Top 10 Most Overhated Post-Movie SpongeBob Episodes

The Top Ten

1 A Pal for Gary

No, this episode gets hate for a good reason. Yes, One Coarse Meal is worse, but this episode still sucks. - DCfnaf

Agree, the episode sucks, but it is way better than people make it out to be - Myname2

2 Pet Sitter Pat

No this one is terrible. How is it funny to watch Patrick abuse a snail? - DCfnaf

At least the ending was sweet. - IcetailofWishClan

3 Good Neighbors

This episode is terrible. Hated it as a kid, hate it now. - DCfnaf

4 Best Day Ever

Yeah, I like this one. - DCfnaf

5 Funny Pants
6 Penny Foolish

Not that bad. - DCfnaf

7 Are You Happy Now?

I find it hard to believe Squidward never had a happy memory. And the suicide was too much, - DCfnaf

Here was one happy moment in two words band geeks

This is actually okay

Dissecting Each Episode on the top 7 of this list.

A Pal for Gary: This episode may not deserve EVERY morsel of hate it gets, but it certainly deserves hate. This episode is abysmal in every sense of the word. Not only is it devoid of comedy, moral, and pleasant imagery, but it manages to make you want to stab the protagonist over and over again. From the carelessness to STEALING, this unlovable sponge drops the quality of this already terrible episode. Not to mention Gary's torture and unjustified punishment. Even if you don't care about that stuff, this episode has nothing left to offer you. Terrible episode through and through.

Pet Sitter Pat: This episode may not be the worst of the worst, but the writing if lackluster at best. However, this is a step up from A Pal for Gary both moral and joke wise. There were a few moments here that I smiled at, and SpongeBob is generally concerned for Gary's health. However, the bad writing shows, when they fall back on the ...more

V 1 Comment
8 Rise and Shine
9 Truth or Square

This one was good, - Goatworlds

10 Shuffleboarding

The Contenders

11 One Coarse Meal One Coarse Meal

It's not really a black and white contrast as many Plankton fans proclaim it to be. It's more like varying shades of gray.

12 Main Drain

Get this to number one. - Goatworlds

13 Ink Lemonade Ink Lemonade

This episode really pisses off the squidward fanbase for all the right reasons.

It's officially my second least favorite episode of the show. - IcetailofWishClan

Never seen it, but I heard it's terrible. - KalloFox34

You mean underhated.

14 A Day Without Tears
15 SpongeBob You're Fired
16 SpongeBob Vs The Big One
17 Pest of the West
18 Gone

Just forget about the ending, I'm just neutral to this episode. - BlueBobYT

19 SpongeHenge
20 Karate Island
21 Demolition Doofus
22 SpongeBob's Atlantis SquarePantis
23 House Fancy House Fancy

Hated and considered worst by many fans for a few seconds, when rest of episode was solid.

BAdd New Item