Top 10 Questions to Ask Blind Guardian Fans

Three way tie between And Then There Was Silence, Thorn and one of their more recent, The Throne.

A tie between Harvest of Sorrow, The Script for my Requiem and The Soulforged for me

Night at the Opera, love the progressive sound and production improvements added to it.

I'd have to say Nightfall. I actually like the interludes (some complain about them).

The Throne, Majesty, Valhalla, Nightfall, Time What Is Time

Memories Of A Time To Come (best of) - 2012.
I also made a list where you can see my preferences and explanations - Top Ten Most Beautiful Blind Guardian Album Covers

For me - Majesty.

I want to say Fly, because of how this could've fitted easily on one of their earlier albums. Hansi is that primed.

I'd say Battlefield

I think they would because a lot of their lyrics are inspired by Tolkien.

A Past and Future Secret or Theatre of Pain

Journey Through the Dark, Banish from Sanctuary, Guardian of the Blind, Majesty.

My top 3 from their 1992 album: Journey Through the Dark, Time What is Time, Theater of Pain.
And of course, The Bard's Song (In The Forest).

The Ninth Wave, The Throne, The Holy Grail, Grand Parade

A lot of good songs here - Thorn, Time Stands Still (At the Iron Hill), Nightfall and the criminally underrated When Sorrow Sang! But Mirror Mirror takes the cake for the best one in my opinion

And Then There Was Silence, Battlefield, Age of False Innocence.