Top Ten Best Non-Canon Percy Jackson and Heroes of Olympus Parings

To the person who wrote about why they hate Tratie, and the others who agree with them: THANK YOU! I don't get how this ship came to be. They have ZERO interaction whatsoever throughout Percy Jackson and the Olympians and Heroes of Olympus. I don't think I need to say much about Tratie — I don't understand why ANYONE ships it.

No, just... No.

I am SICK and TIRED of finding so many of these stupid and no-need-to-even-exist stories where these two characters with barely interaction at all are together.

I interpret both of these characters as usually remaining single. I do the same with Connor Stoll. This is a non-canon ship who so many people think is the best thing ever, when it's seriously stupid.

How was this ship formed in the first place? I you don't even know, ten the ship is already pointless.

So, to all of you whining about how it's "meant to be" and that Riordan should just "go ahead and make it canon". Well, I've got something to tell y'all.

It's not canon. It most likely will never be canon.

Get over it.

I wish this was canon...
Uncle Rick! This must become canon. Katie went missing in the hidden oracle. I also don't remember seeing a travis in that book... what if they went to college together!

Tratie was the first ship my ten-year-old discovered after Percabeth and I still love it. I don't care what others say. They have both strong personalities you can tell from the little phrases in the book.

This legit should have happened like OTP. Leo deserves better than a girl who falls for every guy she meets and their cemistry through Mark of Athena was so natural. I have nothing against Frank x Hazel like they are my fave ship in the series (can't think of a better one so yeah...) but like Leo just seems to have better chemistry.

Hazel is 13 and short, Frank is 16 and giant. They are cute but were better as friends. Leo, is a year younger, and a lot smaller. They have different personalities yet a strong connection and complement eachother well. It's a little strange considering the whole Sammy thing but I don't know, I just love this ship so much and jate that it didn't happen.

I was unaware height/size has anything to do with who you can date.

There was a whole chapter featuring their relationship. Their relationship was CANON. See, they were... um, holding hands and staring at each other for hours (giggles at Frank's face), and remember the part in the Mark of Athena where Percy and Annabeth go together in Rome while Hazel, Leo, and Frank go on the Nico-saving quest? Hazel said she needed Leo, and Frank's smile "turned into something more like Chrysaor's mask"
Later Hazel even kissed Leo. Lol

I shipped them so badly. Honestly I don't like frank so I care that Hazel had a boyfriend though Calypso and Leo are super cute

Uh, have you guys even read ToA book 4? because Reyna says, "Everybody was always trying to ship me with somebody. Thalia. Jason. Gwen. Even Frank. Oh you'd be perfect together! That's who you need! But I was never really sure if I wanted that, or if I just felt like I was supposed to want it. People, well-meaning, would be like, Oh you poor thing. You deserve somebody in your life. Date him. Date her. Date whoever. Find you soul mate." If that's not a message from Reyna and Rick Riordan himself, I don't know what is. I mean, Reyna literally says that she doesn't want to be shipped with people, so respect her, and respect what Rick Riordan wrote. They are HIS books after all.

I know that Reyna doesn't like being shipped with anyone, and that she's a Huntress, so she can't date, but this still definitely goes in my top five ships. This probably would've happened if Juno hadn't wiped Jason's memory and sent him to Camp Half-Blood. Jason even felt guilty when he remembered Reyna's name, even though he was dating Piper!

These two actually KNOW each other, unlike Jiper or Jasper.
They've been friends since they were kids. Basically, Roman Percabth.

They're better than Jasper but they said no demigod can heal Reyna's heart.

That would be fun to watch! Athena watching discovery channel, while Poseidon accidently keeps flushing the toilet every time he looks at Athena.

Oh my gods! Can you imagine it!? Poseiden being all awkward and Athena just with no idea of what to do with herself!

Okay, this is like the only non-canon ship I actually like.

I love this ship. After Percabeth, Pothena is my favourite OTP. And there was a time where I equally shipped Pothena and Percabeth.

I like this one more than Nico and Will because Percy and Nico have built a relationship while going on quests together. Plus, they have known each other longer.

By your logic, Grover and Percy make sense because they've known each other for longer than Nico and Percy. Plus, Nico said that he had a very childish crush on Percy, and that he grew out of it.

Haha nope! Solangelo is like the best ship in the whole thing (no offense to the people who ship them)

When Percy finds out Nico had a crush on him it was so OMG. Why could'nt they have ended up together.

As much as I ship Solangelo to the ends of the Earth, this is a pretty cute ship!

Ahem. I personally don't approve of this ship since I love Percabeth and semi-ship Thaluke but you have no right to call him that! You are entitled to your own opinion but please. Don't broadcast it so offensively in public.

Luke is awaome why do for hate him do you expect every character to be as perfect as Percy."All he did was stab himself" I bet u would not stab yourself I would not.

Luke is in evil maniac who relies on a titan to find joy. All he did was stab himself! Percabeth 4 ever

Uhgg how can you even ship this? Luke is like 7 years older than Annabeth. When she was 12, he was 19!

This is probably me just hating Jason but like if he didn't appear or he wasn't Piper's bf in their memories they probs could have ended up together.

Where in tartarous did this come from?

Can’t you just feel the LOVE these two have for each other? Sorry Piper, but... Brason forever!

Get married down in Elysium, you two. (Tear)

This is hands down the best. Although I agree, it should probably be Cason lol.

This is totally the best. Although it should be Cason - Concussion and Jason.

I thought Jason and Piper were already a thing?

I know that this ship is probably at ninth place because it's canon, and this list is for fanon Percy Jackson and the Olympians and Heroes of Olympus ships, but.. HOW IS NOT AT FIRST PLACE?! NINTH?! WHAT?! Percy dropped voluntarily into Tartarus so that Annabeth didn't have to go alone, they both went crazy went the other went missing, etc. For the sake of space, I'll stop here, but I still can't understand why Percabeth is at ninth place. HAVE Y'ALL GONE MAD?!

Percy and Annabeth for the win! These two are a classic ship, and always find their way back to each other, which is why they are so cute together!

The are just the cutest! They are definitely the most in love out of all the demigods in these books! I mean, why aren't they higher up? Percy literally went to Tartarus just for Annabeth. PERCABETH FOREVER!

This is canon, but I had to vote for it because I love Percabeth.

Just gross. I know they're both dark and punk/emo but no. Just no

Yes, it would never work but it's still cute

Love solangelo also Thule but needs is gay people GAY

1: thalia swore never to go out with anyone
2: nicos gay

I shipped them when I first read titan's curse. They'll probably fight a lot as a couple but if they get over it they'll make a cute couple. Probably also the strongest

Heh its just a cute ship. It wouldn't be the most stable of relationships though, but it could work: definitely not the weirdest ship on this list.

Not likely but would definitely be cute since they're always fighting like a couple. Yes, I know they're technically cousins but who cares?

I love this. I don't know why. They'll be cute couple

Here's the thing: they both seem super straight to me. but let's say they weren't, and I wasn't such a huge percabeth shipper (jasper's fine, but whatever). they would have a lot of chemistry

So cute! They complete each other! ( even though I totes ship percebeth) Annabeth said they had a Bromance in MoA!

It's "Two brooos chillin' in the hot tub, five feet apart 'cause they're both straight", but still

This is literally the best brotp in the whole book series.

Crackship of 2019

1: leos straight
2: nicos gay
3: they hate each other

yessss Nico and Will are perfect for each other! Nico is a son of Hades, representing darkness, and Will is a son of Apollo, so "opposites attract" makes these two a cute couple!

Solangelo forever! Everyone else stay away!

It's cannoned, but I don't care, it's adorable.

Canon, but I love them with all of my heart

YAS the best ship ever! Have known each other longer than percabeth

Percy loves his blue food.

The history though lol

Best ship ever.

I thought it was quite well done in book 4. Then Rick had to ruin it in Heroes of Olympus. She should have been that what if that everybody wonders about

I shipped them for like two minutes before I slapped myself...

1) Athena hates Percy
2)Athena hates Percy
3)Do I have to say any more?

This ship is messed up as hell. Just saying'

1: athena hates percy
2: athena swire not to marry

WHAT IN HADES? Percy and ATHENA? Annabeth's mother? I mean, sure, it's a list of non canon ships but an immortal godess plus a teen demigod? JUST NO. IT'S MESSED UP.

might be cute if
1. Octavian wasn't a complete jerk
2. Octavian wasn't dead
3. Rachel was allowed to date
4. Octavian didn't murder poor stuffed animals. I can never forgive him.

I mean if Rachel was aloud to date and Octavian wasn't a jerk(and dead) then I feel like this would be cute.

If Octavian wasn't a jerk they might have worked out.

LOL I have no idea I just ship it

In the books I thought will and nico were going to become friends and will was going to make nico ask Reyna out because he had a crush on her. When nico and will started dating I was a little surprised, but mostly discussed

I SHIP THIS SO MUCH! REYNA AND NICO FOREVER! Reyna deserves so much better than some scumbag like Jason, he sucks. Reyna and Nico deserve each other, this would be such a cute couple if only Nico wasn't a homosexual. Reuna deserves love! #Reynaisthebest!

THey should definitely be a couple

If there is no Solangelo, Reynico would be the most famous

Hate 2 break it 2 u but in TOA two people got kicked out of the Hunters for being gay. Even though it wasn’t specifically mentioned, they swore off romance

In Trials of Apollo, book 4, Reyna literally says that she doesn't like it when people ship her with Thalia. RESPECT REYNA'S FEELINGS.

They are amazing! ( I know hunters can't be in any relationship but still...) They are perfect, They're both strong, independent woman who have been left by a guy ( Luke, Jason/Percy). Also they're cute.

The hunters' rules never say you can't be with a woman...

Actually, the Hunters swear off all romantic relationships, and vow to be maidens forever.

This one is canon, they have been together Juniper was first introduced in Battle of the Labyrinth.

This is also cannoned, but these two need more screen time.

This is canon and cute

Canon but so cute

I think that, given more time to develop (a.k.a. the time period when Thalia was a tree), Thaluke would've made an awesome couple. Another guess of mine about Thaluke is that they became a couple while they were on the run, but Annabeth was just too young to notice. (As far as I know, though, there's no mention of a Thaluke romance in The Demigod Diaries: The Diary of Luke Castellan, so that's a bit off-putting. But I digress.) And let me remind you that Thalia rejected the Hunters because she'd have to leave Luke, and that Luke still cared for Thalia when he joined Kronos' forces.

If Luke didn't do you know what and Thalia didn't "die" then they would have worked out, but he's dead and she's immortal.

Is this already on the list? I don't know

Ship ship shippity ship

It's canon and so cute!

This is canon but I LOVE THEM SO MUCH AS A COUPLE so I just had to

No, just no. First, they are both guys, and guys dating guys, just doesn't work out for me. Second, luke desrves someone more badass, not a hero. Third, I am gonna puke!

You know by the name it won't work out

Well they got he name right.

You know the ship name is LUKERCY and I ship it too much