Top 10 Reasons Why Amy Rose is Better Than Princess Peach


The Top Ten

1 Amy is hotter

Peach is never hot, her chess is never big, her dress covers on top of her chess, nothing! The reason why I'm saying that Amy is hotter that means like her collar opens more and her dress is Sleeveless this is possibly why I'm saying about this - bugger

You're basically constantly referring to the exposure of her breasts/chest as opposed to her actually being hot.
And chess is a board game and not part of an appearance. - Qryzx

Is this list serious? And this being #1 is hilarious. It's also funny most these list have this in the top tens. It shows you dumb peach haters are just jealous that she's much more prettier than you.

And for Amy rose? She's the actual stalker, whinny, bratty, controlling, not peach.

How can animals NOT be hot?

Amy Rose in my prospective is really ugly.

V 7 Comments
2 Amy is stronger

LOL, Um, No.
*Has speed, and a hammer.
*Can throw her hammer, create wind with it, use it to propel upwards, go invisible, distract her opponent, go hyper (slightly increases her stats and that's all, no super form), form a shield, boxing glove, Etc.

*Has an Umbrella, Sports equipment, Frying pan, A Lamb, Heart Element and Toad.
*A huge selection of magic, including 4 Mood Swings (note that her Joy emotion can control wind, meaning it could counter Amy's whirlwind), Floating (she can pull off with her Heart Magic), Psych Bomb (Bomb-Omb Barrage if you like that better), Freeze Frame (creates an empty frame that freezes trapped enemies inside, lasts five seconds), Status Effect Removal, Comeback (Brings back a fallen ally), Etc.

Amy would win at strength because she can hold an enormous hammer effortlessly.

Peach would win at magic and endurance.

Amy wins at battle experience and speed.

Amy's weakness:
Her obsession ...more - Qryzx

Which is why she's able to defend herself, unlike that princess brat! - KennyRulz244444

Amy can be stronger than her but I don't remember her strength in the Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games series. Lets say how heavy her Piko Piko Hammer. Peach only has like love powers, a Frying Pan, and a Toad which blocks her and also counter attack with it. Amy's hammer can beat up Peach or drops Peach's IQ number. I'm SORRY PRINCESS PEACH FANS! - bugger

Amy is not stronger! She only knows sonic really well and has not taken time to meet tails!

V 5 Comments
3 Amy is cuter

Peach herself tries to be cute but Amy's cuteness beats her up like a boss - bugger

Not really, she's scarier, kind of like Princess Nehema from Eversion.

She's still better than Peach though. - KennyRulz244444

This is the second thing you mentioned about their appearance and it's not even 2 reasons apart.
I could report either reason because it is technically a duplicate reason. - Qryzx

Have you seen her when she gets mad? It’s like the Devil, she tries to kill people with her hammer

V 3 Comments
4 Amy's design doesn't have much pink

You only see pink just from Amy's hair and you see most Pink from her Dress. Boys hate pink but I am a male and I like Pink. So Amy Rose wins, just to say - bugger

So Peach wearing just one pink dress makes her bad, but Amy's red sleeveless dress (that doesn't even cover her legs all the way) somehow makes up for the pink on her body and makes her pink fur that would go almost all the way around her body make her less pink than Peach? How? - Qryzx

Logic: Peach wearing one pink short sleeved body to toe dress makes her more pink than a pink hedgehog that just has a sleeveless red dress covering her torso, red and white boots, and white gloves.
Amy IS a pink hedgehog so your logic doesn't make sense. - Qryzx

Um, Amy’s whole body is pink, so your logic isn’t really making sense. - Videogamesgal

V 7 Comments
5 Amy is for all ages

The game, Super Princess Peach is possibly the only Nintendo games to be for little girls but I don't know if it's the only one. Amy's popularity kind of beats up Peach because we have lots of teenagers that likes Amy from Sonic while Peach is for little girls. I'm just saying. But I do like little kids not meaning that I'm Barney The Dinosaur, sometimes people likes kids. - bugger

She appeals to any demographic, Peach is just for little girls (even they wouldn't like her). - KennyRulz244444

Just because Peach wears a girly outfit doesn't mean she applies only to little kids. - Qryzx

Just because Peach wears a frilly pink ball gown doesn’t mean Peach applies only to little kids. - Videogamesgal

V 3 Comments
6 Amy's voice is less annoying

Neither of them have annoying voices in my opinion! - HeavyDonkeyKong

Listen to Lisa Ortiz's voice, it sounds beautiful.
Listen to Samantha Kelly (who also does Toad, but she's better at doing him), it sounds like nails on chalk.

However, they're just voices so they don't really affect the character. - KennyRulz244444

The voices don't affect negatively the characters. - yamionthetrap

Reasons why I go against this:
1. The voices don’t matter
2. At least Peach’s vocabulary isn’t just “Mario! ” The only word Amy knows is “Sonic! ”
3. Watch Sonic X and tell me that Amy’s voice is less annoying then

V 4 Comments
7 Amy is richer

Um, Amy Rose has 2 rings both positioned of her fists, When you play as Amy just like in Sonic games, you pick up rings to keep you alive. I only see like 6 coins in Peach's castle in Mario 64.

Keep in mind that I'm running out of ideas in this list - bugger

Um really? Having six coins laying around doesn't mean that's her budget.
If you were to have no money lying around at your home, does that mean you're broke? No.
In Mario games, 100 coins make a life. However, losing a life doesn't mean Mario is losing coins.
On the other hand, Sonic and Amy rely on Rings to survive.
What am I getting at? Well, if they're using rings to survive then why would they use it as currency?
If they aren't using their rings to buy stuff, technically the rings don't make them richer.

And also, don't make a list if you can't support it with concrete reasons. - Qryzx

Peach may own the Mushroom Kingdom (possibly, we never see the king or queen) but Amy is richer when it comes to rings. - KennyRulz244444

True, but the Mario Bros universe doesn't use rings for currency. - Qryzx

Logic Fail.
Amy has two rings on her hands and are somehow worth more than Peach's budget.
Peach's budget is approx. 1 Billion coins thanks to Mario.

Do you still think Amy is richer? At least Mario doesn't lose his money each time he bumps into an enemy. - Qryzx

Peach is a princess idiots. - Videogamesgal

V 2 Comments
8 Amy is more beautiful

Isn't this the same as two of the other's on the list?!?!? In my opinion! - HeavyDonkeyKong

Isn't this the same as two of the others on the list?!?!? In my opinion! - HeavyDonkeyKong

As HDK said, isn't this the same? - KennyRulz244444

You have mentioned her appearance 3 times and I'm not even at the tenth 'reason'. - Qryzx

9 Amy has better quotes

But shes always demanding to know where everybody is hiding sonic right?!?!? - HeavyDonkeyKong

Oh yes... 'OH SONIC I FOUND YO- opps your not sonic! ' Great quality lines lol

"Never fear, Amy Rose is here! "
Yeah, High quality lol. - Qryzx

All I hear is “Sonic! ” She drives me insane

V 1 Comment
10 Amy tries her best to help

If you play as Amy in the Sonic Adventure games you see her compassionate side. She looks after a bird that Dr Eggman is trying to catch and she even befriends E-102 Gamma. At times she can be a bit needy of Sonic but her heart's in the right place.

She puts effort into her work and actions compared to Peach.

Amy manages to befriend an enemy and help a flicky bird while Peach is just nothing. - KennyRulz244444

So you deny that she's appearing in spin-offs, did you?

Research is the key to your brain. - yamionthetrap

Hello? Super Mario Bros 2 USA (Playable), Super Mario Bros 3 (Gives P Wings by Letter), Super Mario World (Giving Mushrooms in the final boss fight with Bowser), - Qryzx

Super Princess Peach, Super Smash Bros, Mario and Rabbids, Super Mario 3D World, and other games. PAY ATTENTION

V 3 Comments

The Contenders

11 Amy blows kisses

Her modern design sucks and is way too overrated. She does not deserve to wear a dress (skirt) that sticks out like a tutu.

Peach has blown kisses when she wins in Mario Kart.


Her modern design is awesome. classicist clearly.

V 2 Comments
12 Amy is funny
13 Amy always takes care of Cream

Princess Peach takes care of her 1 million+ toads, what’s your point?

14 She is better at swimming

Ironic since the main protagonist of the games can't swim. - Qryzx



15 Her special moves are better

Oh, You mean their names? Names on special abilities don't matter that much. - Qryzx

Her magic moves aren't cringy.

16 Peach just cares about herself

Clearly whoever made this reason isn’t paying attention to the games. Mario and Luigi series, all the times where Mario saves Peach, and Super Mario Sunshine. PAY ATTENTION PEOPLE!
Amy only cares about herself and that stupid blue rat, especially in Sonic X!

BAdd New Item