Most Overrated Video Games

Jake_Kane22

The Contenders: Page 6

101 Killzone 3

The entire Killzone franchise is overrated. Sorry PlayStation fanboys, but I never liked your crappy Dutch Halo/Medal of Honor clone.

102 Sonic & Knuckles
103 Super Mario Galaxy 2

Game isn't overrated, it's easily an instant classic, it took everything from the first entry, and made it ten times better, and much longer.

Why is this game lower than the first one? It's just its 1.5 version and it got more praise especially by critics. - DaisyandRosalina

This should be top 1!

Seriously, people are fussy about rescuing Princess Peach & listening to her aggressive, overrated voice. And guess what? This game is the highest-rated video game ever!

This is my lest favourite game. It absolutely sucks compared to the first one.

V 12 Comments
104 Star Fox 64

The 64 Elitists need to shut up!

This here is why Star Fox Zero didn't have an original storyline. I miss when there was newer stuff to Star Fox but only if they did them right, like Star Fox Assault. But no, Nintendo had to pander to the 64 fanboys and created a flimsy rehash of Star Fox 64. - Rue

DEATH TO 64 ELITISM!

Lots of people say it was a great game. I'll tell you I didn't really enjoy it. - HALOOOOOOOO

105 Pokemon Ruby

I beat ruby with just 1 Mudkip

It's not overrated, it's just too good for you :-P

106 Subway Surfers
107 Pac-man

P! $$3s me off good and proper but it's fun, simple and is a great classic!

Pacman can be annoying

Pacman has a voice?

This is a classic!

V 3 Comments
108 Sonic Adventure

No more Sonic games should be put on this list, mainly because, when a bad game franchise (I love the franchise, but it's pretty bad) has a good game, it needs the praise

The best sonic games is the original adventure and the first game and generations - ikerevievs

The extensive voice acting was bull.

People need to stop saying that this is the best Sonic game, because it's not. Classic Sonic is way better.

V 1 Comment
109 Tomodachi Life V 1 Comment
110 Pixel Gun 3D

The game wasn't so bad until the new update where it is so hard to level up and get coins

Pixel gun was good when it was in its early years. The old default skins where fantastic but now it's a total crappy wreck.

I used to play it but after buying the 'desert eagle' gun it's hard to get new ones unless your really skilled

V 1 Comment
111 Angry Birds Go

Angry Birds Go... Away. And close the door behind you. And never come back.

V 1 Comment
112 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

How is this not number 1. Each Zelda game that followed improved on everything this game has done but you guys still think it is better than eny other game on the planet. It is the worst 3D Zelda game. Critics should look past Nostalgia, Influence and Age, if they do they will see this game is weak compared to Skyward Sword, Wind Waker, Twilight Princess and Majora's Mask. The fishing isn't that fun either. The music isn't that good. The Dungeons are fun but they could of been more interesting. The Bosses are Overrated, Navi's Annoying, The Running Man is Unbeatable and the story isn't a masterpiece either. I think people should just move on. Ocarina was great for its time but now it is nothing. So many games have came out after this that are both better and more fun than this game. But you guys are closeminded and refuse to change your opinion but you want to. This should definitely be Number One. No game has ever gotten WAY TOO MUCH PRAISE than it deserves. It should be a sin to ...more

Overrated? It's far from overrated. It might not be the best game on the face of the planet, but to call it overrated is a sin. The worst part of the game was Navi the fairy. The graphics were great for it's time, the levels were progressively challenging, and the weapons and items were amazing, AND you could time travel! Do this website a favour and take this game off the list. This list however shows the credibility of this website. Two Halo games on the list and Ocarina of Time, pathetic. - patrickmoore

It is overrated. you say its not the best game, but have you checked the best video games of all time list?

Ocarina of Time is undoubtedly a fantastic game. But there are SO many fanboys/girls that attack anyone and everyone who says this isn't their favorite Legend of Zelda game. You grew up with this game and have nostalgia for it? FINE! It's your favorite game of all time? FINE! You attack anyone who disagrees with you just because you like this game? ACCEPT SOMEONE ELSE'S OPINION!

Please. Please stop calling this the best game ever, and stating it as a fact. - SoaPuffball

V 81 Comments
113 Sonic Adventure 2

Why is this here? I don't see people saying this is best, I see people saying Sonic 1 is best. Either way, it's my opinion.

The mech stages and hunting stages sucked! People literally admit they only like the speed sections! Of course it deserves to go on this list!

This was the best Sonic game, but it's not overrated. It deserves to be loved everywhere.

I really don't like this game.
The controls aren't good.
The gameplay is meh.
The music is actually good...
..but the soundmixing is bad.
The Visuals are dated and depressive (in my opinion).
The cutscenes are laughably bad.
The story sucks.

The game is for me a 5/10.
I don't know why people say that this is one of the best sonic games ever. I can see the positives, but a lot of people can't see the negatives.

This game is for met the most overrated.

V 6 Comments
114 Super Metroid

By far the second most overrated game of the Metroid series next to Metroid Fusion. - xandermartin98

Them ROM hacks though - xandermartin98

Quite possibly the most overrated game of all time.

115 Super Mario Bros. 2

This isn't a Mario game at all, it's underrated... Even the Lost Levels isn't overrated, so no Mario 2 should be here.

Wait... WHAT! This game is consideredly called a very bad Mario game. Get this off the list!

This game is technically underrated, not overrated - GentleTrouter

How is it overrated when nobody likes it?

V 1 Comment
116 Bioshock Infinite

This game I anything is underrated. It has amazing game play a beautiful story and interesting characters. But it show you the darker themes of supremacy and religion and that things aren't as they seem in Columbia. This game deserves the praise. Its is without a doubt the greatest game of all time

BioShock Infinite does get a large amount of praise, but I think that (for the most part) it is completely deserved. Few games can create an atmosphere as immersive and spectacular as the city of Columbia. The world feels so authentic yet surreal. This game easily lives up to it's BioShock name.

117 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

Modern Warfare is great! But I can agree, it might be overrated... But the game is still awesome. This game, number 2 and 3 for it too, aren't overrated. Just purely and simply... Good and awesome. And this is coming from a girl. Most boys love this game. People who voted this are probably little sissy girls. I voted to say what I said.

Oh, When I clicked this I thought it was talking about Modern Warfare in general. They add absolutely nothing each game and try and pass them off as a brand new game. You play one, you've played them all.
P.S Why is Halo CE /Halo 3 on this list? Those games well deserved their popularity.

Some people has compared this to Uncharted 2! What?!
Uncharted is an amazing game by Naughty Dog, this is just in a line of copy paste sequels! And for WHATEVER reason, I see this game in a LOT of top ten lists. It just doesn't deserve it.

LOL!

Call of Duty appeared the 3rd time! XDDD

V 9 Comments
118 Eve Online

Horribly clunky interface, over the top complex and dull gameplay, and a player community of cutthroat sociopaths. What's there to like?

119 Secret of Mana

People think it's the best snes square game ever but that title goes to FF6

120 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night

Extremely broken it is. - xandermartin98

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Most Overrated Video Games of 2013 Top 10 Video Games, Movies and Shows That Are Greatly Overrated Due to Their Nostalgia Factors Top 10 Video Games With the Most Overrated Storyline Top 10 Underrated Video Games Overshadowed by Highly Overrated Ones Top 10 Underrated Video Games from Overrated Series

List StatsUpdated 20 Sep 2017

6,000 votes
442 listings
10 years, 18 days old

Top Remixes (78)

1. Mario Party Series
2. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
3. Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
VideoGamefan5
1. Final Fantasy VII
2. Minecraft
3. Grand Theft Auto IV
htoutlaws2012
1. Half-Life 2
2. Call of Duty
3. Team Fortress 2
ultradrakescale

WRemix
View All 78

Posts

Call of Duty isn't bad, just overrated.
lukestheman4
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P