Most Overrated Pink Floyd Songs

The Top Ten

1 Comfortably Numb

Amazing song, no doubt. But I really think some of the overshadowed songs like Interstellar Overdrive, The Trial, and Another Brick in the Wall, pt. 1, are better. Why? They just have more appeal to me. I don't understand why people claim this song to be Pink Floyd's best. It's like saying the sky is neon, it's questionable. Overall, I don't think this song is Pink Floyd's best. But I do think it's an amazing song. Whatever, it's just my opinion. - MontyPython

It's the song you show to somebody to tell them what the band is about, that's it basically, it has a brilliant guitar solo but I think David has done better on pretty much every other song.

This list shouldn't exist Pink Floyd has no overrated songs - christangrant

2 Wish You Were Here

This and another brick in the wall are rather an easy listen compared to most Pink Floyd songs, yet the most popular ones. That's why I think they're overrated.

V 1 Comment
3 Shine On You Crazy Diamond

A masterpiece. Never will it be overrated.

Heck no this deserves its praise - christangrant

4 Hey You
5 Breathe
6 Run Like Hell
7 Waiting for the Worms
8 Any Colour You Like
9 Another Brick In The Wall, Pt. 2

This is the closest to a Pink Floyd song being overrated but I still say it deserves its praise just like Pink Floyd themselves because they are the greatest rock band ever - christangrant

Pink Floyd have dozens of fantastic songs, but this just isn't one of them. - PetSounds

The only overrated Pink Floyd song

It's good but not their best

V 1 Comment
10 Sings of Life

The Contenders

11 Goodbye Cruel World
12 Don't Leave Me Now V 1 Comment
13 Money
14 On the Run
15 Another Brick In The Wall, Pt. 3
16 Echoes
17 Cluster One
18 Poles Apart
19 The Trial
20 Mother
BAdd New Item
7129

Recommended Lists

P