Top Ten Most Overrated Pies

The pies that just aren't as good as they are made out to be.

The Top Ten

1 Apple

Why is there a list of most overrated pies?

this is a random list but apple pies are very overrated

I love apple pies though, its cherry that's overrated - Lucretia

It's disguisting. Ew mushy apples

V 3 Comments
2 Lemon Meringue

Its good... key lime tastes much worse - Lucretia

I would rather stab myself with a fork then eat lemkn meringue

3 Cherry

Can't stand them from the song Cherry Pie, and I hate cherries so yeah... I can't see why people like them - Lucretia

Makes me puke. WAAAAY too sweet and saturated - TheNewGuy132

4 Berry

Not the worst pie, but its supposed to be really good and its not - CaptainComedy17

5 Pumpkin

Globby and bland. It exists only to carry whipped cream, yet there is never sufficient whipped cream. A symbol of frustration.

I love pumpkin. Its good with ice cream - Lucretia

Pumpkin stinks! Everyone loves it but it doesn't taste like a pie should. It makes me want to puke.

Uhh don't get me started I HATE pum I can't even say it! :(

6 Jelly
7 Peach

peaches taste horrible so why ruin a pie with them!

Good though... - Lucretia

8 Coconut
9 Banana

Yes. Nasty only better then cherry... - Lucretia

10 Raspberry

The Contenders

11 Strawberry

Yes, strawberry rhubarbs are great though - Lucretia

12 Meat
13 Boston Cream

Its great... - Lucretia

BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists