Most Overrated Survivor Contestants

Some contestants in the 26 seasons of Survivor have gotten a lot more credit than they deserve. Winners and losers aside, here are the most overrated contestants of all of Survivor.

The Contenders: Page 2

21 David Wright - Survivor Millennials vs Gen X

Unlike everyone else in that season, he actually knew what he was doing to get far in the game. - naFrovivuS

He got by on luck. So overrated and wasn't that good at the game.

22 Zeke Smith - Game Changers

Zeke is transgender, fine. We don't need a whole segment at the reunion dedicated to this horrible player. - naFrovivuS

23 Randy Bailey - Gabon and Heroes vs Villains.
24 Sarah Lacina - Cagayan
25 Kim Spradin - One World Kim Spradin - One World

R/survivor practically worships her - NicholasYellow

26 John Cochran - Caramoan John Cochran - Caramoan John Martin Cochran, commonly referred to as simply Cochran, is an American reality television personality and television writer.

Was Dawn's puppet the entire time on Caramoan.

Cockyran was considered a hero due to backstabbing his entire tribe who saved him twice so he could make the merge. Afterwards he barely put up an argument before getting voted out and easily eliminated by Ozzy the next day. In Caramoan, Cochran acted as Dawn's puppet and only chose the elimination of Eddie throughout the entire game. He went out of his way to insult Julia, Philip, Eddie, Michael, Malcolm, Corinne, Sherri, Erik Dawn and Brandon while blabbering about his "challenge beastliness. " It would be easier to like him if he weren't so arrogant and self-righteous.

27 Benjamin "Coach" Wade - Tocantins

Coach lived up to none of what he said he was going to do. His lies and schemes (as well as arrogance) prove he is incapable of ever winning Survivor.

28 Rupert Boneham - Pearl Islands Rupert Boneham - Pearl Islands Rupert Boneham is an American mentor for troubled teens, who became known to reality television audiences in 2003 as a contestant on Survivor: Pearl Islands where he placed 8th.

Why do people think he played a great game? He didn't do anything! I know a lot of people like his personality, but in all 4 seasons, he had no strategy whatsoever.

He's only well liked due to good editing. Most contestants can't stand him, and say he's obnoxious and bad tempered. He has no strategy and he's easily one of the ugliest players

He's a pretty bad strategist who has annoyed all the contestants every season he's played on. He also has a huge ego.

I guess the editors feeding onto his image in Pearl Islands made him have this enormous ego he has today

V 1 Comment
29 Todd Herzog - China
30 Chet Welch - Micronesia
31 Colby Donaldson - Heroes vs Villains Colby Donaldson - Heroes vs Villains
32 Jessica Sugar Kiper - Gabon and Heroes vs Villains
33 Debbie Wanner - Kaoh Rong
34 Bret LaBelle - Millennials vs. Gen X

People actually like this douche? He badmouthed all his rivals (TO THEIR FACES), only talked about himself to others, and lacked in any strength in challenges. He said to his allies, "If I end up in a final three with [David], I ain't winning." Pure arrogance and was only thinking about himself and getting out David for 37 days. - naFrovivuS

BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Most Overrated American Idol Contestants Top 10 Sexiest Male Survivor Contestants Best Survivor: Millennials vs Gen x Contestants Top Ten Survivor Cagayon Contestants Best Survivor: San Juan del Sur Contestants

List Stats

200 votes
35 listings
4 years, 253 days old

Top Remixes

1. Sandra Diaz-Twine - Pearl Islands
2. Russell Hantz - Samoa
3. Amber Brkich - Australian Outback
1. Parvati Shallow - Pearl Islands
2. Amber Brkich - Australian Outback
3. Chelsea Meissner - One World



Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.