Most Overrated Warrior CatsAnonymousChick
The Top Ten
I love scourge he was underestimate by his family which sucks. I really wish he wouldn't have died just to see what would have happened. I also think the Erin's could have made scourges death better but that is just my opinion
This guy is easily the most overrated cat ever!
Definitely should be #1, but he's slowly becoming less overrated as time goes on though.
Scrooge is my 7th favorite cat ok he’s overrated I know that but I love how he killed Tigerstar - FoxylovescatsV 11 Comments
Firestar my father my name Squirrelflight and why must it be that my father is overrated. He was a hero, he saved the clans mabye like 5 times and he also saved Sandstorm. Thanks dad you even killed Tigerstar for the last time but you might know what happened he died. Yes he died. Firestar is in the spotlight and he is my father and if you guys HATE him you guys are crazy no offense.
Well, overrated means he gets too much attention, so it's not crazy to think that he's not overrated. - RedTheGremlin
His character grew unrealistic for me. People project everything ideal onto this one character, making him idolized despite his lack of true personality. - keycha1n
At first, I liked his charecter. But then it got so annoying after he becomes deputy, and it started to just get boring. He doesn't have a personality, any problems, anything relatable about him. It's just a bunch of boring crap in a bag. - Terra623
Way to overrated and is a gary sueV 8 Comments
How Ivypool felt was NOT Dovewing's fault! She was just trying to be better than Dovewing! Can people really relate to being whiny and trying to be better than someone else? How the heck is she relatable to so many people? Unless, you call yourself a whiny bratty jerk, I don't really think you can relate to her. Dovewing tried to pay attention to her. But, Lionblaze and Jayfeather dragged her away every second. I just hate Ivypool. She is one of the only reasons that Dovewing is hated so much. Dovewing is not a Mary Sue and Ivypool is very overrated!
Dovewing only has two toms that has a crush on her (still don't know what they see in a bland gray she-cat.) But she isn't really overrated. She gets a lot of hate because she's Dovewing.
Ivypool spied Dark Forest. That is a very good thing. But she was very jealous and mean. And she was always blamed others. I know she is a good character. But she is very overrated.
I agree,V 4 Comments
Not every cat who becomes leader is overrated. Not cool.
Come on, I can't be the only one who isn't 100% okay with his ambitious nature? No I'm not, even Kate hasn't forgiven him for 'Stealing Graystripe's deputyship' and feels apalled by his ambition. I'm still not sure if Yellowfang's life was really worth his
He's Not The Worst But Eh He's Just Trash Like His Personality I don't know Its Hard To Explain But he's Just SO ANNOYING xDD #TigerStarClones
He’s just really bland, and forgettableV 2 Comments
I personally think lionblaze is boring and Hollyleaf and jayfeather and dovewing and ivypool are much more interesting and I'd rather spend time with them - money_face
Excuse me?! Lionblaze is likely the most UNDERRATED of the three. Look- people love Hollyleaf because she's a rule follower and is sassy. She's probably the most favored of the litter, alongside Jayfeather, who is loved for being grumpy. Even Dovewing is more liked than Lionblaze. He deserves more love. ~Rocky
I wish hollyleaf had his powar ;-;
Hollyleaf is my least favorite cat. She's a big hypocrite who should've went to the Dark Forest for murder. Her reasons for killing aren't much different than Ashfur if you think about it.
Lionblaze's power wouldn't suit Hollyleaf's personality. - RisingMoon
Honestly Lionblaze thinks he so cool he’s like Mr.perfect
He’s all like “OOooOooh look at me I’m in the power three OH” now I see why Jayfeather is grumpy and holly leaf is social
She was badly written and gets way too much love for what she is. She ruined Graystripe's character and turned him into a prideful jerk over Feathertail and Stormfur. And nobody bothers to point anything out about her?
I swear she has a million fangirls, it's disgusting! She was literally alive for two books. "BUT SILVERSTREAM IS BEAUTIFUL SHES IN MY OTP AND SHES PERFECT BUT SHES NOT A MARY-SUE! " <--Someone is going to say that...
People worship her a gray a non realistic non developed couple but hate on Millie and gray a realistic kind developed relationship. Honestly when she died I went to the warriors fan page and said Erin hunter was amazing
Gray X Silver is overrated. It's all just based on nostalgia. Newer couples, like Dovewing & Tigerheart *squeals that's my OTP* are better. - RisingMoonV 8 Comments
Such a foxdung person! When Ivypool tried to get her to realize that the Dark Forest was bad, she was just like, I don't care because I just want my mother to pay attention to ME instead of my sister. Her whole story being evolved around the fact that Briarlight needs more attention than her is so annoying! Honestly, I'd like her if she would let go of that stupid envious thought, and just try to be HERSELF to get attention. (Suggestion for Erin Hunter.)
She is written in such a way that makes you connect to her. She has an amazingly sappy story and is last place in the pecking order
Blossomfall is a whiny cat who would kill her sister if she could. I'd throw a party if she dies. - Stormyblaze
She's a selfish piece of foxdung.V 1 Comment
It's ironic how the two most common complaints about her are "mary-sue" and "drama queen" when those two traits do not make sense together
Just the typical tragic leader who plunges into insanity. She was okay before the breakdown, but I thought she was still overrated. - RedTheGremlin
I honestly don't see how she's a drama queen. She went through a lot. Her father never cared for her, her mother died, her sister died, being forced by Starclan to give up her kits to become leader, Mosskit's death, etc. I can see how she would think Starclan abandoned her. After all she did to become leader, her own deputy betrays her. - RisingMoon
GOD I HATE THIS OVERRATED CAT! She has no right to be said to have “gone through a lot.” She is just a stupid drama queen! Let me go over some stupid reasons people feel so much pity for her:
“Oh Stormtail didn’t love Bluestar or her mother! ”
Too bad. Crookedstar’s mother abused him and said things to his face. She also made sure to make him be named “Crookedkit”.
“Oh Bluestar’s kit died and then she had to give her other kits up.”
First of all, kiT. One kit. Other cats have had many kits die. Second of all, it was Bluestar’s choice to give up her kits, and also her choice to have kits in the first place. She didn’t have to.
“She had to deal with Thisleclaw! ”
Thisleclaw was never bad, at least in the super edition. Bluestar just had too much ambition and wanted to be leader.
Many cats have bad parents, and just because Crookedstar when through the torture doesn't mean Bluestar should've too. No cat should have bad parents.
Bluestar had to give her kits up to save her Clan. Couples in the series don't really seem to have a choice in whether or not they have kits. Kits always appear unexpectedly.
Bluestar literally saw a vision of his fur stained with blood. He is bad! It caused her a lot of pain to give up her kits, and she wouldn't have if Thistleclaw couldn't have been deputy. Thistleclaw manipulated Spottedleaf and trained in the Dark Forest. He is part of the Dark Forest! - RisingMoon
I hate how people tried to defend him. He attacked a pregnant queen and a blind medicine cat. - Stormyblaze
I know! He had a crappy father. Well, Crookedstar had a crappy mother. He wasn't evil. - Emberleap
The Dark Forest led Breezepelt to think that. Crowfeather does show hints of affection and care for Breezepelt, but Breezepelt gets jealous when Lionblaze also gets noticed. - RisingMoon
I hate how everyone claims that he's bad because he had a bad father. Well, as Emberleap said in her reply, Crookedstar had a bad mother (which was worse, given that she's the one who was supposed to nurse him) and he was one of the best cats the series has ever seen. - RedTheGremlin
Okay I personally like Breezepelt, I think that it's Crowfeather's fault for not raising Breezepelt like a proper dad (I still like Crowfeather though he's one of my favorites). I wouldn't call him 'overrated', though.V 2 Comments
Moonflower is such a jerk! She picks fights with apprentices as a warrior, she HATES her brother, and hangs out with Stormtail. OH BUT SHE'S SO NICE I HATE HAWKHEART BLAH BLAH BLAH!
It was love at first sight with Stormtail and she was literally a kit when Stormtail was a warrior, this cat is so so stupid, and then Stormtail realized she should be on this list and started hanging out with Dappletail. Boo Moonflower, your name is even overrated we all know we can't have the prefix Moon!
(I'm saying this to the one below me) Shut up, u don't judge the mother of Bluestar. Say that to your mom
She's overrated and was literally alive for just ONE book! Then her "ghost" shows up everywhere, and the book talks about her "sweet scent" which I find bizarre and a tidbit creepy. Also, everyone LOVES her...for what? What did she do (when she was alive) that was so significant? Seriously? Characters like Whitestorm never get the love they deserve compared to this do-nothing character. - RedTheGremlin
But when she was dead, she guided Firestar and in the end died for Sandstorm and Firestar. - RisingMoon
I get that she is pretty heroic in the final battle against the Dark Forest but other than that she lacks character and since she was only alive for such a short time there was no development made. She has only ever been described as kind and sweet which makes her just plain boring.
Yeah, she is pretty overrated.
I have mixed feelings on her - money_faceV 2 Comments
I like her but I also think she has some bad qualities and they're trying to hard to make her not a marry sue at times but it backfires horrendously - money_face
Leafpool is my favorite character. Why would you hate her? - RisingMoon
Leafpool is SOOO annoying.
UghV 2 Comments
Most. Overrated. Cat. Ever. HE'S SUCH A JERK! - FernmistCloverleaf
Loads of people love him
Jayfeather is sooo overrated. Really, why do so many fans have a CRUSH ON A FICTIONAL CAT? - Talljake
Jayfeather is awesome, yet I can't deny it. He's so damn overrated he puts Scourge to shame. I mean, half of this fandom worship him, and the childish ones have a crush on him! Grow up! He's only my favorite because how he handles situations, and how he is so responsible. My best friend, who just started reading Warriors, already is in love with him! Yeah, he's overrated.V 7 Comments
She is like such a brat! She is rude to poor poor Firestar, and horrible to ashfur, she is a bully to leafpool, a jerk to brambleclaw and wow such a horrible cat to her poor poor innocent adopted kittens! JERK! She's also an overrated Mary Sue!
She helped Leafpool and her kits. Ashfur tried to kill her, he is not mentally stable. How is she bad to her kits? I don't like Squirrelflight very much, but at least don't accuse her of something that didn't happen. - RisingMoon
I don't understand. squirrelfight is 17 and ivypool is 2. Squirrelflight is easily the most overrated character and a little bit of that is bramblestar's falt. How is it Ivypool's fault for feeling left out? Even though she was not in the 4 she was certainly braver that lionblaze, dovewing, and jayfeather (fyi: I love jayjay
Squirrel flight is just a typical perfect character
✅included in prophecies
✅has really important kin
✅always fiery and energetic
✅pretty (has toms padding after her)
✅main character mate
✅important kits (alder, spark)
✅crazy fans willing to do anything to protect her
✅in drama but isn't her fault
❎not made leader yet (I hope)
I think she's underrated. Yes, she went off with Tigerheart, but so did about a thousand other cats! She's not my favorite, but she doesn't deserve all the hate she gets. - FernmistCloverleaf
Why is he on here? Dovewing is VERY underrated.
You either love her or hate her.
She's overrated in a bad way, as she gets too much hate. I hate her myself, but that's just me. - RedTheGremlinV 6 Comments
Why the heck is she on this list? Everyone likes her! - FernmistCloverleaf
I don’t really think she’s overrated. Unlike SCORAGE
"Oh he just loved Squirrelflight he so nice if she chose him" save it! - AnonymousChick
People love him...because he was friendzoned. He then went on to try to kill Squirrelflight's father who was his leader and her kits who were Leafpool's kits. She never used him. Read the books people! She thought they were friends and acted like they were friends.
To be honest, it is as though most people hate him. Don't see how Berrynose is overrated. - IcetailofWishClan
He's a cat who's fun to hate - money_face
It's confirmed he became mates with Poppyfrost because she reminded him of Honeyfern. - RisingMoon
Everyone feels sorry for him because he lost his mate and his stupid tail, but what we're all missing is his butt-hole personality and the fact that he's now mates with Honeyfern's SISTER. My goshness, peepsles
I hate him because he was a cat of the park he always looked at River ripple rudely like, "ugh why are you alive" he then went to the ancient tribe and was a JERK to jay's wing AND fallen leaves. I can't BELIEVE HALF MOON WAS IN LOVE WITH HIM! He screeched at fallen leaves that he'd never be a sharpclaw then killed stoneteller and made himself healer then he left the tribe! I could go on and on!
He was mean when he was an ancient cat, BUT HALF MOON WAS IN LOVE WITH HIM! STUPID EMERALDTWOLEG! HE BULLIED JAY'S WING! And then, to make matters worse, it turned out he was an immortal timetraveler! Then he was mean to longtail and told everyone that Darkstripe was Brindleface's mate, making ashpaw and fernpaw get judged by who their father was! UGH! He screamed at Bramblestar for not vanishing Jessy, and then hissed that he'd be a better deputy than Squirrelflight! He was so mean and had like fifty mates! I can't believe DOVEWING IS MATES WITH HIM. UGH. DIE EMERALDTWOLEG
No idea who he is but he sounds bad
Ew he's gross and mean whyyy it got leaked that in raging storm he's gonna murder hawkwing and bring back pebbleshine and murder her too WHY DO PEOPLE LIKE HIM WHEN HE KILLS EVERYONEV 8 Comments
Why isn't he like 6 steps after scourge if he was 1? Wtfreak
So overrated because...
He died sacrificing.
But Honeyfern didn't commit suicide like him,
Yet is so underrated,
My bff said who's Honeyfern.
Overrated for DYING.
Yet Honeyfern, dear sweet Honeyfern,
Because possibly she didn't commit suicide like Swiftpaw did?
Or nearly kill your friend?
Yeah. You get it now.
What!?!? Why is Mosskit on the list!?! - FernmistCloverleaf
I know right? Who knew that Mosskit was on hear? Isn't she just an innocent kit who died on a journey? I mean seiriously how is mosskit "over rated"
STOP U R JUST PUTTING rANDOM CATS ON HERE U SUCk - Foxylovescats
Not overrated because most the fandom hates him already. - BlueberryCatfish
He sucks. - RedTheGremlin
Yes, she's overrated. But that doesn't stop the fans (like me) from loving her! She's just so...relatable. - RedTheGremlin
MOST OVERRATED CAT IN THE SERIES! Everyone calls her underrated, even though like 99% of the fandom adores her. But why? She’s awful! Why are you all hating on Appledusk? He did the right thing! He did everything he could to save the kits, while Mapleshade just stood there basically saying, “NO MY BABIES APPLEDUSK SAVE THEM because I'm TO LAZY! ” And Appledusk tried. Mapleshade was a bs mom, and a bs mate. Overall, hella overrated and probably one of the worst characters in the series. Stop hating on Dovewing and Spottedleaf when this b**** exists. I just keep cracking open that one spot in Mapleshade’s vengeance (THE BEST PART) and read her death over and over. She doesn’t deserve StarClan. the Dark Forest, The Potato Room, or anywhere else. She should be rejected more then my friend (who got rejected times infinity).
WAY too many people love her so much. She's a total idiot, and she murdered someone. She's full of herself. - BlueberryCatfish
Honesty, I could start a long rant about why she's not a good cat. She's a hypocrite, murderer, and coward. - RisingMoon
She KILLED a cat! And tried to kill Leafpool (my favorite). - FernmistCloverleaf
She’s also a coward for running away from her problems. - SilverstreamSucksV 2 Comments
I don't see why people love him so much he wanted to kill firestar,He was so blind and was going to do whatever tigerstar said
He is underrated, but that's because he was just a kit and barely had a part in the books. - RedTheGremlin
How is Snowkit overrated? He was deaf! Its not like he was dumb and just didn't listen! HE COULDN'T HERE THE WARNING. I felt pretty bad for Speckletail. That was her last kit. After that, she was an elder. May Snowkit rest in belly.
~ Foxpaw of FogClan
I hate how everyone's mad at her for exiling Graystripe even though he stopped her from attacking an enemy cat.
She is honestly underrated. She may be pretty, but she isn't flawless. - IcetailofWishClan
✅pretty pelt and name
❎makes good decisions (grey stripe, tiger star, stone fur e.c.t
Gray Wing is /underrated/ in my opinion.
She's actually very /under/ rated
I HATE Millie. Nothing gives you the right to favor one child, and neglect the rest! She's a horrible mother! - FernmistCloverleaf
I like how she cares about Blossomfall and spends her time with her crippled daughter and is instantly hated. - Stormyblaze
Mainly people who hate Millie are butthurt GrayXSilver shippers that are mad about Graystripe not grieving for the rest of his life. - SilverstreamSucks
Briarlight is a caring cat. She has an awesome personality and didn't do anything to deserve hate. - RisingMoon
OVERRATED!? SHE'S BETTER THAN CINDERPELT AND IS HATED FOR "STEALING" BLOSSOMFALL'S SPOLIGHT! - Stormyblaze
I'm one of the few individuals who likes crowfeather - money_face
Literally never heard of cowoat. how is he/she overrated?
Cowoay is my favorite - money_face
Is this even a cat? - FernmistCloverleaf
I can't wait to see more of him. - RisingMoon
She's here because too many people like her and she just gets too much attention from fans. Myself, I don't like her, but that does NOT mean angry Brightheart fans can hate on me. - RedTheGremlin
Really why is she on here - Puppytart
Why is she on here? - Walla
Starstarstar is my favorite medicine cat - money_face
Related ListsMost Annoying Warrior Cats Most Misunderstood Warrior Cats Most Evil Warrior Cats Top Ten Most Underrated Warrior Cats Most Noble Warrior Cats
3 years, 315 days old