Reasons Puella Magi Madoka Magica is Better Than Winx Club

The Top Ten

1 Puella Magi Madoka Magica has better characters

The Winx characters all have same personalities and often it is hard to distinguish between them because they're all like clones of each other. - TwilightKitsune

2 Madoka is a better person than Bloom

Madoka actually has character development and a personality. In the last episode she ended up dying just so no witches would harm the human world. Bloom, on the other hand, gets away from everything, she breaks school rules and somehow always gets a pass through them. - TwilightKitsune

I think both are crap. Bloom (from what I heard) is a rule-breaker who gets away with breaking those rules. Madoka (from what I saw) is just plain useless, until the end where she gets a BS power-up. - SelfDestruct

3 Puella Magi Madoka Magica has better character design

The characters are prettier and have better body shapes. In Winx, every single chaarcter is so thin they look like Scarecrows. - TwilightKitsune

4 Winx Club is stereotypical

For example, Stella is fashion obsessed and adores every boy she meets, always cares about how she looks, whines over clothing and is an extreme shopaholic. I hate those stereotypes - TwilightKitsune

Stereotypes are evil.-Vestalis

5 Puella Magi Madoka Magica has a better plot

Girls turning into magical girls to fight witches, Homura's past with Madoka, the time travel are all better than an unsuspecting earth girl who finds out she's a fairy. - TwilightKitsune

6 Puella Magi Madoka Magica has a better sound track

According to an imdb review, the theme song was made by a guy when he hummed a tune in the toilet. Such truth. - TwilightKitsune

The opening of Madoka, connect by ClariS was sure catchy(even It misleads people), the main ending, Magia from Kalafina was also cool. There are also a bunch of beautiful OSTs(thanks to the amazing composer Yuki Kajiura who made the OSTs). Will Winx Club ever be able to do something as great as this? - MLPFan

7 Bloom is a mary-sue and gets everything easily

Bloom is the Dragon fire princess, head of a rock band, popular kid at school, everyone loves her... WILL YOU JUST LET SOMEONE ELSE HAVE SOME ATTENTION, IGINIO STRAFFI? - TwilightKitsune

8 Winx is overrated

It has too much fans - TwilightKitsune

@TwilightKitsune, being overrated doesn't mean it's bad. But I agree, PMMM is better.

9 Puella Magi Madoka Magica has better villains

Trix, go back to your cereal box. - RoseWeasley

Homura Akemi and Sakura Kyoko started out great! They were even better when they became good guys. The Winx Club villains were named after a cereal company. The main Winx Villain is a cereal box. It uses it's muesli and granola powers to slow down the fairies. - TwilightKitsune

Not to mention the witches. They had better back stories than the villains of Winx, True, their backstories weren't shown, But they were magical girls who fell to despair before they died and became witches. - MLPFan

Witches (not those stereotipical ones with the pointy hat and nose) are better villians than the Trix. Trix, go back to your cereal box.-Vestalis

10 Stella is a horrible friend

She's a bad friend, she is always a liability on everyone - TwilightKitsune

The Contenders

11 Musa's a horrible singer
12 PMMM has Better Transformation Sequences than Winx Club
BAdd New Item