Most Overrated Sonic Games

The Top Ten

1 Sonic Adventure 2

Best Sonic game ever? Ha! Yeah right. SA1 was awesome and deserves all the love it gets. This game is only okay at best for me. After all, I only like the speed stages (minus crazy gadget) and two mech shooting stages. That's not even half the game! Sure it has the best 3D multiplayer in the battle port but I think the Genesis and Sonic 4 games have better multiplayer. Not to mention the inconsistent story, crappy camera, mad space, meteor herd and crazy gadget being stages I loathe, I dislike this game. I respect you opinion if you like the game, but I'm not as nostalgia blinded or community blinded as I once was. At best, part of the game is fun making it an okay, somewhat solid game but at worst, the game is so poorly designed it blows.

Best Sonic game ever? Not a chance! In fact, I think this game is still overrated because people try to say that more than 1/3 of this game is good (but they fail miserably at it)! I applaud the extremely high replay value (actually, this game has too much replay value for its own good. 180 EMBLEMS THAT REQUIRE EVERY A RANK?! That's too crazy, especially in the case of Treasure Hunting and Hard Mode stages!) and improved graphics and voice acting, but other than that, everything else just takes a step backwards (treasure hunting was hit insanely hard with a nerfed radar and a nerfed hint system that was an exact equivalent of having NO hint system if you don't know the level design. Shooting stages were hit pretty hard to with linear level design not built around very clunky controls.), even the speed stages (to those of you who think Adventure 1's sonic stages were already linear, Speed Highway says hello, along with 7 other stages. That said, Adventure 2's speed stages are mostly ...more

Thing is though, SA1 had Big the Cat, horrible lip sinking, god awful voice acting, and the camera was probably a bigger enemy then Eggman's robots and Chaos combined. I'd say the adventure series as a whole was bad and super overrated. I respect your opinion if you like either two, but nostalgia is definitely a huge factor for why these games are loved. If they came out today, I'm pretty sure it would get bashed harder than Sonic 06 and Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric.

'The greatest sonic game of all time'

Then explain the dated graphics, horrible camera, flawed controls, bad soundmixing (good music though), hilarious voice acting and a story that even twilight would laugh at.

For me is it a 5/10

V 7 Comments
2 Sonic Colours

I do love this game but I think it gets WAY too much attention because of the wisps I mean sure they're good but it's not speedy which is what sonic unleashed was and people say that this game brought sonic back to fame but I think unleashed did that.

I'm sorry, but I don't like this game at all. There's far too much 2.5D, which isn't very impressive. There's barely any 3D, which means you can't really explore the vibrant landscapes. And the voice acting is really annoying too, although Roger Craig Smith definitely improved since this game.

"Sonic Colours" is definitely overrated!
I strongly prefer "Mario Colours".

Not better than Sonic Unleashed or Sonic Generations. While I think this game is good, it's extremely overrated by fans and critics. The game's plot is dull, Roger's Sonic sounds awful, the writing is the worst a Sonic game has ever got, wisps are just a stupid gimmick, and 80% of this game is 2D block platforming, that you would expect from an NES game! Also, in the first act of a stage, there is probably some 3D segments but most of the other acts are just generic forced block platforming. The game's soundtrack is awesome though.

V 3 Comments
3 Sonic CD

Well This Game is Good. But I Think The Award For The Best Sonic Game Ever is Getting Replaced Because Due To The Level Design, Generic Boss Battles and The Overrated JAP/EUP Soundtracks. As For The US Version: it is Very Underrated. Anyways Sonic CD is Good, But Not That Good and No It is Not The Best Sonic Game Ever.

This is great it might not be the best sonic game but its good even if the Japanese and europa versions were different also metal sonic first appearince

V 1 Comment
4 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle
5 Sonic Adventure DX
6 Sonic Generations

Good but WAY OVERRATED The 2D Modern Sonic sections are HORRENDOUS Classic Sonic stages were okay and about half of the Modern Sonic were AWESOME and the other half were either okay or RETARDED And Sonic Colors and Unleashed were FAR Superior to this and even the Adventure games were better

WHAT SONIC GENERATIONS IS OVERRATED AS SA2 BO... Gunshot.Yes I Know This Game is Great and All. But All The Problems Are: Only 9 Stages, 6 Bosses and The Final Boss is BullShit. Anyways, This is Not Bad, But I Think Sonic Colors is Way Better Than This.

7 Sonic Adventure

How dare this be top 12. Some considered Sonic Adventure to be the best Sonic game (or so one of the best) so thus Sonic Adventure should be top 1.

It's a bit overrated but still AN EPIC START TO SONIC'S 3D GAMES

This list has Sonic games that are not even overrated, people are just dumping random games on here.

Sonic Adventure should be ripped off by Pac-Man Adventure.

Like this game but I agree.

8 Sonic the Hedgehog 2

Old is great for a video game! Also, this game is great!

I know They Are Both Great Genesis Games. But They Are Getting A Little Too Old Really Fast (At Least There Are Still Fun Classic)

No, it's underrated. This game is getting more and more hate due to Sonic Adventure series.

Horrible difficulty balancing, horrible special stages, no save feature, boring boss fights, and too many horribly placed enemies and hazards

9 Sonic Riders
10 Sonic and the Secret Rings

Wait what? OVERRATED? Yeah, this game actually got good reviews from critics. Believe it or not IGN said it was better than Sonic Adventure 2 Battle.
So a game with fidgety controls and level designs that might as well be train tracks is better than Sonic Adventure 2 Battle? Seriously?

This game shall be replaced by "Pac-Man & the Secret Rings".

I strongly prefer "Mario & the Secret Rings".

I like megaman and the secret rings

V 2 Comments

The Contenders

11 Sonic and the Black Knight

I PUT SONIC & THE BLACK KNIGHT ON THE LIST TWICE! Just because I find Sonic & the Black Knight to be one of the most overrated Sonic games doesn't mean I do not need to check whether I already have Sonic & the Black Knight on the list or not. And I have this game on the list! People only love Sonic & the Black Knight because of the aspects of Modern Sonic games (especially Modern Amy Rose, who has accused Sonic for forgetting her date WHICH SHE DAMN WELL DESERVED! All of the members of Team Sonic need way more love than Amy Rose, and so do many other hyper-strong characters like Blaze the Cat and Team Dark). - The Ultimate Daredevil of North America (aka Kieran Stark).

12 Sonic R

Everyone and their grandma hates this game, so I don't think this game is overrated

13 Sonic Unleashed

This game was never supposed to exist anyways. Besides, Pac-Man Unleashed would be much better.

Yeah, pacman would obviously be amazing as a were whatever pacman is. I was being sarcastic by the way

Do people seriously count werehog stages appropriate for a Sonic game?!

OVERRATED! THIS GAME GETS MORE HATE THAN PRAISE, HATE IT DOESN'T DESERVE! "Oh, but Sonic is a wolf, which is different, and it is so not Sonic.". SO WHAT?! THE WOLFHOG WAS THE BEST PART OF UNLEASHED ASIDE FROM THE FINAL FIGHT AGAINST DARK GAIA (I'm talking about the HD version by the way). "It's not as fast as the hedgehog.". WELL I DON'T CARE! SONIC IS NOT ALL ABOUT SPEED, HE IS A PLATFORMER! ARE YOU REALLY GOING WITH THE "It's different from other Sonic games" EXCUSE? IGNORANT HYPOCRITICAL FOOL!

14 Sonic Adventure DX: Director's Cut

I've never even heard of this. - RalphBob

The whole Sonic Adventure series sucks major balls anyways.

15 Sonic Rush

I Have NO Idea How Everyone Likes This...

BORING LEVEL DESIGN, NOT A TON OF REPLAY VALUE, And A Bad Soundtrack... Please do me a favor, and play sonic rush adventure.

This should be top 1, not a Classic Sonic game!

Seriously, Modern Sonic is overrated & Classic Sonic is overrated!

Levels sucked, music sucked, story sucked, Sonic's slow even whioe boosting, Sonic Rush Adventure for the win!

Agreed! Sonic Rush was too hard for me! And Sonic should just die!

Screw 2-D Sonic anyways.

16 Sonic Advance 3

Even though the Sonic Advance trilogy one of the Modern Sonic games that are literally great, please see Cris Dude's "Top 5 Overrated Sonic Games" for proof. I can actually have a lot of fun with being pressured to get all the much Chao there is during the gameplay.

17 Sonic the Hedgehog (2006)

I bet the reason why Sonic '06 gets its wild fanbase is how Amy Rose and Pricness Elise III are portrayed! Why are people sexist?! These HIDEOUS aspects never make a game.

It's sad that my comments get thumbed down whenever I say that a Nintendo/Sonic game in the 1990s in much better than this. :(

18 Sonic Dash

I forgot to add Sonic Dash to the list. The graphics are rather run-of-the-mill. There are very little music tracks. There is no story. Modern Amy Rose is in this game. The gameplay is retro/arcade-style but rather repetitive and pressuring. I give Sonic Dash a 5/10.

19 Sonic Spinball

More like "underrated". This game is perfect with graphics, music, nostalgia cause, adaptions, being a Classic Era game, the worlds & etc..

This should be top 1! Seriously, I don't want to get this awful game again! Why do people prefer Modern Sonic over Classic Sonic?!

20 Sonic Advance Trilogy

Really, dude?! The Sonic Advance games/trilogy is already on this list! I would put the Sonic Advance trilogy on my list of "Top 15 Greatest Sonic the Hedgehog Games" like Nathaniel Bandy did on his video that was not his list of best Sonic games. - The Ultimate Daredevil, who gives the Sonic Advance trilogy a 4/5

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Greatest Sonic The Hedgehog Games Most Overrated Video Games Most Overrated Video Games of 2013 Top 10 Video Games, Movies and Shows That Are Greatly Overrated Due to Their Nostalgia Factors Most Underrated Sonic Games

List StatsUpdated 28 May 2017

100 votes
41 listings
3 years, 215 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Sonic Adventure DX: Director's Cut
2. Sonic CD
3. Sonic Unleashed
1. Sonic Adventure 2
2. Sonic R
3. Sonic Generations
1. Sonic Adventure 2 Battle
2. Sonic Adventure DX
3. Sonic Adventure 2

View All 4


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.