Top 10 Reasons to Hate Puella Magi Madoka Magica

I HATE THIS SHOW!!!!! Since the other list wasn't enough, here's its SEQUEL!!!!!!!!
The Top Ten
1 Uninteresting Story
2 The Art Style is Bad
3 Annoying Characters
4 It Lacks Creativity
5 It is a Middle Finger to the Magical Girl Genre
6 It Overshadows All the Good Anime
7 It's Highly Overrated

Some people just never learn, do they? Or in this case, they just can't take criticism.

Overrated =/= automatically terrible. How many times we have to go over this?

It's not overrated it got 2 movies and rebellion it even won an award.

I agree with you on that statement.

8 It's Extremely Boring
9 It's Generic
10 It Has Unlikable Characters

The only good one was that blond chick and her death was too confusing and sudden for me to grief for her at all. All Madoka did was cry every god damn episode and did nothing to help her friends, then suddenly out of nowhere we're supposed to believe that she is the most powerful being ever or something and practically a "god" and we're supposed to like the once boring and lacklustre Homura. Every other character (including blue hair and red hair girls) were not noticeable at all and their deaths were supposed to feel emotional and depressing but I felt nothing for them.

That all depends on the person but the only likable characters are Madoka Homura (Not really because she did everything wrong! ) but she is very strong and Kyoko!

The Contenders
11 It's Boring

I know it gets much better later on but even with that inspiration I wasnt able to get through the first couplet of episodes when I had gotten through other anime shows that were boring at first

12 It Tries Too Hard to Be Emotional

It doesn't try hard to be emotional. The writers know how to write something emotional without it being forced. Which is basically Madoka Magica. If you want an example of a magical girl anime that tries to hard to be emotional, it's Daybreak Illusion. (Which is actual trash. Not Madoka Magica)

If you're 15, you might relate to that. Otherwise it is indeed try too be so emo, it becomes a parody of itself.

13 Obnoxious Fans
14 It's Cliche
15 Lazy Animation
16 It's a Sailor Moon Rip-Off

Also if anyone really believes PMMM rips off Sailor Moon then with that logic every Magical Girl anime who sticks with the typical magical girl formula also rips off Sailor Moon.

Well sayaka look like ami and their are madoka vs sailor moon so much and madoka version of moon pride and all the other song.

How? It's literally nothing like Sailor Moon.

But I think it a rip off of sailor moon

17 Lack of Character Development

Well Madoka in Rebellion didn't cry as much Kyoko wasn't such a rebel and Homura is the most developed in the anime Sayaka went to being so stupid and thinking that being a magical girl is about being fame but in the end she realized why heroes exist Mami is the least interesting and undeveloped in the anime.

18 It Takes Forever for the Characters to Blink

I don't understand why anyone would have a problem with that.

19 Fans Get Triggered If You Say Anything Bad About It

It's cause the things you say are very lame and unreasonable.

20 It's Meanspirited

Define how Madoka Magica is meanspirited

21 Too Many Death Scenes
22 It Has No Black People
23 It Tricks Kids Into Liking It

I like PMMM, but I must admit I'm not too fond of the whole cutesy facade thing. I've heard stories of parents who showed the series to their young children, only to by utterly shocked and disturbed when Episode 3 rolled around. The posters, opening, etc. are all extremely deceptive. I understand that it's supposed to make the dark twists more shocking, but the creators should have thought of the risk that kids would wind up watching it due to the cute appearance.

In the first place its not even for kids its rated pg 13 for a reason. Kids are way too young to understand the story, I found out about this when I was 9 and I had absolute no idea about what was going on but now I do since I am at the right age.

Watch Happy Tree Friends instead. That's show is actually funny.

I don't watch nor play those so I don't know.

24 Only Madoka and Homura Shines

Well, Sayaka has more episodes dedicated to her development than Madoka and Homura, so

Untrue. Like I said before, they all shine and Homura and Sayaka shine the most.

I wish that Mami and Nagisa can shine

25 It Single-Handedly Overshadowed Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha in the West.

In the East too, I kid you not, it's considered the 3rd most popular anime in Japan in the top 10 with no entries in the Nanoha franchise in sight.

8Load More
PSearch List