Top Ten Reasons Total Drama Revenge of the Island Is Better Than Pahkitew Island

I liked roti better then tdpi and I'll tell you why(just saying I still liked pahkitew Island and all stars is still poopoo)

The Top Ten

1 A Defined Antagonist

Chris is an antagonist in every TD season.

The primary antagonist was Sugar... She got Ella and Jasmine eliminated. - Turkeyasylum

In roti it was definitely Scott as a antagonist in pahkitew island was it max scarlet or sugar - Shartfart

Scott is a better antagonist than Sugar.

V 3 Comments
2 Cameos in Revenge of the Island

I loved the hidden cameos or "Easter eggs" that were cleverly placed in the show.

Cody's shoe made a cameo in Mo Monkeys Mo Problems.

There weren't any cameos in pahkitew island none of the past contestents were even heard or mentioned - Shartfart

3 More Exaggerated

But in a funny way.

Since many animals were mutated it was a lot funnier - Shartfart

4 Less Annoying Characters

Max: time to get evil just anoying

The characters in Revenge of the Island weren't as good as the TDI cast, but at least they were tolerable. The characters in Pahkitew are just a bunch of jokes.

Leonard Ella beardo j j j just shut THE MOTHER LOVING HELL UP - Shartfart

5 Back to the Birthplace of Total Drama

Ahh camp wawanakwa wait who's this pahkitew island and who does it think it is - Shartfart

6 Better Finale

None of the eliminated Characters in Pahkitew Island except for Jasmine and Dave returned like usual

Roti finale is finally not a race but a duel but in pahkitew island it's a damn race again - Shartfart

I hate the TRROTI finale! The finalist are too casuals!

The only thing that makes the TDPI not the worst finale was the dreadful TDAS finale. - Turkeyasylum

7 More Realistic Characters

I personally thought the producers were running out of ideas when they made Leanord, Beardo, Ella, Shawn, Max, and Rodney. In my opinion, all six of them only had one dimension of them and you could always expect them to act the same way. Dave got a little bit delusional at the end, but before that he was a decent character. Topher was an original character that seemed more realistic because there ARE some psycho fans of shows similar to Topher. Amy and Sammy/Samey were both good characters who entertained me for quite a while. Jasmine and Sky were also quite good. Sugar may have been a jerk, but her design and personality were original and I liked her more than some of the fodder mentioned earlier for that. I personally liked Scarlett because she had tons of different sides to her, creepily knew everything about everyone, and was a bit cynical at times. - Turkeyasylum

Too bad Mike didn't win ROTI! He won TDAS which I am happy!

People like Leonard beardo max and Ella don't exist - Shartfart

mike wasn'

V 1 Comment
8 Nobody Goes Insane

I personally disliked revenge of the island. - Therandom

Dave is literally insane at the end plus I think Dave is dead - Shartfart

Did ya forget about Commando Zoey and Lightning wanting to KILL Cameron? - Turkeyasylum

9 No Sugar

I already mentioned annoying characters but sugar deserves a special entry for being so terrible just terrible - Shartfart

I can't believe Chris let her off without any repercussions (unlike Scarlett and Max, far superior villains of TDPI than Sugar).

10 Better Relationships

Shaun and jasmine in pahkitew Sam and Dakota and mike and Zoey in roti though I hate the two couples in roti so boring - Shartfart

The Contenders

11 Because Revenge of the Island Has Dakota!

Let's get this to number 5, at least.


12 It Has Dawn

Dawn is the best Total Drama character ever!

Dawn was great!



13 Because They Have Mike

Definitely. I love him!

14 Kelly the Old Lady from Ridonculous Race Wasn't There to Lame It Up

@Anon. Kelly wasn't in that season. She didn't debut until three seasons later with "The Ridonculous Race".

Bye bye old lady.

15 Macarthur Doesn't Take the Show Over

To the one who put this reason on the list, congratulations, you made me want to suicide slowly and painfully, thank you very much

16 It Has Anne Maria
17 Gwen Makes an Appearance
18 Beardo Isn't There Spitting on Everybody
19 The Characters Aren't Clinically Insane
20 Ezekiel Makes an Appearance
21 Because Staci is Better Than Amy

Amy is cool (and Sammy is cool too of course) and she's better than the unless and boring Stacy.

It's a good reason.

22 Cameron is Better Than Rodney
23 Revenge of the Island Has Lovable Characters, While Pahkitew Island Has Only One Lovable Character.

The character I love in Pahkitew Island is Ella - Gehenna

24 Chris Gets Punished at the End of TDROTI, While TDPI Leaves Him Unpunished

TDPI was Chris' last year as host of "Total Drama". I kinda wish his character got some closure, before he gets replaced with someone better than him: Don (the host of TDRR).

25 Better Characters
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Best Total Drama: Pahkitew Island Characters Most Annoying Total Drama Pahkitew Island Characters Best Contestants Who Debuted In Total Drama Pahkitew Island Best Total Drama: Pahkitew Island Episodes Best Total Drama: Revenge of the Island Characters

List Stats

25 listings
4 years, 9 days old

Top Remixes

1. More Exaggerated
2. A Defined Antagonist
3. Cameos in Revenge of the Island
1. A Defined Antagonist
2. More Exaggerated
3. More Realistic Characters
1. A Defined Antagonist
2. Back to the Birthplace of Total Drama
3. Less Annoying Characters


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.