Top 10 Reasons Super Smash Bros. Melee is Hands-Down the Most Overrated Game in the Series

xandermartin98

The Top Ten

1 Melee fanboys often treat Brawl and Smash 4 like the absolute worst things ever because of it

That's why I Hates Melee Fanbois

SSBU is the best Smash Bros. game and than Melee and 64 and Brawl and 3DS.

2 Nostalgia blindness
3 The character balancing is actually somehow even WORSE than it was in Brawl and Smash 4
4 Something like half of the entire character roster is literally made out of clones
5 Brawl and Smash 4 were both way bigger and overall more polished games
6 Many of its stages are almost as bad for competitive play as Brawl's

In what way? Battlefield, dreamland and FoD are very similar to each other, FD is battlefield with removed platforms, pokemon stadium isn't bad, just some of the stage changes are dumb, and yoshi's story is battlfield with moving cloud platforms and tilted ledges.

7 The AI is the absolute worst in the series
8 Fox and Falco should NOT be this damned overpowered
9 It wasn't even the best Gamecube game; look at Resident Evil 4 and the first two Metroid Primes for examples of reasons why
10 Yes, the single-player mode was good, but it really wasn't THAT good

The Contenders

11 People treat it way too seriously as a competitive fighting game, even more so than they did and still do with Smash 4
12 Seriously, it had Pichu in its playable character roster

That is like rubbing it in Raichu's face. If characters like Pichu can get in, just put in Raichu already.

13 The later games also had way better character rosters
14 Target Test being changed in Brawl REALLY wasn't that big of a deal
15 Even the graphics were laughable compared to some of the other games on Gamecube
16 There's a very big difference between having the best soundtrack of a series and the best actual gameplay
17 Though not as badly as in the later games, the single-player mode still involves a LOT of cheap/fake difficulty
18 It's the one game in the series that literally just about no one ever uses powerups in
19 It should have had Final Smashes way before Brawl, but ended up not having them due to how phenomenally rushed it was
20 Seriously, it's the most rushed-in-development game in the entire series, and it actually kind of shows at times
21 You Need to have a Pikmin Save Data on your Gamecube Memory Card just to get a trophy.

So, Basically, if you didn't have enough time to buy Pikmin, You're never gonna get all the trophies.

22 The stages were not so creative
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top Ten Reasons Why Super Smash Bros Melee Is Not Really Part of the Series Top 10 Most Annoying Things About Super Smash Bros Melee Best Super Smash Bros Melee Characters Top 10 Super Smash Bros Melee Stages Top 10 Super Smash Bros Melee Newcomers

List Stats

22 listings
1 year, 323 days old

Top Remixes

1. Melee fanboys often treat Brawl and Smash 4 like the absolute worst things ever because of it
2. Nostalgia blindness
3. The character balancing is actually somehow even WORSE than it was in Brawl and Smash 4
xandermartin98

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P