Top 10 Most Overrated South Park Characters

South Park characters that get too much attention. These characters aren't bad but they do overshadow over South Park characters.

The Top Ten

1 Randy Marsh Randy Marsh

The 2nd most overrated South Park character in all of existence.

Is being a unfunny abusive father funny just kill him off

I’ve always hated this guy. I don’t get why people like him so much. - MegaSoulhero

2 Eric Cartman Eric Cartman Eric Theodore Cartman is one of the main characters in the animated television series South Park, created by Matt Stone and Trey Parker, and voiced by Trey Parker.

Eric does everything. Who should take over for a cop that can't read? Why not a 4th grader, Eric? Someone should be a NASCAR driver. Why not a 4th grader, Eric? Someone needs to be mentally retarted. Why not a 4th grader, Eric?

He's decent but not the best character in the show.

He's overrated but funny.

3 Butters Stotch Butters Stotch Leopold "Butters" Stotch is a fictional character in the animated television series South Park. He is voiced by series co-creator Matt Stone and loosely based on co-producer Eric Stough.

There was a time where he was underrated but like Luigi he quickly became overrated.

4 Timmy Burch Timmy Burch

One of the most overrated South Park characters definitely top 5 worthy.

5 Mr. Garrison Mr. Garrison Herbert Garrison is a recurring character in the American animated television series South Park. He is voiced by Trey Parker.

Funny but gets more attention then needed.

i'm GAY!

6 Jimmy Valmer

He's somewhat overrated.

7 Mr. Mackey Mr. Mackey

No he is not mkay?

Mr. Mackey is kind of overratedd m'kay?

8 Ike Broflovski Ike Broflovski

I don't think a explanation is needed.

9 Tweek

Overrated to a extent.

10 Kenny McCormick Kenny McCormick Kenneth "Kenny" McCormick is a main character in the animated adult television series South Park, along with his friends Stan Marsh, Kyle Broflovski, and Eric Cartman.

The Contenders

11 Towelie Towelie

Not as overrated as other characters.

12 Tweek Tweak
13 Karen McCormick

Adorable, but overrated

14 Satan
15 Stan Marsh Stan Marsh
16 Token Black
17 Kyle Broflovski Kyle Broflovski
18 Craig Tucker Craig Tucker
BAdd New Item