Top Ten Most Overrated Pokegirls

Not necessarily bad, but just too many unwanted fans.

The Top Ten

1 Serena Serena Serena has proven to be a kind and polite girl but she can also be openly rebellious towards her mother, Grace. In Kalos, Where Dreams and Adventures Begin!, she refused to wake up when Grace ordered her to, and gave a sassy response to her mother's call to watch the news. This tumultuous relationship more.

@yungstirjoey666 I disagree with Misty being #1. If you take the internet as a whole instead of TheTopTens, then you will noticed that Serena is not hated as much as she is adored. TheTopTens isn't that large of a website compared to places that Serena has a large fanbase like YouTube. Also the main reason why people hate her so much on this site is because you can talk about her without having so much harassment and abuse coming your way when it comes to her.

Now adding Misty into this, I agree she's very overrated. Nostalgia is a huge factor for her popularity. However, she's been gone for over 10 years and the anime is starting to get a lot of fans that started the show around 4-5th gen (Even 6-7th gen) and they do not feel the nostalgic appeal for Misty because of it. Not to mention that a many long time fans have stopped watching the anime a long time ago and don't add much input. Serena, even if her time is up, she's fairly new. She left the show a few months ago. ...more - Rue

She is adorable.

She is the best

I think she's overhated - BorisRule

V 4 Comments
2 Misty Misty

She's so overrated that I can't stand it. She's so weak to electric and grass. Misty is the worst character in the series. - NaruHinaBlaze1

90s = the stupid word genwunners didn't exist it was just big

She is best Pokemon character ever

Misty is the best.,...

V 5 Comments
3 Cynthia Cynthia

I posted a comment about Cynthia on the "Most Overrated Pokemon characters". I explained (and tried to detail) why she is overrated for me. If you don't want to read it, here's the short version : "What a Mary Sue..." - RedLily

4 Whitney
5 Bonnie

What? Bonnie is a best pokemon girls ever! Remove that on this now! - wenkernboys01

Bonnie is really not overrated. If anything, she’s actually underrated. But okay. - TGBBOD

6 Elesa Elesa

She's too skinny and her headphone things make her look like an alien

7 Dawn Dawn Dawn is a character from Nintendo and Game Freak's Pokémon franchise. In the games diamond, pearl, and platinum version she was one of the playable characters you can choose from. She will be an assistant for professor Rowan if you choose her male counterpart, Lucas. more.

Dawn is so cute

8 Skyla Skyla
9 Hilda Hilda

I don't even understand why she is so popular. Rosa is better.
Her fans are bullying Iris just because they wanted their precious Hilda to travel with Ash instead of her. (boo-oo-ooh! ) - RedLily

10 Mallow Mallow

What the hell! Mallow barely gets any love. How can she be overrated? It's...Its...ITS...worse than Serena.

The Contenders

11 Lillie Lillie Lillie is a fictional character introduced in Pokémon Sun and Moon. She serves as one of the player character's allies and traveling companions during the course of the game.


12 May May May is a female companion to Ash in the generation 3 anime. She was also the female character in Ruby, Sapphire, Emerald, Omega Ruby, and Alpha Sapphire. May (anime) debuted in the 275th episode, "Get the Show on the Road!" She was going to be a trainer, but wasn't excited about it. After meeting a more.

Why is May here?
She's way too underrated. Even Iris is gaining a but more fans than her! - yungstirjoey666

13 Iris Iris Iris is from the Pokemon bwhite version & Pokemon black 2 & white. She ether was the gym leader in Opelucid city in white version. She first appeared to aid Bianca, Burgh, and the playable character when Bianca's Munna was stolen, & acted as a bodyguard. In Black 2 & White 2, she was the champion. Iris more.

Who put Iris here?! She is overHATED, not overrated! - RedLily

She is not overrated

14 Fantina Fantina
15 Flannery Flannery
16 Melody
17 Korrina Korrina Korrina is a fictional character in the Pokémon Series as the Shalour City Gym leader in the XY series, in the anime she's a cheerful girl with a explosive personality she has a Lucario who she raised and grew up with from when it was a Riolu, she was later tasked by her grandfather Gurkinn with finding more.
18 Olympia Olympia
19 Maylene Maylene
20 Shauna Shauna
21 Sabrina Sabrina Sabrina is a fictional character in the Pokemon universe as the gym leader of the Saffron City Gym who specializes in psychic type Pokemon.
22 Erika Erika
23 Clair Clair
24 Jasmine Jasmine
25 Gardenia Gardenia
26 Candice Candice
27 Lenora Lenora
28 Roxie Roxie
29 Valerie Valerie
30 Acerola Acerola
31 Bertha Bertha
32 Shauntal Shauntal
33 Caitlin Caitlin
34 Malva Malva

Nope. - RedLily

35 Lusamine Lusamine Lusamine is a fictional character introduced in Pokémon Sun and Moon. She is the head of the Aether Foundation.
36 Delia Delia
37 Bianca Bianca Bianca is a character from Pokemon by gamefreak & Nintendo. She is one of the rivals & a childhood friend of the protagonist in Pokemon black and Pokemon White. She lives in Nuvema Town, and was held back of being a Pokemon trainer because of her overprotective father wouldn't let her be one. Bianca more.
38 Miette
39 Diantha Diantha

Why? Her fandom is super small... - RedLily

BAdd New Item