Top Ten Nightmare Animatronics from Five Nights at Freddy's 4


The Top Ten

1 Nightmarionne Nightmarionne

Nightmarionne is basically Nightmare, but way cooler, original, and creepy. He looks very similar to Slender and has the most unique design out of all of the Nightmare characters. He is just simply my favorite of the bunch. - DCfnaf

V 1 Comment
2 Nightmare Nightmare

Nightmare is a character simply wrapped in mystery. Why does he exist? Is he supposed to be a Shadow of Fredbear? And if he is, why is his head simply a giant brain with red eyes? Nightmare is very unique and seems to be the leader of the Nightmare Animatronics. There's only one character I like more though. - DCfnaf

Nightmare is the nightmare version of shadow Freddy, though I'm not sure why he is in the game. Although he is an awesome animatronic!

V 1 Comment
3 Nightmare BB Nightmare BB

Nightmare BB is basically what you call the uncanny valley. The fingers and mouth are CREEPY. He also scares me WAY MORE than Plushtrap ever did! - DCfnaf

4 Nightmare Mangle Nightmare Mangle

Nightmare Mangle's design is WAY COOLER than Nightmare Foxy's. She has wires coming out everywhere and look similar to Foxy but has Mangle's colors. Her jumpscare is also WAY more startling than Foxy's. She is also one of the biggest problems in the game because she causes her static and audio to play when she's in your closet. - DCfnaf

5 Nightmare Foxy Nightmare Foxy

Oh god, Nightmare Foxy is TERRIFYING. Think of a character that is running through the halls constantly trying to get into your closet, JUMPSCARES YOU when you find him in the closet, and has one of the scariest jumpscares in my opinion. Nightmare Foxy is also the nightmare representation of the most popular animatronic so I allowed him in the top 5. - DCfnaf

6 Nightmare Fredbear Nightmare Fredbear

Nightmare Fredbear is considered the boss of the game and basically dominates the rest of the Nightmare animatronics. His attacks are completely unique and he replaces all the other nightmare characters. He also is a big part of the story. The reason he isn't higher is that he never really scared me that much. - DCfnaf

7 Nightmare Chica Nightmare Chica

The reason Nightmare Chica is higher than Nightmare Bonnie is that she has a unique design and somewhat unique attack. She has one eye working and has her Nightmare Cupcake. She can also use it to attack you from behind. - DCfnaf

8 Nightmare Bonnie Nightmare Bonnie

Nightmare Bonnie is kind of basic and was the first animatronic that got his jumpscare teased. Yeah, he's not really all that scary or unique. - DCfnaf

9 Nightmare Freddy Nightmare Freddy

Nightmare Freddy's main attack is your bed where he summons Fredles to attack you. You basically check the bed and see if his Fredles are there trying to call in Freddy himself. He's honestly boring to me and you barely even see him anyway, which doesn't make any sense since this is ultimately HIS GAME. I don't see where on the game it says "Five Nights at Fredbear's". - DCfnaf

10 Plushtrap Plushtrap

Plushtrap doesn't really count as a nightmare animatronic, but I'm counting him anyway. Plushtrap is kind of different from the rest and is only in a minigame. He doesn't really scare me. - DCfnaf

The Contenders

11 Jack O Chica Jack O Chica
12 Jack O Bonnie Jack O Bonnie
13 Nightmare Cupcake
14 Nightmare Pumpkin
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists