Top 10 People Who Shouldn't Play Certain Historical or Religious Figures

The people who would be oh so unfitting for these roles, even in parody movies! (Note: These people don't need to be alive right now, but they must have been alive after these historical events happened.)

The Top Ten

1 Stephen Hawking as God Stephen Hawking as God Stephen William Hawking (January 8, 1942 - March 13, 2018) was an English theoretical physicist, cosmologist, author and Director of Research at the Centre for Theoretical Cosmology within the University of Cambridge.

One of the greatest atheists of all time (definitely inspired someone like me). Why would he play something he doesn't even believe in?!?! - PhoenixAura81

Let's take one of the most famous atheists ever and have him play God. Great idea! - 445956

The description says that as long as the person was alive after the event, it qualifies, even if they are dead now. - 445956

Yep. Great idea to have an atheist scientist play as something that isn't real - KingSlayer93316

As a christian, I approve of this message. - namesnipe

V 3 Comments
2 Victor Garber as Adolf Hitler Victor Garber as Adolf Hitler Victor Joseph Garber is a Canadian film, stage and television actor and singer. He is known for playing Jesus in Godspell, John Wilkes Booth in Assassins, Jack Bristow in the television series Alias, Max in Lend Me a Tenor, Thomas Andrews in James Cameron's Titanic, and Ken Taylor, Canadian Ambassador more.

Anyone with no brain would want to cast Victor Garber as Hitler, because a Jewish gay man playing Hitler totally makes sense, right? - 445956

It's Acting. The actor doesn't need to have Any resemblance or similarities to the personality, values or lifestyle of the character. A Jewish, gay man may be able to enact the best possible portrayal of Hitler - especially if he's a talented and capable professional. - Billyv

3 Richard Spencer as Martin Luther King Jr.

An alt-rightist playing his worst nightmare. - 445956

That would be both ironic AND absolutely terrible. - PhoenixAura81

The irony is right there.A white supremacist and leader of the alt right playing the role of the leader of the civil rights movement and the man who gave people of colour equal rights as whites.-DarkBoi-X

4 Mel Gibson as Oskar Schindler Mel Gibson as Oskar Schindler Mel Colmcille Gerard Gibson AO is an American actor and filmmaker. He is best known for his action hero roles, namely his breakout role as Max Rockatansky in the first three films in the Mad Max post-apocalyptic action series, and as Martin Riggs in the Lethal Weapon buddy cop film series.

Liam Neeson, who played Schindler on the big screen, may not be Jewish, but he sure isn't a crazy anti-semite like Gibson, which would make sense why an anti-semite shouldn't play a man who saved several Jews from Hitler. - 445956

5 Bernie Sanders as Andrew Jackson Bernie Sanders as Andrew Jackson Bernard "Bernie" Sanders is an independent American Senator from Vermont and was a candidate for the Democratic nomination for President of the United States in the 2016 election.

Probably one of the biggest male feminists in politics wouldn't want to play our most racist president. (Yes, Jackson was more racist than Trump.) - 445956

6 Harvey Fierstein as Heinrich Himmler

Imagine a parody movie about Nazi Germany with people like Victor Garber as Hitler and Harvey Fierstein as Himmler? It would be a parody movie as Victor and Harvey are both gay jews! - 445956

7 Brandon Flynn as Josef Mengele Brandon Flynn as Josef Mengele

This young Jewish gay actor would totally work out as a Nazi who did experiments on jews, and also hated gays, right? But now I think I will stop putting gay jews here for playing Nazis. - 445956

8 Connor Franta as Naphtali Connor Franta as Naphtali

Because let's just have a cute YouTuber play one of Jacob's sons, amirite? - 445956

9 Chadwick Boseman as Joseph Stalin Chadwick Boseman as Joseph Stalin

I couldn't find any lists of anti-communist celebrities, so I took someone completely unfitting for the role of Stalin. - 445956

He looks a lot like Stalin though! - Cyri

10 Dave Goelz as Confucius

You know what we need more of? White puppeteers playing Asian philosophers! - 445956

The Newcomers

? Nicki Minaj as Jesus

I made an unholy monstrosity! - Cyri

The Contenders

11 Donald Trump as Barack Obama

Oh my god this is PERFECT. This movie needs to be made RIGHT NOW. - GlassweighanCountess

I'm laughing so hard! "Yes we can make America great again! " Haha!

Shut up and take my money! - CaptainMowzker

12 Adam Sandler as Adolf Hitler

It doesn't help that Sandler is also Jewish.

13 Peter Dinklage as Abraham Lincoln

Because let's make the midget play one of the tallest presidents ever.

14 Bill Cosby as Jack the Ripper

I want to see this. - Cyri

No it’s a great decision lmao
~ AlphaQ

15 Hillary Clinton as Elizabeth Báthory

Elizabeth Bathory:...
Elizabeth Bathory: Come on guys, I'm not THAT bad. Cut me some slack, please. - GlassweighanCountess

16 Donald Trump as Mahatma Gahndi
17 Donald Trump as Martin Luther King Jr.

"Make America Great Again" was Bill Clinton's official campaign slogan-m Trump stole it from him.

I have a dream that we can make America whi- I mean great again!

18 Seth MacFarlane as Walt Disney

The creator of Family Guy as the creator of many kids movies? I'd love to see how this turns out - KingSlayer93316

Hmmm that'll be interesting to see. - CharismaticKat

19 Neil Patrick Harris as a Klansman
20 Kevin Spacey as Chris Hansen
21 Jim Caviezel as Maximilian Kolbe

I actually made a mistake when I made this suggestion. I misread what the list was about. I didn't see the 'n't' after "should.' - clusium

22 Keemstar as Harvey Weinstein

Haha, this is something I would pay to see - KingSlayer93316


23 Rob Halford as Josef Mengele

Halford isn’t Jewish, but Mengele hated homosexuals - NightmareCinema

24 Barack Obama as Donald Trump
25 Lil Wayne as Martin Luther King Jr.
26 Nicki Minaj as Māyā Angelou
27 6ix9ine as George Washington

The unholy child of Skittles and the worst of modern hip-hop leading the American Revolution... - Cyri

He'll lead the revolution against M and Ms. - CharismaticKat

28 Riley Dennis as Adolf Hitler
29 David Duke as Jesus Christ
30 Chanty Binx as Karl Marx
31 Nicki Minaj as Maya Angelou
32 Lil Xan as Mozart

Hehehe. Lil Xan can't even rap let alone play a violen. - CharismaticKat

33 RiceGum as Hayao Miyazaki
34 Barack Obama as Jesus
35 Donald Trump as Hillary Clinton
36 Michael Bay as Steven Spielberg
37 Roy Moore as Abraham Lincoln
38 Fred Phelps as Jesus
39 Rob Schneider as Stan Lee
40 Honey G as Osama Bin Laden
41 Woahvicky as Mother Mary
BAdd New Item