Top Ten Reasons Why Dovewing is Overhated
Dovewing isn't my favorite cat, but I don't get why so many people hate her. I like Ivypool better, but Dovewing is great also.Yes!
Ivypool fans: "She hates her sister, oh we hate her now!"
Dovewing fans/the truth: "Dovewing loves her sister and wouldn't let go and hasn't let go even though Ivypool has been a sour brat to her ever since they left the nursery."
I hate Idiotpoop so much. She suddenly decides that she's a good cat and then she breaks her sister's heart. I think Ivyfool should go to the Dark Forest when she dies. Dovewing haters never admit that Dovewing actually cared about her sister because they just couldn't think of anything to make Dovewing sound bad. - Moonstar of ThunderClan
Yeah, but why is this a reason why people hate her? Isn't this a good thing that even dovewing haters have to admit she did?
She actually does, well if you were paying attention to what you were reading.
Yes! Thank you! Dovewing tried to fix her relationship with Ivypool, and Ivypool just yelled at her and started being a selfish, whiny brat! Ivypool is one of, if not the worst sibling ever! Dovewing is way better than her! -FierceheartOfThunderClan
This is Ivypool: "I'm gonna save the Clans because then they'll like me better than Dovewing and then Firestar will make me deputy and when he dies I'll become Ivystar and kick Dovewing out for no reason! Perfect!"
This is Dovewing: "I'm part of the Three now and I have to accept it. I will. And maybe someday Ivypool can join us."
Who would you want as a sister? The cat that wants to be better than her sister all the time and is such a sour brat or the warm cat that accepted you even if you weren't as good as her?
I like Dovewing loads better. - Moonstar of ThunderClan
The prophecy was kind of a joke. They didn't really do anything great enough to be passed down for 20 years.
Dovewing warned the Clan cats when the Dark Forest cats were coming.
Along with every other loyal Clan cat...honestly, that doesn't mean much.
The prophecy was kind of a joke. It didn't do enough to have supposedly been passed down for generations. Not that Dovewing was bad, Dovewing is awesome!
She HELPED.
And anyway, the prophecy is so overrated.
So did Jayfeather and Lionblaze...
She taught Tigerheart how to follow the Warrior Code when she broke it herself. REALLY?!
It's not up to Dovewing to get cats to follow the warrior code
He learned that through his Clan first though.
Along with the other Clan cats who went on the journey.
She was only six moons old, and she almost DIED trying to save the Clans. That's so loyal! While she was doing that, Ivypoop was being a brat and whining about everything. Dovewing is so much more useful! -FierceheartOfThunderClan
She HELPED refill the lake.
Um I didn't see this one on the list so: Sorreltail was outside the camp giving birth in the middle of the night and Dovewing heard her crying for help do without Dovewing Sorreltail and her kits might've died right then. Sorry I don't remember exactly which book that was in but I think either the 4th, 5th, or 6th book in omen of the stars ;-)
Because they're clanmates and she's been saved by other cats as well.
She HELPED. Can't leave out Jayfeather and Lionblaze and Firestar.
So did the other three and Firestar.
Yeah.
But Briarlight was still crippled. And Longtail still died.
If I'm being honest, though, that was Mousefur's fault.
More like she couldn't follow the warrior code even if the Clans were in danger and she didn't learn the first time.
um...kind of? I mean you got to admit she was a little stuck up when she acted so so surprised when she realized: HOLLYLEAF KILLED A CAT GASP
when your own husband probably killed more cats than hollyleaf -_-
you gotta admit that is pretty rude...
She WAS? She still is! She stays true to her heart and doesn't let others push her around. She knows what she wants when she wants it and if anyone tries to change her mind she makes them see reason. Dovewing is amazing! -FierceheartOfThunderClan
I wouldn't describe her as humble...
True, but Hollylef was a bad cat anyway. Dovewing is a much better cat and would never kill another cat in battle. She would see that they had a life just like hers and that they deserved to live it . . . . even if they made some mistakes along the way. Some people think that "Oh, even though in the books it clearly says that Dovewing is a better cat and is one of Three, but Hollyleaf is 'better' and she should have everything, la di da!" Hollyleaf was obsessed with the warrior code when she broke it three times and then she gotmad at her own mother for breaking it, what a hypocrite! Dovewing is way better! Like if you agree! - Moonstar of ThunderClan
Hollyleaf is my least favorite character. I don't understand why people like her.
She obsessed over the Warrior Code, even though she broke it three times, and yet she blamed Leafpool for breaking it. That's being a hypocrite.
Maybe you can excuse that because she apologized in the end, but that doesn't change the fact that she killed someone. She directly killed Ashfur and lied about it. For what reason? None, because she told the secret she was going to hide by killing Ashfur.
Stop spreading this BS! Dovewing never replaced hollyleaf. And if your Goddess Ivypool was a part of the three, Would be like: 'OmG I hAtE IvYpOoL ShE RePlAcE HoLlYlEaF!1!1'? You can hate dove without having such stupid reasons to hate her
Sure, holly leaf made a lot A LOT of mistakes and bad choices but she redeemed herself in the last battle but I’m NOT that mad she was replaced
This is a reason TO hate her. HONESTLY! Dovewing NEVER loved him, and it was unfair of her to lead him on like that! Oh my StarClan Dovewing! Just tell him you don't like him like that and be DONE with it! I was so relieved when they broke up!
She doesn't get together with him. They broke things off after Dovewing's Silence.
he was pushy
Unlike a certain silver-and-white she-cat who's name I will not inform, Dovewing actually loves her family and risked her life for them multiple times. -FierceheartOfThunderClan
Yes! Dovewing followed her heart. She wasn't happy in ThunderClan, and she was basically being forced into a relationship she didn't want, so she left to be with her true love. So what if she chose kin over Clan? She did what she thought was best, and that's what matters most. -FierceheartOfThunderClan