Top Ten Poptropica Islands

Poptropica is an online virtual world that is played by over 75 million people. What do you think the best islands are on this popular game?

The Top Ten

1 Mythology

I totally agree! Mythology is the BEST island. Its really long, but its a lot of fun... Everyone should play it! I hope everybody finds it fun and easy(even though the riddle in the labyrinth is hard! )

Perfect Star

I liked the island because it was completely flawless. There was nothing wrong with it what so ever. People should really play this game more often.

The best island made by poptropica... The storyline is entertaining then each place has a mystery to be solved

Hands down the best island.

V 113 Comments
2 Reality T.V.

A great island in my opinion. You got to do the usual poptropica stuff and then all of a sudden you make it on a reality T.V. show! Its sort of challenging to win it all but very very fun to try! And the best part is you can always go back and play another season of the show!

Its fun because you have to work hard to win immunity or you could lose the game. My favorite is the one where you have to get coconuts

Reality T.V. is so easy! Here r some tips on how to pass.
1. Hanglider game- move your mouse to the top of the screen until your person disappears. Then, when everyone loses, you'll win!
2. Shuffleboard- Keep inching toward the win point. Very easy, I always win this! Also, watch out for Grandma Gracey & Grandpa Grump. They'll try to knock you off.
3. Coconut Turtle Shell Toss- Keep aiming for the 20. Keep the mouse in the middle, and stretch it as long as it'll go.
4. Cocunut Catch w/ the Monkey- So really. Stay. In. The. Middle. And. Also. The. Front. When in doubt, go to the back. Also, lastly, grab the bunches of 3 as often as you can.
5. Vote off these people: Grandma Gracy and Grandpa Grump, Director D. ( me & my friend say the D is 4 diva but he says its for dangerous ) Magic Mervin, Lassie Lasso, Betty Brownie, and also Brett Batter & Slim Slam.

Good Luck if your just starting the level!
P.S. the phone number for the pizza place is 555-7383

This island is really great and it has great competition so you could be proud when you win. I love this island in my opinion it is the best island in Poptropica.

V 72 Comments
3 Counterfeit

Very interesting how you capture the theif and all of the secrets and things you discover. It is also fun how you study the paintings and chemicals. Although I wish you could save poor old balloon boy!

I love how you get to uncover the mysteries and use the different gadgets to see if the paintings were real or not. I also really liked the battle at the end where you go against Black Widow! Anyone who hasn't tried this island yet should, it's loads of fun!

Counterfeit island is one of my favorite islands! You get to learn and figure out if a painting is the real one or counterfeit by using chemicals and magnifying glasses, You get to actually travel to early poptropica to meet someone so it can be confidential, You have to think logically and really feel like your actually in the game as your find the heart pounding clues. So if you haven't played this yet I think you should :) Try doing it with a tutorial/walkthrough because I gotta say,... Its worth it!

Mystery, intrigue, action scenes, a scary villain, a meme-worthy balloon boy, what more could you want from an island?

V 23 Comments
4 Time Tangled

I loved Time Tangled Island! It was very well thought out, and very much fun to play. This island required thought and knowledge of historical events. Speaking from the point of view of an older student, this island was intelligently crafted.

Time Tangled is a really fun experience, and this is coming from a fourth grader, so a kid who's meant to be playing poptropica. I think that Time Tangled definitely deserves a spot up here because of its creativity and overall fun with learning!

Time Tangled is so much fun and I love traveling from different time periods! It really teaches you a lot and is so fun to play!

Truly a classic. Short but sweet, with history galore.

V 26 Comments
5 Cryptids

I like how there is different variety of mysterious animal myths, how you had to travel around different areas to find them and also how each of the myths had their own different journey.

Cryptids is so fun! Yes, Mythology is entertaining, but the Boss fight is so hard! I really like the islands that have an equally challenging story plot, too. And I kinda suck at boss fights, so easy ones are great! Really really love this island mainly because of all the different scenarios you have to get through.

It is awesome. I like traveling to look for different animals.. It didn't have a lot of problems. The only problem was that there wasn't enough appearances of the main antagonist, (Gretchen Grimlock) which only appeared twice in the whole game.

What isn't there to like! It is an adventure with fun (real) locations!

V 37 Comments
6 Spy

Spy island is awesome it's challenging but you feel like you really accomplished something! When you finish the island I suggest you try it!

Usually I would say Mythology was the best island, but this one was dead on a winner. I used to be scared of this island because I thought I'd be bald forever but haha that didn't happen at all. The lasers and the robots were challenging and I have to admit: it was hilarious when Director D ripped off his toupee only to reveal a bald head. Plus all the cool gadgets are fun to use, even if I'm terrible at using the grappling hook bowtie :) And like the last person said, I really felt like accomplishing something when I finished.

Trick fun and challenging finding cues to solve the mystery!

It may be a little hard, but it's a lot of fun!

V 27 Comments
7 Mystery Train

I loved the Mystery Train! Although I had to look up a guide because it was confusing at some parts. Great storyline though :) It isn't too hard if you know what you're doing. I actually dressed my character to blend in with the time period (1900s)

I loved this island! It was so different than all of the other Poptropica islands!

I love how you meet lots of different famous people and how you never know what will happen next in the mystery and how not everyone is who they seem to be. It is challenging and as a kid this island was my favorite because of all the exciting adventure and how you learn col stuff about people.

Love Mysteries!

V 34 Comments
8 Ghost Story

I loved it truly. The setting is perfect, with a heart warming storyline. I felt it was a beautiful love story... Perhaps asides from the twinge of sadness in it. :)
I most definitely recommend it.

I really enjoyed playing this island. It had a bit of suspense in it which made it even more fun! It was an awesome love story and I loved the ending!

I recommend it!

I loved Ghost Story. It had so many twists and turns and things you didn't expect. It had suspense that made everything very fun and exciting. And the romantic twist to it! It totally caught me off guard. I highly recommend this island and it should be put higher than Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.

This is my favourite island. The whole storyline is really interesting and I love the characters too.

V 16 Comments
9 Red Dragon

It was too awesome being a ninja! I kept failing the ninja paths because I wanted to to it over and over again. It's amazing quality and obviously well though out. Also since it's based on the magic tree house books made it even more amazing, It's also original and the details are so cool... BEST ISLAND EVER!

I like this island because it has a story in its and its cool being a ninja
I just love it so much and its good at the end when you complete the island so I give this amazing island 10/10 so I hope this gets too top

Red Dragon's story plot and well developed story characters made this island one of a kind. The story really came to life and was never a time when you weren't doing something exciting and challenging. Not to forget the beautiful scenery and detail that resembled the book in Japan so clearly. One of my favorite islands by far...

Epic, just epic...

V 31 Comments
10 Wimpy Boardwalk

If you love diary of a wimpy kid you'll love this island!

Eh, Wimpy Boardwalk wasn't truly my favorite... I didn't like it that much, and I rather prefer Classic Poptropica islands besides the copying of a book. I know that the creator of Poptropica is Jeff Kinney (author of Diary of a Wimpy Kid).

I like it because you can find coins and put fake vomit and other fun mini games. Also you get to dump popcorn on somebody.

I like it because I read diary of a wimpy kid

V 19 Comments

The Contenders

11 Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

I really liked this island. It is just like the movie. It's very fun and very interesting. Not necessarily my favorite island but definitely one of the best.

Very challenging but fun. Who doesn't love almost drowning in a river of chocolate?


I don't know never played this because it is only for members the demo is for non members

I love this island because it;s like a mix between 2005 charlie and the chocolate factory and 1971 and it's cool in the final part and the beggining chase scene was cool and very fun. Corby.C

V 20 Comments
12 Super Villain Island

Who here does not like entering and messing up bad guys dreams? And what about Zeus? And the lightning entrance? Who can hate that? Love it!

I really did love this island! The super villain and super hero islands are SO interesting. I mean, my personal favorite out of super hero and super villain island... Well, there isn't one! My favorite in the experience would probably just be super villain island. Since super hero had flying powers in it, I loved it! But I really did Love Super Villain island and I highly recommend it.

This island is what I would call the best island in Poptropica. The fact that you get to explore the minds of 4 amazing villains is extraordinary! The dreams are quite detailed and fun to explore.

It Was REALLY Hard But I Completed It! Really Good Island

V 7 Comments
13 Back Lot

This island is awesome I love it so much I just is fun I could just play it over and over and over again my favorite part is when you can relax and watch the movie

It is a great and entertaining island, you even get to do a bit of acting!

Back Lot island was super fun. It had my attention the whole time, I found it extremely entertaining. Ha! I found back lot island, which is about entertainment television, to be very entertaining. Pun. Anyways, Back Lot island is very fun, and I highly recommend it.

So fun I love driving around and making the train

V 12 Comments
14 Astro-Knights

Hands down, the most fun Poptropica island. Not only was it one of the original 9 islands, but the story is great, and the exploration of the planets and the different environments is definitely worth it. Plus the BOSS fights are really entertaining and the island provides a challenge that is both fun and exciting. It's like the best feeling in the world, when you figure out the next step in the game, and it's even better when you beat the level and defeat Mordred.

This was the most entertaining game in Poptropica so far! I love traveling into outer space to explore different planets, and the big games in the end were very entertaining. It was hard, but it really makes you feel like you accomplished something great!

I also agree that Poptropica should be played more often. Astro knights in particular could pretty much be a game in its own right.

BEST PLOT OUT OF ALL ISLANDS! my other favorite ones are: Shrink Ray, Super Power, Spy, and Reality T.V.

V 25 Comments
15 Super Power

SO SO fun! You get to become a super hero and save the town! And... I can't tell you anything else! Its for you to find out! It is one of my favorite islands to do and is just a blast!

Its awesome! When you get your super power you can fly cool huh. You also catch all the villans ok not all but still! I'm just saying its cool and awesome both! That's why so play!

I like islands that don't need a walkthrough and can figure out on my own. Super Power island is like that and it more requires skills rather than brains. People who likes excitement and less brain work (though there r still some I mean come on people its poptropica), this island is for you!

Well I'm speechless I love the island so much but I think it could use a few tweaks. Like how you have to like legit capture like 10 villains and then see the retired superhero just to get the license! I mean come on! So instead I think you just need to show the cops your a superhero making the island that bit easier to complete.
Other then that BEST ISLAND EVER! Right behind POPTROPICON!

V 21 Comments
16 Night Watch

I am not a member, but I just completed this island yesterday, in 2 days. It keeps you on your toes and includes tons of thrilling things you can do. I take back what I said about Spy Island. This totally rules! It's open to anyone now, so I reccomend you try it. I also liked how you could visit these different stores. The best parts were the air vent chase at the end and the scooter. The smartphone was extremely cool, too.

This island is the best. I finished it ages ago, but I still play it heaps. Trying to capture the bandit is so fun for me, I just never want to stop playing.

I LOVED THIS ISLAND! Night Watch was so much fun! I think it should be in at least the top 10. I HIGHLY recommend it!

Fun, but wayyy to tedious. I liked the plot but I personally don't have the time to go back and forth between 3 scenes. I enjoyed it but I thought there could have been a better change of scenery. it get kinda boring when your'e just walking between 2 or 3 scenes. I liked playing it the first time but I probably wouldn't play more than once.

V 18 Comments
17 Mocktropica

FUN FUN FUN! I have played this island many times and have loved to do it again. It's cool how you're the one who needs to save all of Poptropica. First you need to get the staff back. And many people mention 'MEGA BOTS' in the island. The boss battle is unexpected. Like all Poptropica islands there's that twist which you don't see coming. Then someone's unplugged the server lines which makes Poptropica realyyy slow! And now way could Neat Flame (my character) let that happen.

This Island is different to all the Islands, (and I can say because I have done all the islands! ) This island is one of my favourite islands, the only reason its not at number 1 is because of those STUPID GLITCHES!

Even thought not a lot of people who play poptropica are members it will be fun to complete the island over and over again

MOCKTROPICA is really awesomely fun

V 10 Comments
18 Steamworks

Fells good after completing the game at the end.
Since it's a mass island, it gives you it a challenge, but the plant monsters make it fun when defeated
Especially the plant core one of the toughest games ever created in poptropica history right now it's
Only 2012 so there may be more.

This island deserves to be ranked number one. It's story line is interesting where some of the other island's story lines are completely predicted. Other than Astro knights and Skullyduggery, this is in fact one of poptropica's hardest islands. Unlike some of the others, it uses actual combat. It deserves more credit!

If you go into zack's room you see balloon boy flying through the sky and sprocket is laughing

This is very hard, but it is one of my favorites.

V 2 Comments
19 Poptropolis Games

This island is totally flawless. You get to walk around playing very fun olympic games. So fun! In my opinion the best island there is.

Really fun game! In my opinion it's way better than reality T.V. However, I think it would be a bit more accurate if you had to be naked, being that's how it was in ancient times. But, I guess that would also mean that girls wouldn't be able to participate which wouldn't be fair.

I like how this island is like not really an island. I just like how it's so different to the rest of them.

It's just really awesome. Each of the mini games was super fun and I thought it was really cool.

V 10 Comments
20 S.O.S.

This was the first island I did and I loved it! It was fun doing all of the little games to rescue the people, and the problem solving too. I really enjoyed it, more people should play it!

This island was not bad. Tricky but interesting. You get to save all the passengers and have fun along the way.

That's mean this island is good for first island so this should be the island that every body dose

This island sucks I hate the person who made it

V 2 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Easiest Poptropica Islands Top Ten Mediterranean Islands Top 10 Universal Studios/Islands of Adventure Rides Top Ten Best Islands In the World Top Ten Best Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker Islands

List StatsUpdated 25 Feb 2017

1,000 votes
51 listings
6 years, 30 days old

Top Remixes (21)

1. Time Tangled
2. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
3. S.O.S.
1. Reality T.V.
2. Cryptids
3. Counterfeit
1. Mythology
2. Reality T.V.
3. Spy

View All 21


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.