Most Shocking American Idol Eliminations

It has to be said. American Idol is doing a lot of things wrong and they need to be addressed.

The Top Ten

1 Pia Toscano, Season 10, Top 9

2 Colton Dixon, Season 11, Top 7

3 Jennifer Hudson, Season 3, Top 7

4 James Durbin, Season 10, Top 4

5 Chris Daughtry, Season 5, Top 4

6 LaToya London, Season 3, Top 4

7 Kellie Pickler, Season 5, Top 6

8 Tamyra Gray, Season 1, Top 4

9 Elise Testone, Season 11, Top 6

10 Jennifer Hirsh, Season 11, Best of the Rest

The Contenders

11 Sam Woolf, Season 13, Top 5

Curse you twist of letting contestants chose to go home or not. Thanks to Jena and Alex, Sam was eliminated. He should've won with Jena as runner up, not Caleb Johnson.

BAdd New Item