Most Overrated Warrior Couples

This counts down the top most overrated couples in the Warriors Fandom. Keep in mind that if you comment, it is /mature/, stating your agreement or disagreement.

The Top Ten

1 Graystripe x Silverstream

Let me say right now, while this is an extremely overrated couple, it is also terrible. A love at first sight and people instantly shipped. People were so tied up in this pairing that when Millie came along, they forgot that Silverstream /saved/ her and claimed that Millie "stole" Graystripe from Silverstream. It just seems as if people treat Silverstream like she's supposed to be the queen of the warriors, when she in fact, is /not/, while Graystripe, on the other hand, is also praised for doing something bad. It just seems as if "love at first sight" is apparently the best thing ever.

Agreed this couple sucks! Millie and Greystripe are far more developed and much preferred!

Everybody Ships them. And it sucks.


V 10 Comments
2 Firestar x Spottedleaf

How does this even exist?

This relationship is creepy... Who's with me?

Summing it up:

Firepaw (literally still a kit): Ooh! Who dat? She smells hot!
Spottedleaf (grown cat): *OMSC. A kit! He is hot!

Spottedleaf: Oh no! I'm dead! Better stalk Fireheart!
Fireheart: uhhh spottedleaf help me
Spottedleaf: Don't you wanna see how beautiful I am?

yes this is literally it.
*OMSC=Oh my StarClanp

Some only liked the pairing because of the feelings toward eachother. Enough said.

V 7 Comments
3 Leafpool x Crowfeather

In my opinion this couple came out of nowhere.

Another forbidden pairing. It's as if forbidden loves are the next best things. It's as if the whole selfishness, brattiness, and the issues are all forgotten about when this pairing comes into hand. This pairing was also partially the cause of the hatred toward Nightcloud x Crowfeather. Another terrible pairing, where both characters are selfish in the relationship, and people support the selfishness (Not trying to offend anyone in any way).

Too many people ship this. Too many people love all the cats. This couple is just, no.

This relationship had so many plot holes in it. Period.

V 5 Comments
4 Mothwing and Leafpool

What the Taco Bell is wrong with both of them being girls? Just because they're both girls it don't mean they can't mate.

First- They are both GIRLS, and they never shown any sign of love to each other. This ship is like saying “ Graystripe hangs out with Fireheart, so they love each other! ” It’s mouse-brained. I love their strong friendship, but they aren’t meant to be mates.

5 Crowfeather x Feathertail

While crow feather was cute with her, she obviously didn't love him romantically. she looked at him more like a good friend, someone she wanted to protect, but not like a mate. it was a one sided relationship. but still cute

For some reason everybody loves this but I never really saw the point of it.

Undeveloped, another forbidden, uncanon. People mainly fell in love with this couple for how many times Crowpaw had saved Feathertail, and how Feathertail died saving Crowpaw. We barely knew about the couple, yet some shipped it because of how affectionate the two were toward eachother.

6 Squirrelflight x Ashfur

It was more of a friends kind of thing, was undeveloped, and many people got angry (specifically at Squirrelflight) when the pairing wasn't canon and when Squirrelflight turned Ashfur down. Ashfur could have been like Thrushpelt, but of course, he instead decides to go haywire. Some people claim that he "loved Squirrelflight too much," but if he really loved her, he would let her be with Brambleclaw, but instead, he went crazy. He's the complete opposite of Thrushpelt, which makes me confused. People like Thrushpelt when he let Bluefur be with Oakheart, but they also like Ashfur for not letting Squirrelflight go and making her miserable.

Couple? What couple? These two cats were never together; they were just friends, and when Squirrelflight told Ashfur that she just wanted to be friends with him, he reacted terribly! He didn't actually love her; if he did, he would be happy that Squirrelflight was happy with Brambleclaw! Ashfur needs to be taught something from Thrushpelt.

No squirrel would NOT go well with Brackenfur whoever said that, he is like twice her age

They were friends but Ashy thought she loved him. Worst. Couple. Ever.

V 2 Comments
7 Dovewing x Tigerheart

Once again, a forbidden pairing, but uncanon. I was sort of thinking of replacing this with Dovewing x Bumblestripe, but I decided not to, even though Dove did sort of use Bumble to get away from Tigerheart. Most people really liked this couple because it was forbidden, and how many times they've met. Though it may be a pretty good couple since they are basically two perfect cats, great for shipping. Basically, they've been training together in the Dark Forest while

With the new story centered around Tigerheart, this couple only gets worse. Underdeveloped, yet ANOTHER forbidden love story, etc. Tigerheart is a complete idiot, and how Dovewing can get into this and also act like an idiot ruins her character.

They're not overrated, a lot of people hate it. Unless it gets crazy fan girls, this couple isn't really shipped. They have some development, but not much.

I felt that Dovewing and Tigerheart have a way better developed relationship than Dovewing and Bumblestripe had.

V 2 Comments
8 Bluestar x Oakheart

Forbidden but canon, love at first sight, and just happened. Once again, this is like a Gray x Silver couple without the deaths. I used to like it but it just simply went downhill when I remember how it just... happened. Their meeting was pretty amusing, but afterward, Bluefur suddenly loved Oakheart. Lots of people especially like it when the whole kit thing came in, as well as the prologue to Bluestar's Prophecy, and I can understand that, but I still feel like this pairing was very overrated.

Oakheart And Bluestar Were Cannon, And Their (Insert Lenny Here) Was Before They Were Made Deputy In There Clans.

Never! Best couple ever! - QueenOfRacing

I don't like it and auctully really disliked how sudden it was but once it got going, it was okay.

V 2 Comments
9 Jayfeather x Half Moon

Very overrated. Half moon never even had a personality.

It's an adorable couple, but pretty overrated. People (as well as myself) have shipped this for how close Jay's Wing and Half Moon were, and especially with the quote "I'll wait for you forever," indicating that Half Moon would always wait for Jay's Wing even though she /was/ pretty old. Basically, people (and I) mostly shipped this because of how the two treated eachother.

It's so overrated that the Hype from this pairing let me hate it.

I like it, but jay x willow more. - gamerkitty6274

V 3 Comments
10 Dovewing x Bumblestripe

This relationship was undeveloped, and was just, sort there to keep the story going.

This relationship is so underdeveloped it hurts. Dovewing X Tigerheart for the win!

WAY better then Tigerfart

The Newcomers

? Jayfeather x Briarlight

The Contenders

11 Ashfur x Scourge


12 Lionblaze x Cinderheart

I don't really like this one, personally. I always thought that Lionblaze would be better off with a more strong independent woman type cat rather than Cinderheart. No offense but Cinderheart is definitely not strong or independent. And I always thought of Cinderheart as a lesbian to be honest. - Warriorcatsfandom

A canon, non-forbidden couple! This one is actually good, but it can get out of hand sometimes, with how overrated it seems. A lot of people usually like this couple because of the struggle between the two with their friendship, and how powerful Lionblaze was, even trying to prove that he can control his power in front of Cinderheart. I must say, this pairing is mostly overrated because of how everyone was hoping they would have kits.

WHOAWHOAWHOAWHOA! A cat fell in love with someone from their own Clan? I think it's safe to say no one saw this coming, am I right?

I don't mind it but I have seen better ones.

V 1 Comment
13 Firestar x Sandstorm

This is developed and they have their differences and their similarities. I like em'

It was cute but its veeery overrated.

Yeah whoever put this up 1. Doesn't know what a decent ship is 2.Is spottedxfire fangirl/boy

14 Squirrelflight x Brambleclaw

Squirrelflight was sooo horrible to Brambleclaw. by the way I ship Bramble x Jessy too much.

I hate BrambleXJessy

I’ve never liked Bramble x Squirrel. Honestly I felt like it was kind of forced, especially since I honestly don’t like Squirrelflight that much. I mean, it felt like the only reason they tell in love was because they almost had to, just because they both went to find Midnight. Honestly, I never felt an actual connection between them and I think the Erin’s just needed some sort of plot twist or something to keep the books interesting

15 Yellowfang x Raggedstar

I never really got enough info. On this ship. It was weird. Raggedstar was killed b4 I learned much about him...

16 Firestar x Cinderpelt

She had a crush on him, but people think that her life was destroyed because she couldn't be his mate. No, it was because she couldn't be a warrior. Of course, it was kind of sad for her, but people overate it.

17 Clear Sky x Storm

Love at first sight... LITERALLY

18 Cloudtail x Brightheart


19 Emeraldtwoleg x Dovewing

Ughhh I hate him he sucks so glad dovewing dumped him for Tigerheart (even though I hated Tigerheart EMERALDTWOLEG MADE ME LIKE HIM) and they had kits and dovewing killed him BUT HE GOT REVIVED!

Ew Dovewing is too good for that JERK!

20 Lionpaw x Heatherpaw
21 Longtail x Mousefur

And the lowest on this list is Longtail x Mousefur. I don't /hate/ the pairing, but I don't like it. People mostly shipped it because of how Mousefur treated Longtail, and how she upset was afterward, looking up at Silverpelt to find Longtail's star, and resting in the old nests that still smelled of Longtail with Purdy. (i. E curled up with Purdy in a nest that still smelled of Longtail). Basically, it isn't /too/ overrated but I've noted that people usually ship it because of how Mousefur treated Longtail/vice versa.

I really like this relationship, but it should've been a main plot.

Kinda cute honestly

I think this pretty overrated and thia make me dislike it.

22 Grayfall x Hollybright
23 Gray Wing x Turtle Tail

Their cute

24 Blossomfall x Ivypool
25 Daisy x Spiderleg


He so doesn’t care about Daisy or their kits!

26 Gray Wing x Slate
27 Birchtail x Mallowstream
28 Gray Wing x Storm
29 Whitestorm x Willowpelt
30 Dragonfall X Mothstrike
31 Blacksky X Dawnwhisker
32 Jessy x Bramblestar
33 Moonflower x Stormtail

Moonflower was a kit when Stormtail became a warrior!

34 Graystripe x Cinderpelt
35 Hollyleaf x Fallen Leaves
36 Fallowtail x Reedfeather
37 Stormfur x Brook
38 Lionblaze x Icecloud
39 Oakheart x Bluefur
BAdd New Item