Creepiest Moments in MLP

The Top Ten
1 Rainbow Dashes nightmare from "Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?"
2 Pinkie Pie going crazy in "Party Of One"

And thus began the creepypasta of "Cupcakes".

3 Luna's Nightmare from "A Royal Problem"
4 Twilight going crazy in "Lesson Zero"
5 Sweetie Belle's Nightmare in "For Whom The Sweetie Belle Toils"
6 Apple Bloom's Shadow in "Bloom and Gloom"
7 Luna causing a bunch of Spiders to come to life in "Luna Eclipsed"
8 Scootaloo's Nightmare(s) in "Sleepless in Ponyville"
9 Pinkie Pie going through the hallway, while looking for Pound Cake in "Baby Cakes"
10 Apple Bloom's non-apple-cutie-mark Nightmare in "Bloom and Gloom"
The Contenders
11 Everypony's Smile in "The Cutie Map"
12 Starlight's second nightmare from "To Where and Back Again"
13 The balloons laughing at Pinkie Pie in "The Return of Harmony Part 1"
14 A bunch of spiders surrounding Yona in "What Lies Beneath"
15 A bunch of eyes surrounding Fluttershy and the voices laughing at her in "Hurricane Fluttershy"
BAdd New Item