Top Ten Most Overrated Creepypastas

There are good creepypastas. Then there are this who steal the attention of the better creepypastas, and do NOT deserve it.

The Top Ten

1 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

Just a serial killer - Pokemonfan10

Way to overrated

This is EVERYWHERE - blackflower

I like Jeff and his story and all, I really do, but for a Creepypasta it's not very scary and is very flawed when you think about it. Still, I like the story all the same and I do think it deserves at least a little credit.

V 5 Comments
2 Sonic.Exe

I Think Is A good One

This is honestly one of the worst creepypastas I have ever read. This story is forced, unoriginal, poorly written, and has cliches up the ass! Worst creepypasta ever and the most overrated pasta ever!

I like the characters but the story is awful and damn overrated

At least make a better story, or else I will make one - BorisRule

V 1 Comment
3 Laughing Jack Laughing Jack

I actually love Laughing Jack! He's my favorite Creepypasta next to Jeff the Killer (although Jeff's story IS flawed). The Origin of Laughing Jack is a bit chilling just as a Creepypasta should be.

4 Sally/Play With Me

This disturbs me. The worst story. Sickening use of a horrible crime

Features rape. Enough said.

5 Clockwork: Your Time Is Up

I still like the story and all, but I gotta say, it's more gore than scary and it's very flawed.

6 Squidwards Suicide

This is most overrated creepypasta and everyone says it's scary but it' not scary.

The use of dead kids is unnecessary.

Not even scary - blackflower

Not that scary and very overrated. Enough said.

V 2 Comments
7 Eyeless Jack Eyeless Jack

Despite me actually liking eyeless jack, it is overrated.

8 Ben Drowned

Don't get me wrong, this pasta is well written and clever, with footage too, but the attention could go to other pastas

Extremely well written and made, and convicing as hell, but also incredibly overrated in my opinion.

9 Nina the Killer

rip off

Of all the Creepypastas I've heard/read so far, this is the only one I don't like. It sounds like a cheap remake of Jeff the Killer, only with a girl as the main character. This one disappointed me. She even has the same catch phrase as Jeff, only with "my prince" added on.

Sonic.EXE himself is my favorite, Nina drools - BorisRule

10 The Slender Man

It's a good story but it gets more attention than it deserves

The Contenders

11 Cupcakes

Just terrible - blackflower

12 The Rake The Rake
13 Pokémon Dead Channel
14 Smile Dog Smile Dog

What’s scary about a chain letter - blackflower

15 Ticci Toby

Many people have usually been commenting that Ticci Toby is one of their favorite Creepypastas,so he is confirmed overrated.If you read "I eat pasta for breakfast,"when Toby is introduced,scroll down the comments and most of them will be people applauding his appearance.


Another case of the internet taking something completely innocent and trying to turn it into something it's not.

17 The Russian Sleep Experiment

Great story, and does bring up dark experiments done Post WW2 Era, but it holds other Experiment Creepypastas back.

BAdd New Item