Top Ten Most Overrated Athletes

The Contenders: Page 7

121 Brooks Robinson

Not arguing his defense - but on offense an average to below average third baseman - OB% low -seldon walked, lifetime Slug %.401 - not worthy of HOF - yes he had some bright postseason spot - really good 1970 - but not the super all around player made out to be - several third basemen overall better numbers

122 Mark Sanchez

His butt fumble was ridiculous. He is a freckle on the butt of quarterbacking. One day, we will look back and say "man, Sanchez was awesome? "

He played for the Jets. That explains why he's overrated.

123 Sachin Tendulkar Sachin Tendulkar Sachin Ramesh Tendulkar is a former Indian cricketer and captain, widely regarded as one of the greatest batsmen of all time.

Your kidding right? Averaging mid 40s in test cricket is good if not great. He averaged like 55. And had over 45 test centuries. People these days...

124 Johnny Unitas Johnny Unitas John Constantine Unitas, nicknamed "Johnny U", or "The Golden Arm", was an American professional football player from the 1950s through the 1970s.

Baltimore colts got lucky to win that one super bowl against Dallas cowboys with johnny unitas as their quarterback.

V 1 Comment
125 Novak Djokovic Novak Djokovic Novak Djokovic is a Serbian professional tennis player who is currently ranked world No.1 in men's singles tennis by the Association of Tennis Professionals.
126 Dion Phaneuf

HORRENDOUS D-MAN! Now making $7,000,000 per season.

127 Tajh Boyd
128 Anna Kournikova Anna Kournikova

She was once voted as one of sports biggest flops or something like that. She should be in the Top 10 though you have to catch people's attention as an athlete before getting voted as an overrated one. She was more like a pinup girl.

She could play tennis, won some doubles titles but her image made her much more famous than her actual game. I'm surprised shes this low.

Unbelievably overrated in every single way. And that attitude of hers. Ugh No thanks.

129 Jack Wilshere Jack Wilshere Jack Andrew Garry Wilshere is an English professional footballer who plays as a midfielder for Bournemouth, on loan from Arsenal, and the England national team.
130 Saku Koivu
131 Zdeno Chara Zdeno Chara Zdeno Chára is a Slovak professional ice hockey defenseman, currently serving as captain of the Boston Bruins of the National Hockey League.
132 Ty Dillon
133 Paul Scholes

Unbelievably overrated by fellow players and fans alike. Not even close to the level of English footballing legends like Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard, yet held in the same regard. Always baffles me totally. If Gerrard had the team that Scholes had round him he'd have won a scary amount more. Just looking at Frank's goals from midfield and also how he is still playing today shows how much better they both were than the slightly above average Paul Scholes. Even looking at individual attributes of the three. There are very few categories which Steven Gerrard does not top and also very few where Paul Scholes does top them.

134 Magic Johnson Magic Johnson Earvin "Magic" Johnson Jr. is a retired American professional basketball player who played point guard for the Los Angeles Lakers of the National Basketball Association for 13 seasons.
135 Phil Kessel
136 O.J. Simpson O.J. Simpson

Out of 11 years in the nfl, OJ had 5 years with 1000 + yard seasons and only 2 seasons with more than 10 touchdowns. You can argue that the league had 14 games a team but if people claim OJ is so good, then why would 2 games even make a difference

137 Tim Howard V 2 Comments
138 Brett Gardner
139 Stone Cold Steve Austin Stone Cold Steve Austin Steve Austin (born Steven James Anderson on December 18, 1964, later Steven James Williams), better known by his ring name "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, is an American actor, media personality, producer, and retired professional wrestler who is signed to a legends contract for WWE. more.
140 Mike Trout Mike Trout Michael Nelson "Mike" Trout, nicknamed The Millville Meteor, is an American professional baseball center fielder for the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim of Major League Baseball.
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Greatest Athletes of All Time Most Overrated Actors and Actresses Most Overrated Rappers of All Time Most Overrated Bands of All Time Most Overrated Video Games

List Stats

5,000 votes
151 listings
11 years, 296 days old

Top Remixes (6)

1. David Beckham
2. LeBron James
3. Eli Manning
1. John Cena
2. LeBron James
3. Tony Romo
1. Stephen Curry
2. Cristiano Ronaldo
3. Russell Wilson

View All 6


In defense of the Babe
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.