge had the worst kit-hood ever! You have to agree with me on that at least! He grew up with his siblings Socks and Ruby, who bullied him for being the runt of the litter. Then he was wounded by Tigerstar (Tigerpaw at the time). So, I am so happy that Scourge killed Tigerstar in the end! Plus, Tigerstar had nine lives, Scourge only had one, and killed him in a one-hit blow! So amazing! I really like Scourge, and I think he could have been a better and sweeter cat if it weren't for his siblings and everyone else who hurt him on the inside. Love you, Scourge!

Scourge. He should be number one. He is the most evil cat I have ever seen or heard of. But I guess I shouldn't blame him. He got picked on because of how small he was, so that was his revenge.

4 Hawkfrost Hawkfrost is a villain character from the Warriors series. Hawkfrost is a dark brown tabby tom with a snow-white underbelly and ice-blue eyes. Hawkfrost was a former Riverclan warrior and member of the Dark Forest. Hawkfrost tried to kill Firestar with a fox trap but was killed by his brother Brambleclaw by his neck being pierced by the stick of the fox trap.

This cat followed in his father's pawsteps. As soon as Brambleclaw was appointed deputy, he put Firestar in a trap so Brambleclaw could kill him. Luckily, Brambleclaw didn't, and killed his half-brother instead, so peace would come to the forest.

Evil, faking the sign, pure evil. He is like Tigerstar, trapping Firestar! Why? He didn't deserve to live and definitely not to be deputy when Mistystar was trapped.

Hawkfrost is so rude. He made his sister lie and tried to help kill Firestar. He trained in the dark forest and should be known as Tigerstar Jr.

5 Mapleshade Mapleshade is a character in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. Mapleshade is a large, tortoiseshell-and-white she-cat, with a scarred white muzzle, and white patches throughout her pelt. She is thick-furred, and her pelt is ragged, patched, and scarred. Her fur is thick around her neck, like a mane, and she has a broad muzzle and face. She has amber eyes. she is mistakenly described as ginger-and-white... read more

She's like the best villain, literally causing a chain reaction in villains. I also felt pity for her while reading her story. But, why would she have kits cross a flooded river? That was pretty stupid on her part. Anyway, she's one of the most interesting villains in the series, not being driven by ambition, like most of the other villains - Brokenstar, Tigerstar, Hawkfrost, etc. But like the people saying that she should've gone to StarClan, I strongly disagree. Not only the fact that she killed other cats, but she would be forced into a clan where there would be the cats that denied her and who she saw killed her kits? (Well, besides Frecklewish, but is it just me or would it have been cool to see them interact in the Dark Forest together?)

She tricked Crookedkit into a deal for her to make him become leader but have no one else involved. When he was in love with Willowpaw, she tried to kill her with a tenia ball but failed. Afterward, she killed her by giving birth to Crookedstar's kits. She manipulated so many cats, including Thistleclaw, Brokenstar, Tigerstar, and Hawkfrost. This cat isn't the worst, but she is a terrible cat who changes cats' lives for her desire.

6 Darktail

Darktail was a mouse-brained, crow-food-eating, mangy pelt who chased out SkyClan, ShadowClan, and RiverClan. He killed Dawnpelt, Needletail, Rain, and Sharpclaw and captured the innocent. If they repeated the "Kin's" promise, they would get a skinny, bony rat. Onestar did a great job killing him. Darktail was also just plain evil. Those who joined him were mouse-brains, and he led by fear, just like Tigerstar.

Onestar was his father, and Smoke was his mother. When Smoke wanted to join the Clans, he said it was too dangerous and she would never fit in. When she heard him say that, she vowed never to meet him again and to teach Darktail to hate the Clans. Onestar owed it to all the Clans to kill Darktail. So he did, killing himself in the process. - Dovefeather of ThunderClan

This kitty was an evil, evil, evil cat and deserves a better ranking.

I think Darktail is a really interesting and clever character. The author's backstory of Darktail was very tragic but good to read. But enough about this.

What did he do? That's not the question. What you should be asking is: what didn't he do? Well, he chased out SkyClan from their home, influenced loads of rogues, and ShadowClan apprentices to follow him, turning them into heartless fox-hearts. He took over ShadowClan, then RiverClan, killed a ton of cats like Needletail, and forced misery and tragedy upon countless cats. He then helped Ashfur in the Dark Forest. So yeah, start voting for him, people! He deserves it!

Featherfrost of SkyClan

7 Darkstripe

Feeds kit death berries, acts like a big dumb coward, and instantly went with Tigerstar. Like, he's so dramatic when Firestar became leader and went all, "Really? A kitty pet as a leader? I'm not gonna rant anything to a kitty pet." Like Firestar has proved so much to be a great leader. Man, I hate you, Darkstripe.

Why try to feed Sorrelkit death berries? Why do you like Tigerstar? Why do you fight for BloodClan when your leader dies to them, just because Firestar was Tigerstar's enemy?

Who tries to kill a kit? She's a kit, for StarClan's sake! He is evil, trying to kill Sorreltail when she was a kit! And she was a kit! Darkstripe even was going to kill Firestar! He's so evil, he kills or tries to kill a kit?

8 Sol

He is such an interesting one. He didn't fight to get his way. He used his mouth to bribe cats. He killed so many of them. He drove out SkyClan. He bribed most of ShadowClan to stop following the warrior code and stop believing in StarClan. He got cats from WindClan to attack ThunderClan. He's a good villain, though.

Sol was an interesting villain because he didn't need to use his claws to get what he wanted. He used manipulation and other abilities he had to get what he wanted out of the clans.

He even managed to convince nearly the whole of ShadowClan to stop believing in the warrior code and StarClan! And he convinced a bunch of WindClan cats to attack ThunderClan for no reason but his own revenge! Look alive, people! Sol is a good villain, I hope he returns.

-Fruity the Loner (He/they)

Alone, Sol didn't want much, just to be praised, worshipped, to be special. To have, be, or know something someone else didn't. He saw a chance, he took it. He deceived and cheated. This was a cat of cunning. This was a bad cat.

Feather Frost of SkyClan

9 Thistleclaw Thistleclaw is a villain in the Warrior Cats series. Thistleclaw is a gray-and-white tabby tom with spiky fur and amber eyes

Okay, settle down. This is going to take a while.

For one, Thistleclaw did not make Tigerstar evil. Goosefeather saw evil in Tigerstar when he was still a kit. He was simply an evil cat, nothing to do with Thistleclaw. Also, it's not Bluestar's fault Thistleclaw was evil. Your girlfriend's sister not liking you doesn't give you the right to turn against everyone that loves you, everyone you grew up with. Bluestar also didn't chase Thistleclaw into the dark forest. That was a joke the authors made up.

Thistleclaw had no reason to be evil. He trained in the Dark Forest in Spottedleaf's Heart and chose to stay there. Don't make the excuse that he lost his mate and sister. Look at Crookedstar, he lost his mother, his father, his mate, his kits, and his brother. And yet he still stayed loyal to the end.

He was the mentor of Tigerstar, always looking for a fight. Wanting to kill cats for no reason and his ambition to become deputy was terrible. Sadly, Tigerstar followed in his pawsteps and ended up being evil. This cat is evil but cared once when he saw his son.

10 Clawface

Right, I hate this cat. He killed Spottedleaf and followed Brokenstar! After the death of Brokenstar, he joined Tigerstar as a rogue and came back to ShadowClan with him. He is an evil cat, conferring with TigerClan and Tigerstar.

He loved Brokenstar too much. I read Exile from ShadowClan. This cat thought that all the things he was doing were right, but Nightstar is right: he would just never stop killing.

I don't like him, even if he was forced, he still did it. That's like saying it was Yellowfang's fault Brokenstar became evil, which it was not.

The Contenders
11 Bone

This guy is just a thug who is the henchman of a much cleverer cat. He's dumb, big, and a killer, but he's loyal and was just following orders. Plus, Whitestorm drove me crazy. The old, wise cat just had to die. He'd been alive too long. I love Bone. He didn't deserve what he got. I hate the apprentices. They are the mindless killers, not Bone. Long live BloodClan! Die ThunderClan! I hope Scourge rips out Firestar's throat in the future!

Bone is pure evil! He literally collected claws from cats and teeth from dogs. He deserves to be in the Dark Forest for his bloody actions. Maple Shade killed to avenge her kittens. Bone doesn't deserve to be in StarClan. He died because of apps, so he can learn his gory actions from the past.

Bone was so cruel. Bad deeds: Following Scourge as his second in command, nearly killing Barley and his sister, Violet, and killing Whitestorm. He also killed many other cats. Bone deserved to die in the paws of the apprentices.

12 One Eye

Grr. If there's one cat I hate, it's One Eye.

For the clueless ones, here's his story:

One Eye was a rogue from Dawn of the Clans, and before the clans were created, he was an ordinary rogue. He had a mate and a daughter, whom he pretty much manipulated in his arrogant way. He practically told her that her mate would be Slash (luckily, it didn't end up that way). He made his daughter spy for him, then joined the clans to take over SkyClan. He killed Tom, an innocent cat protecting his kit, who he also tried to kill. Then, he just sat there, licking the blood off and telling them he had had harder opponents. He then exiled Clear Sky (Star), branded his mark of a single eye on every cat in SkyClan, and started a war with the different clans.

This was one bad kitty.

Feather Frost of SkyClan

He's in Dawn of the Clans, so most of you don't know him. But he's so evil that he kicked Clear Sky out of his own clan, killed Tom, nearly killed Sparrow Fur, and put his mark of a single eye on innocent cats, making Snake betray his group and made Petal die, leaving Birch and Alder without a mother. And, thanks to his daughter, Thunder, Cloud Spots, Pink Eyes, Lightning Tail, and someone else I don't remember, left to create a new group. So, if you think he is something to forget, then I'll make his dead spirit haunt you in your dreams.

13 Skystar

Skystar is a literal jerk. He's so rude, snappy, and snarky to all the other clans. He doesn't care about his medicine cat (Mica) dying. Also, Clear Sky took like every mate his kin loved. He took Storm and Bright Stream from Gray Wing while he took Star Flower from Thunder. He's also a liar and loves fights. He told Gray Wing that he would feed Jackdaw's Cry but didn't. He rejected his son, saying that he was testing if he could live by himself. Clear Sky fought Gray Wing when Gray Wing didn't want to. He's also a killer. He killed Rainswept Flower and almost killed Gray Wing.

-Creekwhisker from ThunderClan

I don't care how much loss he has, he brought it on himself by being such a jerk in the first three books of Dawn of Clans. Everything was fine until he started making borders, just so that his cats would go hungry, even though there was already enough prey for everyone to share. To be honest, he kind of deserves everything that happened to him. He is the reason why the first battle happened. The cats who died in that battle are because of his actions.

14 Ashfur Ashfur is a character created by Erin Hunter for the book series named Warrior Cats. Ashfur is a muscular pale gray tom with darker flecks and dark blue eyes. He has short, thick fur, and a torn ear.

This cat here, yeah, this man takes insane to a new level. Need I say more? Okay, I will give the exact insane level he is on. He took over BrambleStar's body just so that he could get a second chance with SquirrelFlight, then he threatens to kill Bramble Star if they don't do what he wants. Also, this cat manipulated Shadow Sight so much that in the end of the series Shadow Sight thinks he should go to the Dark Forest. Yeah, this cat should die for a third time and then some.

I've been rejected 4 times, exactly like Ashfur, and I didn't try to kill people that didn't do anything. Ashfur, you're cool but not gonna lie, a baby. Like, you need to grow up and move on. You have so much more things to do than kill because you don't have a mate and try to get revenge.

THIS CAT! I know and understand he was heartbroken that SquirrelFlight chose BrambleClaw instead of him, but that's no reason to try to kill her kits! (Well, LeafPool's but he never knew). And he ends up being killed by Hollyleaf, one of the kits. He started possessing Bramblestar, and when SquirrelFlight found out, he kidnapped her! This cat is pure evil and he can't get over his love for SquirrelFlight, and killed cats (including Greystripe) for his love.

15 Sleekwhisker

Sleekwhisker was awful, just a horrid nightmare. She was the first cat to volunteer in joining Darktail. Then she stole Yarrowleaf's kits! I don't even know why she wanted to stay with Nettle and Raven. I mean, Nettle was prepared to kill his own kits, and I am sure that Sleekwhisker eventually had a kit with Nettle. She's just so awful! And I'm sure if she ever did have kits, she wouldn't even care about what happens to them!

She's so evil. First, as Sleekpaw, she joins Darktail's rogues and plots against the clans. Then, she gave herself a warrior name and turned Violetpaw in for trying to put Darktail to sleep. She then helps Darktail drown Needletail for Violetpaw's punishment. Later, she goes to SkyClan and begs for sanctuary with Yarrowleaf. Then, she puts Yarrowleaf to sleep, steals her kits, and betrays the clans.

I hate her. She loved Nettletail but then was jealous of Rain because Nettletail loved him. But after Darktail told her to kill Nettletail, she was very loyal to Darktail, so she killed her. I mean, she killed her own love!

16 Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He becomes the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He is mates with Sandstorm and has two kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. Formerly a kittypet named Rusty, Firestar is killed by fatal wounds inflicted by the spirit of Tigerstar and a falling tree... read more

Firestar killed my favorite character, Scourge. I know he sounds like a great cat, but he is a LIAR. He never lost his last life. Instead, he never shared with any cat that he could return to his body. He's also killed too many cats for some to forgive him.

Umm, he kind of cheated on Sandstorm. He still loved Spottedleaf even after she died, and wasn't afraid to express it. Sandstorm knew this, and if your boyfriend or girlfriend did this to you, would you feel sympathy? When Spottedleaf died in The Last Hope, he said that she would wait for him in StarClan. Sandstorm was right next to him when he said this. Also, he didn't tell anybody that SkyClan existed.

When you think about it, Firestar is evil. DON'T YELL AT ME YET! He killed an apprentice. It was a young apprentice too, or knowledge shows that. And a tiny apprentice. HE LOOKED LIKE A KIT, WE KNOW THAT MUCH. Firestar murdered him with a cold heart. You may wonder who I'm talking about. Scourge. Yup, he was a young apprentice with no battle experience that killed Tigerstar... GARY STU! I still think that is just on how he fights and other than that, he has no points where he's a gary stu. Firestar is the worst!

17 Socks

I absolutely hate Socks! He bullied and teased Scourge with Ruby, and they're the reason he's evil! Also, Tigerstar attacked him when they were young, so he's part of why he's evil too! Socks had no reason to bully Scourge. Scourge did nothing to them, did he?!?

I love Scourge, and Socks was the one that made him evil by bullying him. What did Scourge even do? And when he grew up, he asked Scourge to give him food, and Scourge did give them one meal. One meal isn't a lot, but it is better than starving. Scourge didn't even forgive Socks yet, so why would anyone suspect that he would give Socks one meal?

- Crystalpool of Leafclan

No one likes a bully. Socks is too easy of a character to hate - along with Ruby -, and I seriously do not like him. Although Scourge did bad things, it probably wouldn't have been as bad if his siblings hadn't bullied him. Just like with Thistleclaw and Tigerstar, it wasn't Thistleclaw's fault entirely, but he definitely didn't help.

- Sagefall

18 Snowtuft

We don't know much about Snowtuft, but he's evil. He almost killed Ivypool, and he was in the Omen of the Stars. It's hard to judge this cat, Snowtuft.

Snowtuft was in Omen of the Stars. He almost killed Ivypool.

Snowtuft was evil. But then his change just made me have a different feeling.

19 Blackstar

I hate Blackstar. He was on Tigerstar's side. Although the warrior code does say to always obey, agree, or not hurt your leader, I will give him the slack that he was at least obeying the warrior code. But still, I don't like him.

He was bad when he killed Stonefur, but he was a great leader. He's not really evil anymore once he becomes Blackstar, but when he's Blackfoot, he's evil! Stonefur was amazing!

I hate how everyone was just fine with him being leader when he supported Brokenstar and was one of the reasons why Stonefur died.

20 Appledusk

He just wanted to be recognized in RiverClan as a good cat and did not care about Mapleshade anymore. He would rather be let into RiverClan than have Mapleshade be safe. He was almost using Mapleshade to get kits, but now that the love he had for her was gone because Mapleshade "killed" his beloved kits. He rejected her. So, good on Mapleshade for getting rid of that cat.

If I could, I would set him on fire! He (mostly) caused Mapleshade to become evil. I will give him the right to find another mate and be loyal to his clan. But how can some cat not care about the death of their kits? He was a terrible father and mate. For anyone defending him, would you take him as your mate if you had the option? No, because he is a terrible mate. End of story.

- Raindancer of Riverclan

Appledusk is the worst. He did not care for his mate or his kits. He is the literal reason Mapleshade became evil. I was happy when Mapleshade killed the fox-heart!

21 Rainflower

I absolutely hate this cat and would like to point out that she is one of two she-cats on the top 25, next to Mapleshade. That really says all there needs to be said.

Poor, poor Crookedstar never deserved this abomination of a mother. Seriously, how did she get into StarClan? I hate her so much and she deserves to rot in the Dark Forest for the rest of her miserable, pathetic life.

Such a mean mum! Like, bruh, renaming your kid because they broke their jaw? That's seriously not nice! At least she got what she deserved and died horribly.

MewNotMeow

22 Pinestar

Pineheart is one of the worst cats, and hear me out. He led to Tigerstar slowly becoming evil, gave Tigerstar trauma and depression, and led to all of Tigerstar's kills, and Tigerstar's own death. Is there a page where I can vote for the worst father ever?

Twitchtail -
World's worst father. You raised a murderer...actually, you weren't even there for him. You pretty much left him to fend for himself. Pinestar should be at the top because he was the one who made Tigerstar a murder machine!

I HATE HIM! He left his mate, his 2 sick kits, and his whole clan! Just so he wouldn't die, but then he died anyway. He should NOT have gone to Starclan. Besides, kittypets don't believe in Starclan! They don't know what it is! And he shouldn't have given Bluestar one of her lives. He's the worst!

23 Slash

OMG. How is Slash number 23!? He is just so evil!

For those who don't know him, here's his story:

Okay, so he comes from Dawn of the Clans, was a great friend of One Eye (another fox-heart), and was a leader of a band of selfish rogues. He also kidnapped Star Flower when she was heavy with Clear Sky's (Sky Star) kits. He almost starved her, nearly killing her in doing so.

So if you question me on why I call Slash a fox-heart, hopefully you now understand.

Featherfrost of SkyClan

Slash is one of the most evil cats in the series. Slash abused cats, made them hunt all day, just so he and his most loyal cats could actually have a decent meal. There were plenty of other perfectly fine prey, but he made the other cats starve. Also, might I mention, that he KIDNAPPED an "innocent" cat, just for MORE prey.

Slash... Slash..! Slash..! SLASH! I HATE THIS FREAKING CAT! He kidnaps Star Flower, starves her when she is expecting kits, and steals prey from all the groups, making them starve. He tells them they have to starve to save Star Flower (not literally). He tells Frog that he doesn't get any prey because he didn't steal enough, only gives the good prey to his best friends, and doesn't lift a single claw to help his cats when Red Claw accidentally leads dogs into the camp. He kidnaps Black Ear because he is Gray Wing's son, who he somehow hates now, and almost lets the KIT get hit by a monster. And then...! I'm done ranting on this cat. There is too much for me to say. NEXT!

-Silverblossom

24 Leopardstar Leopardstar is a golden tabby she-cat with amber eyes.
Leopardstar was a leader of RiverClan in the forest and in the lake territories. Leopardkit was born to Mudfur and Brightsky alongside three unnamed kits; however, Brightsky and her littermates died during the kitting. Mudfur gave her the name of the mighty spotted cats from LeopardClan to give her the strength to survive. Shimmerpelt took... read more

Leopardstar is on my list of most hated characters in media, not just Warriors. Her first strike was just taking over ThunderClan stupidly, thinking she would be a good leader by being reckless and just overly willing to fight.

Leopardstar isn't too evil, but it was a horrible decision to join Tigerclan. Because she joined Tigerclan, her loyal deputy, in other words, the beloved Stonefur, got killed by Blackfoot, later to be known as Blackstar. Leopardstar was a hot-headed she-cat, if I may say so, with a pretty short temper. I would not recommend having her as a leader.

Sorry, Leopardstar, but you joined Tigerstar and ShadowClan because you wanted to be mates with Tigerstar and hoped he would let you rule the forest with him. Sorry, Leopardstar, NOPE!

25 Hawkheart Hawkheart is a stone-gray tom with flecks of darker brown fur, yellow eyes, and graying whiskers.

Hawkheart was a WindClan medicine cat under Heatherstar’s leadership in the forest territories. He originally served as a warrior before becoming a medicine cat. He was said to have an unusually strong and rough personality. During an attack on WindClan's camp, Hawkheart violently defended his... read more

Hawkheart IS EVIL! And I don't think it says anywhere that he went to STARCLAN! And it's against the warrior code to kill! To the person who said he trained as a warrior first, it doesn't matter! It is still against the warrior code to kill, warrior or not. You could have wounded her badly, but not killed her! He is also pretty rude.

I HATE Hawkheart! He should be much higher on this list! Cats shouldn't kill. Even if he was defending his herbs, he didn't have to KILL Moonflower. It isn't ok to ask Goosefeather if he killed someone, even if he was joking. Also, he was rude at Featherpaw's ceremony, I think. It was as much Shrewpaw's fault as Moonpaw's for arguing. And he was super rude to Bluestar when she was an apprentice.

People hate Hawkheart only because he killed Moonflower. If Spottedleaf was in WindClan, born earlier, was a medic there, and killed Moonflower, would you hate Spottedleaf? It was Goosefeather who sent Moonflower to her death. Oh yes, this is against a code. He's a codebreaker, now I can't defend him anymore. Kick this guy out, along with Ashfur and Hollyleaf!

8Load More
PSearch List