Best Quarterbacks in NFL History

The Contenders: Page 4

61 Jake Plummer

Plummer's biggest problem was that he was Drafted by an team with little to no talent, he had to force the ball to get anything going and when he was finally traded to a team where he had something to work with he was so use to forcing the ball that he was never given a chance to develop

Underrated but he was the best bootleg

62 Ken Anderson

He is to low on the list. He went to the super bowl with no top players.

Name a better quarterback from his era. Go ahead. I'll wait. - David29414

V 2 Comments
63 Ryan Tannenhill

He's really good, but the rest of the team needs some work

Tannehill should be number 2000000 on here.

He is the best quarterback who ever lived

Ryan tannenhill sucks

V 4 Comments
64 Nick Foles Nick Foles Nicholas Edward Foles is an American football quarterback for the Los Angeles Rams of the National Football League.

He had great potential but like Kaepernick his on the tale of falling down. - htoutlaws2012

He's not the one who will take the eagles to big game.

Nick Foles is a one hit wonder and that was with Shady and Desean Jackson.

He. Is very good

V 4 Comments
65 Arnie Herber

He changed Packer history, without him Curly and the Packers would stink bad

V 1 Comment
66 Matt Flynn

If he had a solid shot at with a team he could be great. Look at the comebacks he had at Green Bay in place of Rodgers with no perpetration.

V 2 Comments
67 Danny White

Took the Cowboys to three straight NFC championships, should be 25 spots higher

68 Trevor Siemian Trevor Siemian

Although he was just a rookie he showed confidence in himself showing john elway he can play this game

This is the coolest QUARTERBACK


Horid henry

69 Joe Kapp

Roughest toughest quarterback to play the game. Steve Sabol will back me up on that! (drafted by the Minnesota Vikings 1967)

The forgotten man. The toughest quarterback to play the game! Steve Sabol will back me up on that!

70 Doug Williams Doug Williams Douglas Lee "Doug" Williams is a former American football quarterback and former head coach of the Grambling State Tigers football team.


Lucky Baltimore picked him up

Best qb not enough credit for what he did should be higher

He's awesome

V 2 Comments
71 Andy Dalton Andy Dalton Andrew Gregory Dalton is an American football quarterback for the Cincinnati Bengals of the National Football League.

I'm shocked that Andy Dalton is in the top 65:) lol

He needs some help

I personally don't care for Andy Dalton, but I am a Bengals fan and I find it appaling that he is not on this list. Ryan Leaf? Are you KIDDING?


V 2 Comments
72 Bernie Kosar

I watch him bring the Browns back in the game. He made the other team pay for there mistake.

Probably the most football smart quarterback in nfl history

V 3 Comments
73 Tobin Rote

Under-rated Charger QB of the 1960s.
MVP of the league. - AFCMan

74 Jim Hart

I loved to watch jim play when I was a kid. he was a great player and leader he just never had a great team of players around him.

He was a Cardinals Leader and should be about five places higher.

Jim hart was great in the 70's - only the cowboys could beat st louis back then - he should be wayyy higher (top 40)

75 David Garrard

No one will take that hail Mary away from him

76 Carson Wentz Carson Wentz Carson Wentz is an American football quarterback for the Philadelphia Eagles of the National Football League. He played college football at North Dakota State University. He was drafted by the Eagles with the second overall pick of the 2016 NFL draft, becoming the highest drafted quarterback from an more.
77 Josh McCown Josh McCown

He should have replaced Jay Cutler forever!

How far is ej manuel he sucks bad josh is better than a landslide!

V 1 Comment
78 Geno Smith Geno Smith Eugene Cyril Smith III, better known as Geno Smith, is an American football quarterback for the New York Jets of the National Football League.

What the hell is he doing on this list - Itckdos

Really good QB he is so under rated

Best rookie qb in 2014


79 Trent Dilfer

The one hit wonder of QB's - htoutlaws2012

80 Bert Jones

Every body forgets this guy!
Ask the quarterbacks of the 70's and they will tell you what was and would have been if not for Bert getting injured!

Lots of people never saw this guy, he was easy in the top 50.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Fantasy Football Quarterbacks in NFL History Top Ten Lefty Quarterbacks in NFL History Top Ten Best Cornerbacks in NFL History Top Ten NFL Quarterbacks of All Time Best NFL Quarterbacks of 2013

List Stats

17,000 votes
138 listings
10 years, 342 days old

Top Remixes (161)

1. Joe Montana
2. Peyton Manning
3. John Elway
1. Tom Brady
2. Joe Montana
3. Peyton Manning
1. Peyton Manning
2. Dan Marino
3. Joe Montana

View All 161


Bret Farve?
Manning is over-rated!
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.