Top 10 Movies with the Most Inaccurate Ratings on Allmovie

Just so you know, Allmovie is basically the movie version of Allmusic. I own an account on Allmovie and I most of the time can say they get all the ratings right. However, there are a few exceptions.

The Top Ten

1 The Green Mile

WHAT 5 stars surely - lolsy

Why am I the only one who seems to hate this film? - AlphaQ

Not that great. Really overrated. Maybe 7/10. - LordofL

3 is very low for this. - zxm

V 1 Comment
2 Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines

No, I think this was pretty deserving. - Jackamalio

I want to see this movie - johnconnor

A huge dissapointment - lolsy

Dog head

V 1 Comment
3 Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

I honestly agree with that rating, it was kind of mediocre. - DCfnaf

Like it a lot actually - lolsy

Rating: 2.5 stars
Okay, disagree with this all you want. I could've chosen 2002's Attack of the Clones (please don't kill me for liking it) as 3 stars or 2015's The Force Awakens as 4.5 stars but I feel Rogue One didn't need a 2.5 stars. It was actually a pretty good movie. - jack2244

I agree. My whole family hates them except for me. Feel a bit saddened by that - KDProductions

Better than TFA - CLMF

4 La La Land

I know that some people hate this movie but a LOT of people love it so the rating isn't very inaccurate.

Horrible, I'm sorry if I over hate this movie, but I'm just giving my opinion and it's a pile of crap - DCfnaf

This movie had my wanting to stop after half than hour - lolsy

This should have a 1 star rating - YOSHIA2121

5 Cape Fear

Rating: 3.5 stars
I personally find 1962's Cape Fear better than Scorsese's 1991 remake. However, I just can't help but say that the 1991 movie is amazing as well. It is disappointing compared to Scorsese's 1990 classic Goodfellas but it is still a good thriller. - jack2244

6 Fear and Desire

Rating: 2 stars
By far, Kubrick's most underrated movie. 1954's Killer Kiss was a great movie with 3 stars, but I had to go with Fear and Desire due to it's 2 stars. I heard this movie wasn't as great when I looked at the reviews, but then, I didn't let the reviews get the best of me and decided to go ahead and watch this 60 minute 1953 movie directed by Kubrick because it interested me. And I wasn't disappointed. - jack2244

7 Transformers: Dark of the Moon

This should have 1.5, not 3 - jack2244

You're right. This rating is totally undeserved... it should have had a 1.5 - MarianasPilots

This need 4. - AlphaQ

Trashcan movie. deserves to burn. - johnconnor

8 Cars 2

Cars 2 is Pixar's worst movie. In fact, I think 3 stars is too high for it. - phillysports

I really do like this film, but I just find it... bleh. - ChibiDaFox

Rating: 3 stars
Again, disagree all you want. Cars 2 is a brilliant movie. It was just as good as 2006's Cars. I always hate when people use the argument "Out of all Pixar movies, they just to make a sequel of Cars". I don't care, because in my humble opinion, I loved Cars 2 as much as Cars. - jack2244

Nah, Cars 1 was way better, but Cars 2 ain't even bad and it gets way too much hate. - peaceswagtv

9 The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Lost World is sooo horrible - Datrandomdude

Rating: 3.5 stars
Oh god, where to begin with all the hatred. I noticed the flaws and enjoyed the movie. It'll never be as great as 1993's Jurassic Park though. Jurassic Park is just one of those movies that is hard to beat. However, this was pretty good. I think it's also pretty good compared to 2001's Jurassic Park III, oh god, where to begin with Jurassic Park III - jack2244

10 Pixels

Terrible film. - johnconnor

I'd Say 3 Is Fine For This, - VideoGamefan5

The Contenders

11 Back to the Future Part II

i like

12 Transformers: Age of Extinction

Are you serious, this got a 4.5, are you serious? - jack2244

This should NOT have got a 4.5. - AlphaQ

This is proof that media rn is hopelessly messed up...

4.5. 4.5! This movie doesn't even deserve a 1.5! - naFrovivuS

13 Men in Black
14 Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull

The movie that nuked the fridge gets a 3.5? I don't think so. - naFrovivuS

This is a great movie. Ridiculous rating. - DCfnaf

Rating: 3.5 stars
Another movie with annoyingly intense hatred. This movie wasn't even that bad. Okay, like The Lost World: Jurassic Park, I can see why people hate it but it's hatred is way too harsh for a film that isn't even bad. - jack2244

15 Zootopia

This bad because it about drugs so it worse than the dead pool movie

Zootopia is brilliant film - Ipeon

16 Stop! or My Mom Will Shoot

The title though - johnconnor

17 Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan
18 The Fate of the Furious

This deserves a five, it was better than most of the movies - EliHbk

This deserves 5 stars. It only got 2. - AlphaQ

Perhaps -- and this, of course, is just my opinion -- it's because they're milking this franchise until it's nothing but repetitive car crashes with a script that Michael Bay himself could have written. - MarianasPilots

This Movie Is Not That Great, - VideoGamefan5

For one this movie earned the cast The Generation Award which means this whole entire trilogy had to be good. - KDProductions

Why Does Everyone Like This Movie? , Everything About it is lame, Bad Soundtrack, Bad Editing, Just Boring - VideoGamefan5

19 Bridesmaids
20 Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen

Your kidding me, this got a 4.5 as well? - jack2244

These movies are trash - DCfnaf

BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Movies with the Most Inaccurate Ratings from the MPAA Top Ten Ways In Which Sci-fi Movies Are Scientifically Inaccurate Top 10 Good Movies with Bad IMDb Ratings Video Games, Movies, and Shows With the Least Accurate Ratings Animated Movies that are Good with Bad Ratings on Rotten Tomatoes

List StatsUpdated 26 May 2017

100 votes
32 listings
22 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. La La Land
2. The Green Mile
3. Pixels
1. The Fate of the Furious
2. Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
3. La La Land
1. The Green Mile
2. Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
3. Cape Fear

View All 4


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.