Most Overrated Warrior Cats

I hate Ivypool! You know how she "spied" on the Dark Forest? She never told anyone! Every time they asked her it would be "None of your business!" she didn't even help in the battle, if you read The Last Hope she's an awful fighter. And she never trained in the Dark Forest to save the Clans, she did it out of jealousy so she could be better than Dovewing! And then she REJECTED her own sister! I would be annoyed if my sister got powers, but I wouldn't be too rude about it! And Dovewing hated having powers and tried to let Ivypool be in the prophecy. And before that, Dovewing went on the quest to find the beavers, and then Ivypool thought she was making stuff up, but was still jealous when her sister became famous for a short amount of time! It's not Dovewing, it's Ivypool! - Stonepaw

Don't get me wrong, I love small villains who will rip your face off if you call them weak. But Scourge, he...he went too far. I understand he went power-hungry after everyone thought little Tiny killed a dog, but just because Tigerpaw went a little overboard doesn't mean you get to go on a murder spree.
...the worst part is probably the fangirls who make daughters of Scourge, coated in blood-red fur dye and unrealistic emo hair. I'm not saying have an OC related to Scourge is a bad thing--heck, my main kittypet OC is Ruby's kid--but wow. Seriously, there's sO MANY.
Scourge must've been busy...

I love her, but there's no denying the fact that she's incredibly overrated. I love her because she's an interesting character and I can sort of relate to her, with the whole "being rejected by everyone you love" thing. I completely relate to that. But that still doesn't give her the excuse to go on a killing spree, when the only ones who really deserved to die were Oakstar and Frecklewish. Appledusk was annoying but he didn't really do anything terrible besides cheat on her. I love her, but she's overrated, and I don't agree with her decisions. -FierceheartOfThunderClan

I love her, but its annoying seeing everyone treat her like a goddess. Just because she had a tough life doesn't mean she can kill cats (except for Appledusk and Oakstar, they deserve it) and ruin Crookedsatr's life. There are a lot of people who've been betrayed/saw their loved ones die, but they don't kill/manipulate people.

She's ok, just like Millie. Please stop saying like things like: 'Oh, Millie had a terribly injured kit and two kits who were fine, how horrible of her to pay more attention to the hurt kit, Silverstream, the cat we only knew for 1 second, would be a much better mother! Whine, whine, whine', I mean, you don't even know what Silverstream would've done if she had to nurse her kits! And Millie really cares about all of her kits, but what's wrong with being worried about your kit who has no legs anymore? Please, people, be fair!

To be honest, I can't find myself hating Silverstream over causing an argument between Firestar and Graystripe. Friends have arguments all the time, no matter how good of friends they are. I have petty arguments with my best friend all the time, but we always make up. It's been a while since I read the first series and I don't remember much of it, but I do know that it wasn't her fault that Graystripe left to RiverClan when she died. That was Graystripe's choice, and she didn't make him do it. Sure, she betrayed her Clan, but I mean, so did Graystripe. She is overrated, and I think she was just a side character created so Graystripe would have a love interest, so I'm confused why people love her. But I'm not going to hate her over whatever "horrible things" she's done.

I honestly hate him and Lionblaze SO MUCH. I can't wait for both of their deaths, too many people love Jayfeather but all he does disrespect Starclan, complain about his blindness, how he's so "powerful", and kiss a stick scratched by an old bald cat. Now Lionblaze, I hate him with all of my heart. He's so annoying and thinks he's "got the power of the stars in his paws" just like his brother. He endlessly claws the heck out of cats for NO reason. His life is FINE. He is the most selfish, bossy cat there is. He and Jayfeather deserve The Dark Forest, or should at LEAST die. Hollyleaf and Dovewing are okay, but I don't like them and never will.

Jayfeather is awesome, yet I can't deny it. He's so damn overrated he puts Scourge to shame. I mean, half of this fandom worship him, and the childish ones have a crush on him! Grow up! He's only my favorite because how he handles situations, and how he is so responsible. My best friend, who just started reading Warriors, already is in love with him! Yeah, he's overrated.

Sorry Firestar-lovers, but I hate this guy. Firestar is DEFINITELY overrated. He's a freaking gary sue and I absolutely hate him. I liked him in the first series when he wasn't totally stealing the spotlight all the time, but afterwards when he kept coming back and being a total hero over and over again, he got really boring and annoying. It was like no one else was allowed to have their moment to shine. He literally appeared in the Broken Code, which was two series after Omen of the Stars, when he died. He's such a gary sue and everyone loves him so much that the authors keep bringing him back, and it's nothing but annoying.

Firestar my father my name Squirrelflight and why must it be that my father is overrated. He was a hero, he saved the clans mabye like 5 times and he also saved Sandstorm. Thanks dad you even killed Tigerstar for the last time but you might know what happened he died. Yes he died. Firestar is in the spotlight and he is my father and if you guys HATE him you guys are crazy no offense.

Everyone annoyingly treated her like a queen after she got hit by a car! And she's kinda a Mary Sue. She got blessed back into another cat's body the second she took her last breath, and only Firestar, Sandstorm, and all the kits that died should reincarnated! What did she do?! Nothing! She's basically Spottedleaf all over again! Everyone loves her for doing nothing! I also hate this cat because they ship her with Firestar! She's an overrated little brat! - Dovefeather

She's a Mary Sue. She got blessed with reincarnation the second she died, and now the whole fandom worships her like a queen because she got hit with a car, it is VERY annoying! What did she even do?! She's just annoying and some people ship her with Firestar (which drives me crazy, I only ship canon, unless it's Jay x Half, I must ship Jay x Half)
- Stealthshadow

I understand sympathizing with her death, but saying she's your favorite character is a little too much. She died at around 2 moons old, so we didn't know anything about her. She's just another kit death, and they're bound to happen when cats live in the wild.

I know right? Who knew that Mosskit was on hear? Isn't she just an innocent kit who died on a journey? I mean seiriously how is mosskit "over rated"

She's some people's favorite character, yet she died as a kit and we knew nothing about her.

Lion is pretty boring as character if start looking to his siblings. Like I have never cared about Lionblaze becouse I think that even Jayfeather has more of a character than Lionblaze. Hollyleaf in the other hand is very diffrent from her brothers and I see her not as plain character as Lionblaze.

I never really saw Lionblaze as overrated, only boring. For me, he's just there - one of the three, cool-but-not-really-cool powers, and that's it. I really did not like the way he reacted to Shadowsight in the Broken Code, but otherwise, that's mostly all the feeling I had for him. So I never really saw him as overrated. Yeah.

I think he is awful, but seen as most everyone agrees he is not overrated because he has a terrible rate. But I don't like him. Can't get hurt in battle? Give me own reason he is not a sue?

Dear Lord. I hate this cat so much. He supports abuse and didn't give a rat's behind when Squirrelstar was grooming and abusing kits. (There's a scene in Leafpool's Wish where she doesn't want the kits to stay. It can be implied that she didn't want them to know. But I got a feeling she r@ped Lionblaze. And in this series, she definitely molested Nightheart, who is acting like a child who has been GROOMED.)

Bramblestar is definitely overrated. He's literally abusive to Squirrelflight and he's ambitious and a jerk. I hate him. I have to admit, I never really liked the idea of Graystripe becoming deputy before, but now I know that he would've been a better choice than freaking Brambledung.

I hate him! Squirrelflight should have chosen Ashfur instead of him. All Brambleclaw does is flirt and snap at her, and Ashfur actually loves her. And once greedy Brambleclaw got Squirrelflight, he mistreated her. Like, seriously! And then a kittypet named Jessy comes along, and Brambleclaw starts flirting with her, and he's like "Eh, who cares that Squirrelflight is feeling sad, hurt, and jealous right now." And also, in Squirrelflight's Hope, he waited to treat Sunrise's injury, and she was about to DIE. An innocent cat was about to die just go Bramblebutt could have his stupid way!

You suck, Brambleclaw!

GOD I HATE THIS OVERRATED CAT! She has no right to be said to have "gone through a lot." She is just a stupid drama queen! Let me go over some stupid reasons people feel so much pity for her:

"Oh Stormtail didn't love Bluestar or her mother! "
Too bad. Crookedstar's mother abused him and said things to his face. She also made sure to make him be named "Crookedkit".

"Oh Bluestar's kit died and then she had to give her other kits up."
First of all, kiT. One kit. Other cats have had many kits die. Second of all, it was Bluestar's choice to give up her kits, and also her choice to have kits in the first place. She didn't have to.

"She had to deal with Thisleclaw! "
Thisleclaw was never bad, at least in the super edition. Bluestar just had too much ambition and wanted to be leader.

SPOILERS FOR THE BROKEN CODE!!!
Ashfur is so overrated! Nowadays everyone ships him with Squirrelflight because everyone hates Bramblestar these days! Ashfur also is just a boring character and he should have died earlier, and when he does die, he figures out how to get into Bramblestar's body so Squirrelflight loves him, and then he attacks a medicine cat! Isn't that against the code or something? And how do people even like him? He's way to overrated and was a minor obstacle! - Stonepaw

I have always hated Ashfur. Fr I started accidentally from Power of Three's first book, Sight and I have hated him since. I mean he was horrible mentor for Lionblaze for no reason, he tried to burn Holly,Jay and Lion alive, he was going to reveal the secret only becouse he could not just take that Squirrelflight loves Brambleclaw. And he should have never get go to StarClan. He belonged to Dark Forest even then, and the whole thing of him controlling Bramblestar's body sucks.
I hate fact that Bristlefrost had to drown too after she was drowned Ashfur. I do not undestand if u like him because he has created his stupid problems himself and has maken other cats to suffer from them. He is too overrated.

I hate you Spottedleaf. Everyone thinks that she's Firestar's mate but no, the only words she said to him were: "Get back to camp, he needs rest!" That's not even affectionate. Sandstorm didn't like Firestar at first but she started warming up to him, and shut up, all of you Spottedleaf lovers, because they're already a ship. Spottedleaf is such a A Mary Sue! And when she died, she made StarClan look like a laughing stalk, go to the Dark Forest, you fool! And in one of Firestar's dreams she tried to pull Firestar into the deepest part of StarClan so he could never retire. Don't believe me? Read the books again! And it would be sort of weird because Spottedleaf is old enough to be Firestar's grandmother! What did she do that was so important? - Mossfall

Crookedstar had a bad mum, get over it. Nightcloud is wonderful (she didn't make him do anything). He attacked a pregnant Queen and s blind medicine cat. He said it was great Hollyleaf died but it wasn't she is a hero (no matter what the estupidos enemigos say) but he never saved anyone! He deserves to live alone with no one then die and burn in the dark forest. Though he's underrated not overrated more people hate him than like him.

I hate how everyone claims that he's bad because he had a bad father. Well, as Emberleap said in her reply, Crookedstar had a bad mother (which was worse, given that she's the one who was supposed to nurse him) and he was one of the best cats the series has ever seen.

Okay I personally like Breezepelt, I think that it's Crowfeather's fault for not raising Breezepelt like a proper dad (I still like Crowfeather though he's one of my favorites). I wouldn't call him 'overrated', though.

Why does everyone blame Dovewing? Let me tell you their story: Bumblestripe was a pushy furball who forced poor Dovewing into a relationship. Then, when she accepted it, he became all mouse-dungy and annoying. I hate him.

He asked her to be his mate at a funeral (yeesh, buddy) and then ran away. And when she came to say sorry, he yelled at her! He mistreated Dovewing and kept pushing the relationship to the point where she ran off to another Clan (the second best one) to get away from him! He's a creepy stalker!
- Stealthshadow

I dislike Moonflower. She hated her brother, had a crush of some guy who didn't actully even care about him and then she thought it as a great idea of going to go destroy some meds herbs and then she died. Overrated

It was love at first sight with Stormtail and she was literally a kit when Stormtail was a warrior, this cat is so so stupid, and then Stormtail realized she should be on this list and started hanging out with Dappletail. Boo Moonflower, your name is even overrated we all know we can't have the prefix Moon!

I hate Moonflower. She tries to attack the Windclan herb store, picks fights with apprentices, and hates her brother. How is she liked?

I'll list some reasons why I don't like Leafpool:
1. She broke the Warrior Code
2. She ran away from the Clans
3. She disobeyed StarClan because she wanted to
4. She was whiny
5. She broke the rule about medicine cats not being able to have kits
6. She was dramatic
7. She refuses to admit her secret so she doesn't get punished
8. Her life was made up of lies
9. She abandoned her role as medicine cat so she would get out of trouble
10. She wanted Squirrelflight to lie for her
11. She damaged Crowfeather' and Nightcloud's relationship
12. She was focused on to much
13. She could have saved Cinderpelt if she had never left the Clan and had blocked the blow and if she died instead
14. She cared to much about Mothwing
15. She was too easy on WindClan when Mothwing fed them the tainted water
16. She broke the rule about trespassing on other Clan territories
- Dovefeather of ThunderClan

Reasons I don't like Leafpool:

1. She tried to run away from her clan

2. She broke two very important rules from the code

3. She thought it was ok to abandon her duties of saving the lives of her clan mates by leaving to be with some random Tom from another clan

4. She damaged Crowfeather and Nightclouds relationship, which caused their son to feel neglected by his father and become bitter and angry.

5. She refused to admit her secret, even though she had to deal with the consequences of disobeying her family and her clan

6. She lived a life of lies all to protect her precious secret that was eventually found out by her clan

7. She disobeyed StarClan just because she wanted to

8. She was kinda whiny and dramatic

9. You know how there's a rule? A rule that says medicine cats can't have kits? That was made for a reason, people. When you're a med cat, the clan around you is like your kits. You care for them and watch over them every day. If you have kits of your own, the medicine cat will help deliver them. WHAT IF you're THE MEDICINE CAT? Who will help you? I don't know, beats me. Also, having to take care of 1-3 extra cats in the clan does not sound easy. It may make your life overwhelming or even miserable. Priorities, people. StarClan didn't just make these rules for no reason.

Those are my reasons!
-Koipelt

She is NOT WHINY BRAT she cared for her adopted kits she loved her sister mom and dad she was loyal to her mate. She made a great mother to Alder Heart and Spark Pelt she was very supportive of them also she cared for Sparkpelt's Kits when her mate died. Squirrelflight is also she helps very much on the great journey and got wiser through the series. She helped her good sister Leafpool (that also picked on here which I disagree) with her kits. For all whom think Squirrelflight is overrated think again maybe just maybe she is a great character!

So overrated because...

He died sacrificing.

But Honeyfern didn't commit suicide like him,

Yet is so underrated,

My bff said who's Honeyfern.

Again

Overrated for DYING.

Yet Honeyfern, dear sweet Honeyfern,

Is underrated,

Because possibly she didn't commit suicide like Swiftpaw did?

Or nearly kill your friend?

Yeah. You get it now.

Okay, his death was sad and all, but he is seriously overrated for what he is. He's a background character who wasn't meant to get much attention (besides a bit because of his sad death)

Overall, he was a good cat, but WAY overrated for what he was

-Sweethoney of ThunderClan (He/they)

Everyone feels sorry for him because he lost his mate and his stupid tail, but what we're all missing is his butt-hole personality and the fact that he's now mates with Honeyfern's SISTER. My goshness, peepsles

Doesn't deserve love from cats or sympathy/pity. He's overrated, spoiled, whiny, annoying and a brat. Thank you Tawnypelt for killing him!

To be honest, it is as though most people hate him. Don't see how Berrynose is overrated.

Yeah! Why do people like this screaming banshee? She screams, she is lazy, selfish, overprotective, stubborn, whiny, annoying hypocrite and a coward. I know why Spiderleg dumped her: who would want a mate who does nothing but sit in the nursery all day and refuses a warrior name?

She was bad when she had kits, but other than that, she was fine.

Doesn't Everyone hate her...?