Top 10 Most Overrated Rock Albums of All Time

CaptainMowzker
DISCLAIMER: I'm not by any means calling these albums terrible, but I think they get WAY MORE attention than necessary. So please don't overreact if your favorite album is on this list.... but I know that overreactions will be inevitable.

The Top Ten

1 Nevermind - Nirvana

Not even the band's best... hell Kurt himself and the rest of Nirvana hated this album for how polished it sounds. - CaptainMowzker

In Utero is better. - Userguy44

2 Back in Black - AC/DC

It's fun catchy rock music... but past that the lyrics are quite average. - CaptainMowzker

3 Abbey Road - The Beatles

The most overrated "rock" album by the world's most overrated "rock" band. Also the Beatles are more of a boyband than a Rock band if anything... hence when I used quotation marks. - CaptainMowzker

Lol. Sorry. You seem to have a very limited and misconceived understanding of the history of The Beatles and rock music. It's valid that for a bit they were presented and introduced to the mainstream public as something similar to the more modern "boy bands" but they were already accomplished musicians, and they continued to grow as pioneering songwriters, composers and recording innovators, yet they also had previously established themselves in clubs as a raw rock band. The initial marketing was more of a pretense initiated by what record companies and radio stations wanted. It was a means of securing a contract and breaking into the industry. They then led the drastic influx of rock's popularity, paving the way for others who were both inspirers by them and reaped benefits of their breakthroughs. What's overrated is your personal dislike and preferences - the existence of a minority opinion does not make the vast majority opinion "overrated". - Billyv

Personally I think "Let it Be" is worse, but this is definitely overrated. - truckturner

I miss some Led Zeppelin albums on this list, especially their first 2-3 albums that had many rip offs but the albums are viewed like the Second Coming. - Metal_Treasure

They r clearly a pop band and not a rock band

V 3 Comments
4 War Pigs - Black Sabbath

I agree. Paranoid has to be the most overrated metal-related album (by the way, the album title is Paranoid and not War Pigs).
And yes, I said metal-related album and not a metal album. Because there's no single metal song on this album. The title track isn't a metal song but many believe it's the best metal song of all time (proves how overrated it is). War Pigs isn't a metal song, either, and so on.
Also, many claim this album started metal. What?! If anything, their debut album that came out before Paranoid at least had one doom metal song on it - Black Sabbath. Was doom metal the birth of metal? Not sure, but at least the debut album had a song from a genre that is still considered metal - doom metal. - Metal_Treasure

Overrated?
This is joke.
Paranoid was milestone of guitar music.

It gets praised like it's one of the best things to happen to music...and well that's a bit of a stretch. - CaptainMowzker

I love this album, but Master of Reality is way better.

P.S. The album’s title is Paranoid, not War Pigs.

5 Hybrid Theory - Linkin Park

This album isn't Linkin Park's best... and in general hasn't aged well at all. - CaptainMowzker

Meteora is better - Userguy44

In my opinion it is the best LP album.In fact it's my favourite album but I respect your opinion. - DarkBoi-X

6 The Black Album - Metallica

One of the most overrated and overplayed metal records of all time. Not bad, but compared to their first 4 albums and most other albums from metal bands released around the same time as this (Rust in Peace, Cowboys From Hell, etc), it kind of feels inferior, especially with the more simplified radio-friendly sound of the album. Still better than what we got in 2003 and 2011 respectively and unlike some people, I think MoP deserves the hype it gets - IronFist13

Yup. - Userguy44

7 Revolver - The Beatles
8 The Stage - Avenged Sevenfold

One of the most overrated modern rock albums in existence... and in general the hype it gets is pretty annoying just like the hype for A7X itself... - CaptainMowzker

9 Led Zeppelin IV (Aka Zoso) - Led Zeppelin

Not a terrible album by any means, just ridiculously overrated. - Joeljohns249

10 Meteora - Linkin Park

Not as overrated as Hybrid Theory... but still pretty up there. - CaptainMowzker

The Contenders

11 Hysteria - Def Leppard
12 The Wall - Pink Floyd
13 Master of Puppets - Metallica

Not a bad album, but in general I think they've done better than this especially with the two albums that came before it. - CaptainMowzker

Not a bad album but not Metallica's best. - Userguy44

Unpopular opinion, Master of Puppets isn’t a good song as much as people claim for it to be - Not_A_Weeaboo

14 Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - The Beatles

I will probably get hate for adding this, but I personally think it's highly overrated. - TheHabsFan

15 A Night at the Opera - Queen

The movie's release has caused another massive does of this being overplayed.

16 All the Right Reasons - Nickelback
17 Dookie - Green Day

More overrated than American Idiot and again while not being a bad album... is fair from their best. - CaptainMowzker

18 American Idiot - Green Day

I like this album but admittedly it's kinda overrated. - CaptainMowzker

19 Elephant - The White Stripes
20 Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd

Highly perceived as the "greatest album of all time," yet I personally don't really see it. It's a good album, no doubt, but I've found myself more interested in a number of other Pink Floyd albums: Meddle, Atom Heart Mother, and Animals for example.

I think it deserved its praise. - Userguy44

21 Girls Girls Girls - Motley Crue
22 The Bends - Radiohead
23 1984 - Van Halen
24 Crush - Bon Jovi
25 ... and Justice for All - Metallica
26 Ok Computer - Radiohead
27 In Rainbows - Radiohead
28 Am - Arctic Monkeys
29 Is This It - The Strokes
30 Twin Fantasy - Car Seat Headrest
31 Teens of Denial - Car Seat Headrest
32 Teens of Style - Car Seat Headrest
33 My Back is Killing Me Baby - Car Seat Headrest
34 Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino - Arctic Monkeys
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top Ten Most Recognizable / Well Known Rock Album Covers Most Important Albums in Rock History Top 10 Most Underrated Albums from Great Rock and Metal Bands Most Underrated Rock Albums Top Ten Most Underrated Hard Rock Albums

List Stats

34 listings
77 days old

Top Remixes (6)

1. War Pigs - Black Sabbath
2. Abbey Road - The Beatles
3. The Stage - Avenged Sevenfold
Metal_Treasure
1. Nevermind - Nirvana
2. Back in Black - AC/DC
3. The Black Album - Metallica
IronFist13
1. Nevermind - Nirvana
2. Revolver - The Beatles
3. Back in Black - AC/DC
iliekpiez

WRemix
View All 6

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P