Top 10 Most Overrated Disney Characters


The Contenders: Page 2

21 Megara - Hercules Megara - Hercules Meg is a heroine from the Disney movie Hercules. Meg is the love interest for, the protagonist, Hercules. Meg sold her soul to Hades for her boyfriend's freedom. However, the (soon to be ex) boyfriend ended up cheating on her. Meg is scared of getting hurt again. However, once she sees how genuine Hercules's more.

I HATE HER She is the most OVERRATED Disney character!

22 Moana - Moana Moana - Moana
23 Maximus - Frozen

Wow, someone was so obviously blinded by their hatred of "Frozen" that they failed to remember which movie Maximus actually came from.

Um, who's Maximus? That sounds like a really awesome name, though. - RockFashionista

Maximus is from Tangled! - EJ0602

24 Bill Cipher - Gravity Falls Bill Cipher - Gravity Falls Bill Cipher is a triangular dream demon formerly existent only in the mindscape who wished to gain access to the real world. He has been running amok in Gravity Falls, Oregon since being summoned by Stanford Pines over thirty years ago. He is known for his mysterious demeanor and sadistic humor. He more.

Bill. The most overrated character in any fandom. - santibros2002


25 Baymax - Big Hero 6 Baymax - Big Hero 6 Baymax is a fictional character, a superhero appearing in American comic books published by Marvel Comics.

No offense but Disney advertises him too much. It's like they expected him to be the most popular character. Just because he's non human! Yes, I know he's the mascot and all but a lot of other Disney movies has had more than one mascot! I feel like Disney is trying to shove him on bh6 fans but if you noticed, a lot of fans tend to like Hiro and Tadashi more, and how much was Tadashi advertised? Disney sometimes advertises Hiro.

I feel like as they were making the movie, they tried to make Hiro everyone's favorite, but in commercials it was nothing but "Baymax this" and "Baymax that". They hardly ever brought up Hiro except if it was something about Baymax despite him being a bit more important to the movie. But they act like Baymax is more important. And they STILL over advertise Baymax.

While Baymax is a great character, I think in advertizement, he's very overrated! - AnnaOfArendelle332

Why is Baymax here?! Baymax is silly, friendly, and helps the people in need.

26 Jim Hawkins - Treasure Planet

Overrated, paired with every male and female just because he's "sexy" and I think that's kind of annoying. And I thought Jack Frost fangirls were that bad.

I see him everywhere these days.


He's about as overrated as Peter Pan. He's every girls fantasy bad boy; he's edgy, he's rebellious, he's sentimental, he has family issues that are only there for five seconds (sorry fans of the movie but it is). At least with Peter Pan he's got charm and likable traits, but Jim, I see none.

Be honest ladies, you only defend the movie just because you think Jim is "sooo hot."

27 Grumpy - Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
28 Lilo - Lilo and Stitch

Not so much everyone thinks everything she does is cute than some of her weird, freaky, and (let's face it) annoying behavior is totally justified by her rough life yet Vanellope gets ridiculed and criticized left and right for her behavior despite HER rough life. And I'm sorry, but Lilo is the more annoying of the two.

Especially the way everyone thinks everything she says or does is cute yet faults Vanellope from "Wreck-It Ralph" for the same things.

29 Genie - Aladdin Genie - Aladdin The Genie is a jinn appearing in the Aladdin franchise from Disney. He is never given a proper name. He was portrayed by Robin Williams in the first film.

Heh! I'm looking at this picture and waiting for his jaw to drop after realizing he's on this list.

He's awesome! He isn't overrated! How is nobody noticing the huge difference between adored and overrated? TAKE HIM OFF!

He doesn't deserve to be on the list, but that picture of him is pretty funny! - BoltMarksman


30 Buzz Lightyear - Toy Story Buzz Lightyear - Toy Story Buzz Lightyear is a fictional character in the Toy Story franchise. He is a toy space ranger hero according to the movies and action figure in the Toy Story franchise.

The arrogant space captain! He should be higher on the list.

31 Simba - The Lion King Simba - The Lion King Simba is a fictional character who appears in Disney's The Lion King franchise. Introduced in Walt Disney Animation's 32nd animated feature film The Lion King (1994), the character subsequently appears in its sequels The Lion King II: Simba's Pride (1998) and The Lion King 1½ (2004).

As a kid he is an obnoxious little twerp and before anyone thinks to themselves "well he has character development" I actually prefer him as a kid as an adult he has no personality and just my opinion but Matthew broaderick's voice isn't sexy (I mean I'm a guy but I don't see what is so sexy about his voice - Gamer4life

I love the Lion King and Simba, but the Lion Guard totally ruined him.

He is a brat, and not a good choice for the role of protagonist at all.

32 Mr Toad - The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad/The Wind In the Willows

I'm glad his "wild ride" no longer exists in Florida. Now if only California would get rid of theirs.

Yeah, he's a drunk car rider how smashed into a delivery trick and gone to HELL! - Maddox121

33 Mulan - Mulan Mulan - Mulan Fa Mulan, a character inspired by an actual historic figure is a character who appears in Walt Disney Pictures' 36th animated feature film Mulan, as well as its sequel Mulan II.

If it weren't for the modern feminists, she would have been long forgotten.

I KNOW she saved China! That doesn't mean I have to worship her like some kind of goddess.

There are plenty of other strong female characters, get over her please!

The country that stole so many American jobs and exports so many poor quality products (2007 toy recall due to excessive amounts of lead, anyone) was not worth saving, so don't anybody be throwing that "she SAVED CHINA" crap around any time someone says this chick is anything but the perfect holy being you all want us to think she is.

V 4 Comments
34 Mater - Cars Mater - Cars Tow Mater, or simply Mater, is a character in Cars and its sequels, Cars 2 and Cars 3 as well as Cars Toons. He is voiced by Larry the Cable Guy and inspired by a 1951 International Harvester tow truck.

Why did this obnoxious sterotype get a spinoff series?

He's Funny In The First Cars(2006)

But He's Not Funny At All In Cars 2(2011)

35 Tiana - The Princess and the Frog Tiana - The Princess and the Frog Princess Tiana of Maldonia is a fictional main character who appears in Walt Disney Pictures' 49th animated feature film The Princess and the Frog.

I don't care what color her skin is. Didn't stop me from just wanting to slap her many times throughout the early part of the movie, and no the ending didn't make me suddenly love her either.

My issue is that she's an annoying workaholic- race has nothing to do with it.

No one should aspire to be a workaholic. So much for her being anything resembling a role model!

No little girls I've seen talk about her, she gets ranted on because the few people who like her for her skin, and she never makes the top 5/10 on a list. It may just be because where I'm searching or my perspective, but I think Tiana is underrated

V 4 Comments
36 Penny Forrester - Bolt

Bad enough that she's played by Miley Cyrus, but now two overly-obsessed fans of hers have created a big shipping/flame war around her.

Oh the only con about her is that she is voiced by miley cyrus. that's pretty much it. could be 2-3 pros about her [shrugs]

37 Judy Hopps - Zootopia Judy Hopps - Zootopia

This rabbit (can't call her a "chick" given her movie's big "be PC or else" message since that's both a not-PC term and not her actual species) is nothing special; Mulan was the first female to defy convention and what society expected of her. And FYI, I do not like Barney, Dora, Adult Party Cartoon, The Fox and the Hound 2 (or any of the Disney Direct-to-Home-Media sequels and prequels), Foodfight, Sausage Party, Sanjay and Craig, post-Elmo Sesame Street, Fanboy and Chum Chum, newer SpongeBob, Calliou or whatever else you all like to accuse people who go against your personal opinions of liking.

If it were not for her movie being overhyped and the furries, she would have been quickly forgotten.

Oh yes, she is ov3rr@ted - VideoGamefan5

Fans only like her because of the dumb WildHopps shipping. :T

Seriously give some more of the underrated characters like Mr. Big some love.

38 Mickey Mouse Mickey Mouse Mickey Mouse is a funny animal cartoon character and the official mascot of The Walt Disney Company. He was created by Walt Disney and Ub Iwerks at the Walt Disney Studios in 1928.

Oh the star of Disney.

39 GoGo - Big Hero 6
40 Lightning McQueen - Cars Lightning McQueen - Cars Lightning McQueen, typically referred to by his surname McQueen, is a anthropomorphic stock car in the animated Pixar film Cars, its sequels Cars 2, Cars 3, and TV shorts known as Cars Toons. V 1 Comment
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Most Overrated Disney Movie Characters Top 10 Most Overrated Animated Disney Characters Top Ten Most Overrated Disney Infinity Characters Most Famous Disney Characters Top 10 Most Overrated Disney Movies

List Stats

300 votes
80 listings
3 years, 197 days old

Top Remixes (13)

1. Stitch - Lilo and Stitch
2. Mulan - Mulan
3. Judy Hopps - Zootopia
1. Elsa - Frozen
2. Rapunzel - Tangled
3. Olaf - Frozen
1. Judy Hopps - Zootopia
2. Stitch - Lilo and Stitch
3. Lilo - Lilo and Stitch

View All 13


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.