Best Music Debates Ever

zxm
There have been always some music debates .
Here's some of them.

Please add more

The Top Ten

1 Who is the better singer, Elvis Presley or Michael Jackson Who is the better singer, Elvis Presley or Michael Jackson

Aw, I thought this was gonna be rap battles. - keycha1n

Elvis Presley is better

Elvis is better

Presley - catwalk

V 2 Comments
2 Which song is the best ever, Bohemian Rhapsody or Stairway to Heaven Which song is the best ever, Bohemian Rhapsody or  Stairway to Heaven

Bohemian Rhapsody! Stairway to Heaven has a ripped off element (from the song Taurus by Spirit) and this turns me off. Also, Bohemian Rhapsody has better vox. - Metal_Treasure

If you mean tempo, Rhapsody clearly is faster. And if you think Stairway is "more energetic," then you conception of "energy" certainly is curious.

Bohemian Rhapsody. - BeatlesFan1964

Bohemian Rhapsody

V 7 Comments
3 Who is the better guitarist, Jimmy Page or Eric Clapton Who is the better guitarist, Jimmy Page or Eric Clapton

This is a hairy one, and depends entirely on personal taste. Think, however, Page has recorded more celestial moments than Clapton.

Jimmy Page by far bro - 2234

Guys that's why I have made this list. All of them/these are very famous and almost close to their competitors.

These are ongoing debates

Anyway I prefer Page over Clapton.He could play more genres of rock than Clapton.He also created some hard-core guitar riffs and solos which led hard-rock to heavy metal. - zxm

Jimmy Page - catwalk

V 1 Comment
4 Who is the better singer, Freddie Mercury or Robert Plant

Freddie was the best singer we all know but Robert Plant did have a very good vocals although his singing technique wasn't very good - zxm

Definitely Freddie but Plant is very good, too. - Metal_Treasure

Freddie, it is obvious. - bzsuzsi0128

Freddie

V 5 Comments
5 Which is the better metal band, Metallica or Iron Maiden Which is the better metal band, Metallica or Iron Maiden

Metallica went downhill in the 90s and haven't really gotten back up. Iron Maiden had Blaze Bailey for a while but even then they produced some of their best live songs such as Sign of the Cross and The Clansman. Check out the Rock in Rio live versions of both of those songs. They will blow your mind. The studio versions are good too.
Maiden's band members also have better and more likeable personalities. - IronSabbathPriest

Metallica, guys. Metallica. Though Iron Maiden are also good. - RiverClanRocks

Iron Maiden. - BeatlesFan1964

Iron Maiden - catwalk

V 1 Comment
6 Which is the better metal band, Metallica or Megadeth Which is the better metal band, Metallica or Megadeth

I'll go with Metallica. Megadeth is a great thrash band, but Metallica did stuff other than thrash well, just not as good as they did thrash. Plus, Metallica caused Megadeth to be created. - Skullkid755

I'd tie them. Both went downhill but in their early days produced substantial material. - IronSabbathPriest

This is the biggest real debate in the metal community. I know the advatages and disadvantages of these two bands, like them both but if I have to choose I would probably go with Metallica. - Metal_Treasure

Megadeth - catwalk

V 1 Comment
7 Who is better, Led Zeppelin or The Rolling Stones Who is better, Led Zeppelin or The Rolling Stones

The Rolling Stones - catwalk

I like Led Zeppelin more

but stones are also awesome - zxm

Zeppelin - BeatlesFan1964

If you're talking pure rock 'n' roll (with inherent forays into R&B), Stones every time.

8 Who is the better singer, Freddie Mercury or Elvis Presley Who is the better singer, Freddie Mercury or Elvis Presley

Elvis was more influential rock artist.

Freddie had better singing abilities. - zxm

Freddie, easily, however I love Elvis.

Freddie. I love Elvis, but Freddie had an amazing vocal range.

Freddie.

V 4 Comments
9 Who is the better guitarist, Jimmy Page or Ritchie Blackmore

Ritchie Blackmore. Page is extremely overrated. - Metal_Treasure

Jimmy Page - catwalk

10 Who is better the hard rock vocalist, Bon Scott or Brian Johnson Who is better the hard rock vocalist, Bon Scott or  Brian Johnson

Brian is more energetic - zxm

Brian Johnson - catwalk

Bon Scott - BeatlesFan1964

The Contenders

11 Who is the best singer of the Beatles, Paul McCartney or John Lennon Who is the best singer of the Beatles, Paul McCartney or John Lennon

McCartney's range once was mind-boggling, but Lennon's was much more distinctive, with qualities suited to several sub-genres.

Paul McCartney - catwalk

McCartney. - BeatlesFan1964

12 Who invented heavy metal, Black Sabbath or Deep Purple

Deep Purple. Black Sabbath played heavy blues rock in the 70s (confirmed by Tony Iommi himself) but metal has nothing to do with blues. Heavy metal and heavy blues rock are stylistically different - metal uses classical scales and not blues scales. For the same reason Led Zep have never been a metal band - they were also blues inspired. So Deep Purple is the answer - they had classically inspired songs. - Metal_Treasure

I wish if someone added Led Zeppelin with it - zxm

Helter Skelter. - BeatlesFan1964

Deep Purple - catwalk

13 Who's better screamer, Ian Gillan or Rob Halford

I can't choose, both are awesome but Gillan started it all, especially in metal singing so Halford himself was influenced by Gillan. Gillan also was Bruce Dickinson's vocal idol. - Metal_Treasure

Halford, close though. - BeatlesFan1964

Ian Gillan - catwalk

14 Who's more talented, Rush or Led Zeppelin

Led Zeppelin is a tighter band, however Rush is, overall, more talented. - BeatlesFan1964

Rush. - Metal_Treasure

Rush - catwalk

15 Who was the best member of Guns N' Roses, Axl Rose vs Slash

Those who like vocal more normally they choose Axl
And those who like guitar more they choose Slash

I like guitar but I think Axl is better (for me) - zxm

Slash, Axl is a giant dick. - BeatlesFan1964

Buckethead. - IronSabbathPriest

Axl Rose - catwalk

16 Who is worse, Rebecca Black, Nicki Minaj, or Justin Bieber

Justin Bieber - catwalk

Nicki Minaj. - BeatlesFan1964

17 Who's the best vocalist, Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey or Celine Dion

Of those choices, Whitney Houston easily takes the cake. - BeatlesFan1964

Whitney Houston - catwalk

18 Who is better rock vocalist, Mick Jagger or Robert Plant

Robert Plant is a better singer, however, Mick Jagger has a more distinctive tone to his voice. - BeatlesFan1964

Plant has better vocal skills. - Metal_Treasure

Plant had a great voice, but his falsetto always sounded like a cartoon cat with its tail on fire.
Jagger's voice well-suited to the Stone's repertoire.

Robert Plant - catwalk

V 1 Comment
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Ten Most Controversial Debate Topics Top 10 Who’s Better Sports Debates Top Ten Awkwardly Dumbfounded Things for a Candidate to Say On an Election Debate Top 10 Debates People Are Tired Of Top Ten People That Would Destroy Ben Shapiro in a Debate

List Stats

18 listings
2 years, 168 days old

Top Remixes

1. Who is the better singer, Freddie Mercury or Robert Plant
2. Which is the better metal band, Metallica or Megadeth
3. Which song is the best ever, Bohemian Rhapsody or Stairway to Heaven
Metal_Treasure
1. Who is the better singer, Elvis Presley or Michael Jackson
2. Who is better, Led Zeppelin or The Rolling Stones
3. Who is the better guitarist, Jimmy Page or Eric Clapton
zxm

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P