Top Ten Reasons That Warriors Is Better Than Harry Potter

It took me a very long time to think up who to compare Warriors to.

The Top Ten

1 The deaths are sadder

I was so sad when I read Yellowfang's death I just started crying at school. I think it was sadder because IT'S AN OLD FLUFFY CAT! NOT A HUMAN! A CAT!

Doubt that! They're even for me! Sadder deaths? I cried for Sirius but not for warriors! - Catsarah123

Cyclne, Yes I have seen Warriors books in the front of book shops - Bloodfire of DeathClan

Everyone cries. I hear lots of stories of people reding a death and then they freak out - AnonymousChick

2 They don't have the same main character

We like unique people! Harry Potter wasn’t always right! Plus, we get to see it from another point of view!

I don't want to hear about the same persons opinion over and over. I want to know what other characters think.

Well, except that narration by a single character is used in only about 90℅ of books ever.

Like I want it to see what VOLDEMORT Is thinking (yes sometimes you can but its still kinda harry) And in warriors it changed from firestar, to another cat, and another cat so on

3 Cats are awesome

That's not a reason. Cats are a beautiful creature, but it's not a reason of speech for an argument. - Swellow

Cat power

That's right.

4 It pulls you in

Harry potter boring, but WARRIORS was fun to read. - BlazeHeart

I am obsessed with Warriors and proud of it! Except I'm going insane because I can't find the next book, but still.

They say I'm obsessed - AnonymousChick

It's just so easy to get drawn in

5 You adore the characters


Hollyleaf and Ivypool rules! - BlazeHeart

Warrior cats characters are like pieces of cardboard, while Harry Potter characters are realistic and we'll developed. Warriors is incredibly overrrated


6 The cats are unique

Yes. Hollyleaf is my personal favorite character. She’s not an average she-cat. I haven’t read Harry Potter. I only read some part of the last book for some reason and it was boring. When my a friend told me about Warriors, I instantly fell in love.

7 Erin puts the "best series" in "best series ever"

Coming from a person who has followed both fandoms pseudo -religiously, I can tell you warriors doesn't trump Harry Potter. And I remember a large chuck of my elementary life was spent pretending to be a cat. Admittedly years I wish to forget, but it shows the magnitude of how much the series impacted me as a person, and I can still say Harry Potter is greater. Boy, my life is ruled by books... ! - keycha1n

My mom likes the books and she's a grown up

8 You start to care about nature

No! Two legs! Don't destroy the clans! - AnonymousChick

Hug trees!

I shall say that I hate ron for driving that car.
1. it pollutes the air
2. it destroyed the whomping willow

9 They have lots of books

Warrior cats have 50 something books and dumb harry potter only has seven boring books! I hate harry potter, I was reading it I'm past page 100 AND THEY JUST GOT IN THE SCHOOL!

But nothing compared to 36 books, 6 series, not mention the super editions and the novellas

And seven books isn't that much? - Swellow

Yes that is awesome X)

10 You cry at the deaths

I like the Warriors series, but think Harry potter is better. - Dawnstar

Flametail's death was very, very sad to me at least because I enjoyed reading in his point of view - Puppytart

Warriors is so much better than magical wizards running around casting spells

I cried seeing Sirius Black die, but not Silverstream or firestar okay?

The Contenders

11 Warriors is very original

It is more original. Tell me have you ever looked at a cat and said "Hmm I am gonna make a series about a bunch of cats that live in clans, and have a code, and blah blah blah." That is creative

I really love both Harry Potter and Warriors, making a difficult decision. Saying "the deaths are sadder" or "cats are awesome" isn't really an argument, considering that they are opinions (though cats are pretty awesome, but you get my point). Harry Potter has tons of original stuff, and clever names, but Warriors;
"huh, let's make talking cats that live in four clans and are part of a religion! Ha, that'll be fun! " and it's a bit random but AWESOME. Love them both, though :D

-Emberflight of StormClan

12 It makes you think more about what it's like to be a cat

Yeah, now I wish to be a warrior cat - BlazeHeart

I completely agree.

so true

13 The story is better and creative
14 You get mad when the characters get taunted

When Flametail taunted Lionblaze to cross the ShadowClan border, I wanted to jump out and say, "Hey Flametail! Why don't YOU cross the border, you ShadowClan foxheart! "

But Flametail is pretty sweet.

15 You feel for the clans

Their clan disasters make you feel sad, when a clan you LOVE wins a battle, (lets face it) YOu burst up jumping and literally dancing during a test

16 It has way more characters

It might get confusing, but it seems more real. It makes me like they’re real clans.

17 Harry Potter (the character) is mouse-brained
BAdd New Item