Top Ten Best Non-Canon Percy Jackson and Heroes of Olympus Parings


The Top Ten

1 Tratie (Travis and Katie)

V true, it won't be made canon - aplayer_8

No, just... No.

I am SICK and TIRED of finding so many of these stupid and no-need-to-even-exist stories where these two characters with barely interaction at all are together.

I interpret both of these characters as usually remaining single. I do the same with Connor Stoll. This is a non-canon ship who so many people think is the best thing ever, when it's seriously stupid.

How was this ship formed in the first place? I you don't even know, ten the ship is already pointless.

So, to all of you whining about how it's "meant to be" and that Riordan should just "go ahead and make it canon". Well, I've got something to tell y'all.

It's not canon. It most likely will never be canon.

Get over it.

Tratie was the first ship my ten-year-old discovered after Percabeth and I still love it. I don't care what others say. They have both strong personalities you can tell from the little phrases in the book.

To whoever wrote the paragraph on why they hate Tratie:
I agree. I agree so much--I'm not crazy! I'm not the only one who hates this glorified crackship!

V 14 Comments
2 Lazel (Leo and Hazel)

I still wish I got to see this as canon

I love it so so much lazel forever

SHOULD HAVE BEEN TOGETHER AND I'M STILL SO UPSET THAT HAZEL'S WITH FRANK ok I'm very passionate about this, calypso doesn't deserve my boy leo and frank doesn't deserve my girl hazel - pjo

There was a whole chapter featuring their relationship. Their relationship was CANON. See, they were... um, holding hands and staring at each other for hours (giggles at Frank's face), and remember the part in the Mark of Athena where Percy and Annabeth go together in Rome while Hazel, Leo, and Frank go on the Nico-saving quest? Hazel said she needed Leo, and Frank's smile "turned into something more like Chrysaor's mask"
Later Hazel even kissed Leo. Lol

V 8 Comments
3 Jeyna (Jason and Reyna)

They can and will only be FRIENDS
Jasper is so much BETTER

Yes. Much better than Jiper or whatever the Hades the ship name is.

I like them as friends, but not as a couple.

They're better than Jasper but they said no demigod can heal Reyna's heart.

V 5 Comments
4 Pothena (Poseidon and Athena)

I love this ship. After Percabeth, Pothena is my favourite OTP. And there was a time where I equally shipped Pothena and Percabeth.

Sounds like it might be cool.

That would be fun to watch! Athena watching discovery channel, while Poseidon accidently keeps flushing the toilet every time he looks at Athena.

--Northstar of Stormlan

V 4 Comments
5 Percico (Percy and Nico)

Haha nope! Solangelo is like the best ship in the whole thing (no offense to the people who ship them)

This one sucks because percabeth and solangelo are way better - aplayer_8

Should've been married

I like this one more than Nico and Will because Percy and Nico have built a relationship while going on quests together. Plus, they have known each other longer.

V 7 Comments
6 Lukebeth (Luke and Annabeth)

Ahem. I personally don't approve of this ship since I love Percabeth and semi-ship Thaluke but you have no right to call him that! You are entitled to your own opinion but please. Don't broadcast it so offensively in public.

Luke is awaome why do for hate him do you expect every character to be as perfect as Percy."All he did was stab himself" I bet u would not stab yourself I would not.

Luke sucks annabeth way to good for him
- Dewstar of Thunderclan

Luke is in evil maniac who relies on a titan to find joy. All he did was stab himself! Percabeth 4 ever

7 Brason (Jason and Brick)

Where'd the brick come from?

This is totally the best. Although it should be Cason - Concussion and Jason. - CalebPro

Why isn't this at the top?!

Perfect. Absolutely perfect.

V 17 Comments
8 Liper (Piper and Leo)

Where in tartarous did this come from?

9 Percabeth (Percy and Annabeth)

It is canon who added this? - aplayer_8

So the besttt

This is the best but its cannon has of Battle of the Labyrinth

Ship it!

V 9 Comments
10 Thalercy (Thalia and Percy)

I shipped them when I first read titan's curse. They'll probably fight a lot as a couple but if they get over it they'll make a cute couple. Probably also the strongest - Oreo_xo

Not likely but would definitely be cute since they're always fighting like a couple. Yes, I know they're technically cousins but who cares?

Heh its just a cute ship. It wouldn't be the most stable of relationships though, but it could work: definitely not the weirdest ship on this list.

I ship it! Sure, they are technically cousins, but remember, the gods don't have DNA, so it wouldn't be an issue. - BronzeWolf2

V 2 Comments

The Contenders

11 Thalico (Thalia and Nico)

No they are siblings basically, that would be disgusting - Camaro6

I like this one even though I KNOW THAT SOME PEOPLE THINK he's GAY BUT WHAT CAN I SAY?

Just gross. I know they're both dark and punk/emo but no. Just no - Oreo_xo

Yes, it would never work but it's still cute - AnnaOfArendelle332

V 3 Comments
12 Nicleo (Nico and Leo)

Crackship of 2019

1: leos straight
2: nicos gay
3: they hate each other

13 Pipabeth (Piper and Annabeth)

Pipabeth is my favorite ship out of the whole Percy Jackson series.

I'm sorry this is my OTP, and also it was never confirmed they were straight, bisexuality is a thing

Their both straight and where in the nane of hades is percabeth?!

14 Jercy (Jason and Percy)

So cute! They complete each other! ( even though I totes ship percebeth) Annabeth said they had a Bromance in MoA!

It's "Two brooos chillin' in the hot tub, five feet apart 'cause they're both straight", but still

Their both straight!

15 Percthena (Percy and Athena)

this sucks - aplayer_8

1) Athena hates Percy
2)Athena hates Percy
3)Do I have to say any more? - Oreo_xo

This ship is messed up as hell. Just saying'

WHAT IN HADES? Percy and ATHENA? Annabeth's mother? I mean, sure, it's a list of non canon ships but an immortal godess plus a teen demigod? JUST NO. IT'S MESSED UP.

V 4 Comments
16 Percalypso (Percy and Calypso)

I shipped them for like two minutes before I slapped myself... - Rye

v true - aplayer_8

17 Solangelo (Nico and Will)

This is canon - aplayer_8

This needs to be higher

Best ship ever

Why is this not #1?

V 5 Comments
18 Reynico (Reyna and Nico)

If there is no Solangelo, Reynico would be the most famous

In the books I thought will and nico were going to become friends and will was going to make nico ask Reyna out because he had a crush on her. When nico and will started dating I was a little surprised, but mostly discussed

Yes I so ship this, they are so cute together! I wish Nico wasn’t gay. - Camaro6

19 Pertemis (Percy and Artemis)

I love it can anyone give me good author for this ff

This ship seems so random, but it’s actually really cute, and the fanfics for it are some of the best. A personal favorite.

How on earth did this even start? - Oreo_xo

I know, I know. impossible. Yet for some reason this is my favorite non-canon ship

V 1 Comment
20 PerBlue (Percy and Blue Food)

Best ship ever.

Great ship! lot better than percabeth! - aplayer_8

YAS the best ship ever! Have known each other longer than percabeth

21 Puke (Percy and Luke)

Puke is right! - Camaro6

Well they got he name right.

LOL Love the name! - Oreo_xo

You know the ship name is LUKERCY and I ship it too much

V 6 Comments
22 Octachel (Octavian and Rachel)

ITs ok, but Octavian dies and all...

LOL I have no idea I just ship it


A lot of people think that people ship this because they’re both oracles/augurs, but I ship it because I feel like Rachel could’ve changed Octavian for the better- that she was the best one for the job.
That’s just my opinion. Feel free to criticize.


23 Peyna (Percy and Reyna)
24 Jercico (Jason, Percy, and Nico)

+ thalia - aplayer_8

Umm ok I guess I do0 sorta ship them

25 Jasery (Jason and Percy)

This is my brotp. I ship it in a bromance kind of way. I used to ship it romantically, but I stopped after I thought, "This is getting weird". So, yeah.

It's also called "Jercy" or "Person", not "Jasery". Who in the gosh diddly heck decided to call it "Jasery"? It doesn't roll off the tongue quite right.

26 Thaluke (Thalia and Luke)

Ship ship shippity ship - aplayer_8

Is this already on the list? I don't know

I ship this 100% - Camaro6

27 Theyna (Reyna and Thalia)

They are amazing! ( I know hunters can't be in any relationship but still...) They are perfect, They're both strong, independent woman who have been left by a guy ( Luke, Jason/Percy). Also they're cute.

They workkk

28 Pazel (Percy and Hazel)

umm - aplayer_8

Why is this even a thing.
Please let this not be canon.
Please let it never be canon.
Just no.

29 Reybeth (Reyna and Annabeth)

Who in the underworld put this on here?

30 Pipeyna (Piper and Reyna)

Interesting ship - aplayer_8

How was this not on here already? Seriously my OTP.

31 Thapollo (Thalia and Apollo)

No longer in ToA - aplayer_8

She did say he was hot - Oreo_xo

Ew that's her brother

Yeah I, know that Thalia is an huntress, but I ship them so much. They're cute together😍😍

32 Ocpipavian (Piper and Octavian)


33 Thluke (Thaloa and Luke)
34 Annaseidon (Annabeth and Poseidon)

WHaT iS tHiS

Why. Just why.

35 Groper (Grover and Percy)
36 Lukethan (Luke and Ethan)

I absolutely LOVE Luke X Ethan! Way better than almost ANY ship on this!

37 Conisse (Clarisse La Rue and Connor Stoll

NOOO! CONNOR IS TOO GOOD FOR HER! NO JUST NO! (Okay, Clarisse is okay, but Connor deserves so much better! )

I ship this so much! I can't find any fics for it, but Clarisse needs a wild edge and Connor needs some sanity.

It's perfect! Nobody ships it... But Clarisse needs her wild edge and... Connor needs some sanity. Otp! (think about it for a while, it'll grow on you.

38 Wilico (Will Solace and Nico)

No offense, guys, but I absolutely DETEST this ship...Reynico is so much better. - Camaro6

Greatest Ship! ♥

This is canon.

... This is canon, though - RizaLovato

V 3 Comments
39 Perachel (Percy and Rachel)

The What If
World not have been mad had this been Canon

I know Percabeth is my OTP but why did no one add this to the list?! I actually shipped them in the battle of the labyrinth because annabeth was falling for Luke too much

40 Reyneo (Reyna and Leo)

Cute! but will never happen - aplayer_8


41 Fraper (Frank and Piper)

Makes sense, children of war and love - aplayer_8

42 Clariseus (Clarisse and Percy)
43 Annataviabeth (Octavian and Annabeth)

I don't really like either of them, so I thought they might be cute together. - Penelope_DOP

44 Hazey (Hazel and Percy)
45 Frannabeth (Frank and Annabeth)

I don't know. I just think that Annabeth would find some way to help Frank through all of his problems, and they wouldn't fight very much, only over stuff like: What is the best marsupial? and What is the best butterfly?

46 Friper (Frank and Piper)

Okay I know it's impossible but just imagine it!

47 Octason (Octavian and Jason)

LOL what

48 Gruniper (Grover and Juniper)

This one is canon, they have been together Juniper was first introduced in Battle of the Labyrinth.

49 Perlia (Percy and Thalia)

They are so cute together, they would fight a lot but I ship it.

50 Tharemis (Thalia and Artemis)

" I know it will never happen but they're cute!

8Load More
PSearch List

Related Lists

Funniest Heroes of Olympus and Percy Jackson Characters Best Trios in the Percy Jackson and the Olympians and Heroes of Olympus Series Hottest Percy Jackson Heroes of Olympus Characters Best Joss Whedon Parings Top Ten Heroes of Olympus Characters

List Stats

500 votes
51 listings
4 years, 107 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Percico (Percy and Nico)
2. Pipabeth (Piper and Annabeth)
3. Jercy (Jason and Percy)
1. Lazel (Leo and Hazel)
2. Pothena (Poseidon and Athena)
3. Tratie (Travis and Katie)
1. Lazel (Leo and Hazel)
2. Tratie (Travis and Katie)
3. Jeyna (Jason and Reyna)

View All 4

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.