Top Ten Reasons Why Books Are Better Than Movies
The Top Ten
You can imagine characters, places, scenes just the way you want them to be. Books allow your mind to be creative.
Okay. 500 people read a Harry Potter book for the first time. They will have each 500 different versions of how Harry, Ron, Hermione look like. Next they watch the movie. Now they think that only Harry looks like Radcliffe, Ron like Grint, and Hermione like Watson.
YES! In books, no one can make fun of my cartoon like perception of the world
I agree with nearly all the items on this list but books really force a person to use his/her imagination.
Logan Lerman was about five years older than Percy shoulda been in both The Lightning Thief and The Sea of Monsters.
In movies, a lot of times, brilliantly developed characters fail to impress because of the actor's inability to perform the role.
Ah, but great acting cannot be surpassed. Similarly to what you say, there are often poorly written characters. - Billyv
Movies always remove your vision of the book and bad acting ruins the book. EVERYTHING in the movie ruins the book!
I gotta vote this. All characters in books possess the Oscar in my mind.
You can read a book at your own pace. You can either enjoy it slowly over a few weeks, or you can devour it in a day or two.
I think books are better than movies and I'm also writing a report on why books are better than movies so can please help me because its due on Friday please help me show my class why books are better than movies
Mini series are also better than movies for this exact reason. I hate movies.
Not really, Books can wear off the quality real fast on paperbacks.
I need to pay my respects to this amazing list. Let's have a moment of commemorative silence.
Apart from doing something recreational, you're also doing something productive.
Books can really be helpful in improving your English or any other language that you read.
I know, right? The best part is you can sound smarter when you use harder words. Hey, I've done that before! - MysticDragon_
This is amazing how did you get this much information guys please tell me
Apart from narrating the storyline in depth, books explain the thoughts going through a characters' minds while performing an action, which lets you connect with them better and immerse yourself deeper in the story. Example: The Shining - Book VS Movie. While reading the book I felt Jack was a close friend and I started caring for him. But his character in the movie felt sort of underdeveloped, the Overlook hotel too. It was the main reason why Stephen King hated the movie adaptation of his masterpiece.
How is some text on paper more detailed than a whole crew of actors and visual effects and background?
Because some movies don't involve all the details they sometimes leave some details and ideas out because you cannot fit all the ideas of the novel in an one hour book that is why books are better because they have every single detail.
Books also often develop their characters more and add multiple dimensions to them.
Authorial intent always messes everything up. I want to decide how everything happens.
Totally concur. I love films but I'm forced to imagine only what the actors project. With books, the imagination is limitless. I don't want to be shown what's going on; I want to use my imagination and be creative with it.
Yeah! Books allow you to create the scene the way you want it to look, so you imagine.
You need to use your imagination because in life imagination is important
Even the simplest characters like Greg Heffley are spot on in the books, but just seem off in movies. Zachary Gordon wasn't that bad, but since there were at least 7 Wimpy Kid books out by the time the movie version of Dog Days came out. So, they tried a remake. Those never work.
when I read captain underpants, they described him better but in the movies, they don't describe him a bit.
In movies they often do not say what the characters are thinking, we can just only look at the way they act, while in books there is usually sentences of the way the characters feel (for example "the heart is beating faster") and/or think. Such a way an actor from movies can not expose.
Harry Potter looked way different in my head, and I almost wouldn't watch the second movie, because I didn't like how almost all my favorite characters were changed.
So true. Movies are the reason why my mom, dad, and sister are all blind.
Movies are bad for your eyes and so are books if you try reading them in the dark trust me that was not pleasant
No its actually proven that T.V. screens and movies are not bad for your eyes. People say, "don't get to close to the telly, or you'll need glasses"
but its not true, so yeah, learn your facts...
On the other hand books are too. I do not agree with it
It depends on the movie and the book, but I must agree. Percy was funnier in the books, Tris wasn't so girly, Katniss stayed the same but I just couldn't get interested in the movies.
You can get bored at a theatre while when you wanna leave the rest of the book for the next day, you can do that!
That is subjective
What I said for Books more detailed.
Actually, yeah, they do. Usually, it's at the end of the book and features other books by the author.
Television movies have more adds
Yea that's great reason
That is subjective
Yep. Memories that feel like amazing dreams
A lot of directors are so focused on making money that they stop caring about their movies' quality. They know what sells, and so, they follow the basic blueprint which is sure to get the masses filling up theatres. An infamous example: The Transformers Series.
Breaking News : Modern publishing has been doing this for decades - creating popular and "name" authors who have talent but aren't necessarily writing better fiction than people who can't attract a publisher or get quickly sent to limited run or ceased publication status
Totally true and reading makes you a better speller
But the chart says...
Ever heard of streaming services? You can watch movies on your phone watchu mean.
You cannot take a movie in school can you?
You will have to worry about having electricity to play the movie. You just need a comfortable space and good lighting to read a book.
They are but when you get a screen that small, its kind of worthless.
Nothing ticks me off more than a good book being turned into trash because the movie was poorly developed.
Yes of course they are... I totally agree...
You can really understand whats happening, in movies it always a bit of a jumble of explotions and yelling, in books way more understandable when there is a fighting scene
Movies Can Be More Exciting
I disagree as much as you can disagree with something or someone - Potterhead2001
A good story can't be told to it's full potential in two and a half hours.
Movies don't have the same budget as books, books budget is imagination
That is true they will for get it
We can read books again and again.
It is true because it gives a lot of useful thing to improve your reading level
Books help in developing speaking and reading skills
Speaking? By reading? Wouldn't you improve your oral skills more by a medium with actual dialogue - movieman666
IT'S GOOD BRUH
That's why in schools use books for education
A story you have read over a few days stays with you longer.
Yes books take your mind for peace
That is subjective
A good actor can be much more expressive than text, due to being able to see what the character's going through rather than having to rely on the narrator/characters to convey it through words.
A books character isn't someone 'acting' it's the person in their own right, they are themselves, they KNOW how to act out their own emotion. For one they're not getting payed to act out someone elses life/feelings. an actor can only ever portray a characters emotions not live them.
Financially, books help educationally as movies do not.
Yes! This is what a lot of people would want, who doesn't want to get smarter?
Books are better because allow you to express your imagination and creativity of mind
If you borrow books from a library, they cost NOTHING unless you order a book and then you pay a mega small borrowing fee.
Ok that's right, but it's better to chose quality over quantity.
Ticket price + popcorn and a drink - for a movie which will last no more than three hours vs the price of a book - which will last for a week or two.
Last time I went to the movies it cost $10. when I bought a book, it was almost $20. so it depends on the book.
Movies are Also Great Babysitters
But books last longer
So are movies, but I get the point.
Movies just plop the actor into whatever the first scene is and usually rush the background information or throw it in the trash. Book based movies usually convey the message, "This is (insert favorite book character here). He/she is the main character. We don't care about their background. Okay?"
Books are awesome
I KNOW! I'm currently doing a project at school in with I am writing a The 39 Clues Fan-Fic, and LOVE the way my ideas are turning up! No one stops me from writing what I think!
What?! This is not a reason that books are good... also it depends on what you're reading. Obviously the magic tree house isn't going to have sexual scenes but have you ever read any page of Game of Thrones?
Actually, in books, authors normally have more permission to add dirty or suggestive themes in their books than in movies because there are no actors and because you're not actually visually seeing it.
Quite often, suggestive scenes in books can be more descriptive than in movies. Also, what's with the extreme hate towards anything vaguely sexual?
Little kids don't need to be looking at that dirty stuff
In movies all the ugly characters look ugly but in books you can imagine how you want all if the characters to look.
Why should ugly characters look nice?
Thanks for the info
Awesome research, thanks