Top Ten Reasons Why Ivypool Is Better Than Dovewing (Warriors)

Yeah. The two sisters. One is my favorite and the other.. , not so much

The Top Ten

1 Everybody loved Dovewing and she was complaining the whole time

I hate when spoiled cats complain about their life. Do you hear Crookedstar complaining? Nope! Briarlight? I don't know. Brightheart? Okay, maybe yes but she has a reason! Dovewing has EVERYTHING! SHE IS IN LUXURY! She constantly whines "He Hates me! " Boi, if he hates you he sure doesn't hate well!

Like, boohoo, you have special powers to help you save your clan. Ivypool had no powers yet she did more. - AnonymousChick

Honestly...she didn't complain that much. I seem to recall Ivypool complaining quite a bit, actually. - Scarletfall

I HATE Dovewing. She is my least fave cat! But that's beside the point. At first I loved Dovepaw/wing and thought,"Wow she will have to go through so much and make tough descisions all because of her powers. That's a pretty hard job to do! " But then this happened...Dovewing became annoying. She was constantly complaining about her powers and was on again off again with Tigerheart. Gah! Dovewing just make a decision! Stop being so whiney! Sorry for that rant, but Dovewing did complain quite a lot at least enough for me to hate her the most...ok well rant ova! Bye bye!

V 7 Comments
2 Ivypool had to deal with a type of depression

Didn't know that, but it makes sense

And this makes her cooler how? - Scarletfall

3 Dovewing fell in love with a ShadowClan

Dovewing fell in love with ShadowClan? I didn't know that.
Just kidding.
I don't really ship Dovewing and Tigerheart, but, to be honest, Dovewing x Bumblestripe is a whole lot worse. - Scarletfall

Dovewing fell in love with ShadowClan?

Warrior. You forgot to add that word. Still. Ivypool > Dovewing. - RiverClanRocks

Tigerheart(star) was also her uncle, so I guess she is inbreeding. Why does every cat pick the cats who are related to them.

V 1 Comment
4 Ivypool was determined to stop the dark forest

Imagine if you lived your whole life, set aside and shadowed buy another sibling. Not only that, but they were unaware that they did so. When you tried to tell them, they just accused you of being jealous and that they were always better than you. (Fading Echoes) By now, the person reading this should know that they're acting as Ivypool. Anyways, once Ivypool found a way to compete with her sister, she took it as her only hope. That hope was fighting, and through the dark forest. Once Ivypool figured out the dark forest were purely evil, she risked her life to spy and give information. When all came down to the battle, Ivypool was the main reason the dark forest didn't win the battle. She stayed loyal to Thunderclan and almost died while protecting her belief. Now, Dovewing, is...a different story. Dovewing whines all thetime, when she has everything a she-cat could want. She broke and mended Tigerheart's heart a numerous amount of times, showing that she doesn't really care. She ...more

Meh. She is a mary-sue. She is unflawed, mary-sue. So um, shut up.

€Dovewing had everything that any cat would want! She was treated like the main star, but poor Ivypool just lived in her shadows not complaining about her life! She even risked her life to be a spy in the dark forests and what did Dovewing do? Way less then Ivypool! So ummm screw DOVEWING and GO IVYPOOL! ”

My Defending Dovewing Rant: Defending Dovewing RANT

Ahh Dovewing. The cat everyone hates, but I love. She actually is relatable and is a good character. I really didn't like it when became a background cat like Firestar and Squirrelflight did. She's flawed and isn't a ''Hollyleaf replacement'' or ''bad sister''. People say a lot of untrue things about this cat and personalily she doesn't desevere all the hate. After everything she did for her Clan. Ivypool's the real sister that's bad.
''She's a whiny Mary-Sue! "
Not even close! She's one of the most flawed cats in the series.
-Whining is a flaw!
So she can't be a ''whiny Mary-Sue'' because whining is a flaw!
-She told Tigerheart about the catmint
She loved him so she though she could trust her. Yet again, this is one of her FLAWS. Then she thought Tigerheart was using her so she broke up with him. She didn't brake up with him cause she didn't love him.
-She crosses borders to be with ...more

I totally agree with you that Dovewing is not a Mary-Sue! She is WAY overhated. "She complains all the time! " No she doesn't! Who can blame her for wanting to be normal? Who can blame her for feeling worthless, after she was expected to be the best hunter all the time because of her special powers, which she just lost? Apparently, about 999/1000 of the Warriors fandom. I am sick and tired of hearing Dovewing being called a Mary-Sue.
(I still like Ivypool though) - Scarletfall

5 Dovewing didn't care about her sister

Yes she did! She cared a whole lot! Dovewing and Ivypool were so close before Jayfeather and Lionblaze discovered that Dovewing was the third. Dovewing did care, and showed it on many different occasions. To say that Dovewing didn't care about Ivypool would be a flat-out LIE! GOD! - Scarletfall

I like both, but honestly, Dovewing did care about her sister. I honestly feel that most people don't even read the books throughly. - Oliveleaf

Dovewing sucks. - Aquastar_of_DewClan

In Fading Echoes
Ivypaw: jerk
Dovepaw: :runs away crying:

V 2 Comments
6 Dovewing acts like an idiot sometimes

Whoever put this one up-I LOVE YOU!

Honestly, even though I love Dovewing I can't argue with this one - Scarletfall

( second scentnce ) SHE IS, THANK YOU! ( I needed to correct this)

, whoever did this, thank you! This is what Dovewing is like;
Dovewing: Oh I have these powers and these great parents and two people that love me and an amazing sister but it’s not enough, I need more...
Dovewing: *sniffs delicately* well that’s not MY problem.
*a while passes and she has no toms that like her because she hurt them, but the whole clan treasures her*
Dovewing: My life is ruined... *sobs*
Ivypool: I was spying for the clan in the dark forest and no one cares!
Dovewing: not my problem!
Also, I have a song to share with you guys.
Mary Sue’s, oh Mary Sue’s, just how are you acquired? One must make an oc and make it perfect from personality to attire. Mary Sue’s, oh Mary Sue’s, just who is you queen? Oh it is the stupid retarded Dovewing!
And there it is! Please don’t just take this, but you can use it! Just say that Roseheart made it! ...more

V 2 Comments
7 Even after the battle, Ivypool fought for her rights


8 Ivypool was tricked and then she tricked them
9 Ivypool is humble

Yes. She spied on the Dark Forest for her clan, and never bragged or went on about it. She deserves credit, much more than Dovewing. - Minecraftcrazy530

She wasn't very humble at first but I still like her! - Puppytart

Ivypool was a great cat. her sis thought that she was SO much BETTER but no. Ivy pool did so many things for her clan but so did Dovewing (but she did way less than Ivypool) she is SO STUCK UP ON HER SELF and on the other hand Ivypool thinks that shes as important as any other cat. when I read ''Sunrise'' I HATED Hollyleaf she killed silverstripe (i can't remember the cat she killed but I think that was his name) just so hewont tell her secret but than at the gathering she blurted it out and she RUIED me, leafpool ' and squerlleflight 's life. RIGHT NOW I HATE DOVEWING WAY MORE THAN HOLLYLEAF

10 Ivypool would die to her clan

She would totally die to her clan

Ivypoop is litterly the BIGGEST MARY SUE EVER! at least Dovewing has flaws!
1. Loving to toms at once
2. Dealing with her power
3. Coping with Ivypool
AND MORE! ''Top Ten Reason Why DOVEWING Is Better Then Ivypool! "
Ivypool's flaws. She doesn't whine. She expressed her feelings bitterly. She doesn't fall in love. She doesn't have any flaws. SHE'S. NOT. RELATABLE. EITHER! At one point she's TAUNTING HER SISTER! WHAT KINDA OF MATURE OLDER SISTER WOULD DO THAT? Ivypool is the most annoying, biggest Mary Sue, and is my 10th least fave.

The Contenders

11 Dovewing is a Mary-Sue

Saying 2 toms falling for her makes her a Mary sue?

12 Ivypool is not useless

Actually, if Ivypool hadn't warned the Clans, all four would have been destroyed.

She actually is useless. Ivypoop didn't do anything durning the battle with the DF.

13 Dove freaked out when she lost her powers

After The Great Battle...
Ivypool:.O.O calm down.

14 Dovewing was super mean to Bumblestripe

Bumblestripe deserves way more. Dumb Tigerpoop (Tigerheart) just because you're all 'oh I'm so precious and I'm the only one you think about ALL the time' that doesn't mean you're actually a good cat, you're the exact opposite! Poor Bumblestripe, tried so hard and all the flippin time Dovepoo (Dovewing) was thinking about a completely different cat! I agree with Ivypool, (the most amazing cat of all time which is my first favourite cat and then Hollyleaf and then Bumblestripe) BUMBLESTRIPE IS NICE AND TIGERHEART IS JUST STUPID, SO GET YOUR HEAD OUT OF THE CLOUDS!

She broke up with him "because I don't like you."

She shoes a childish noob over the nicest tom in her clan.

15 Ivypool did brave tasks

She deserves more than dovewing and her kits need better names! Because thriftkit, flipkit, and bristlekit are probably too weird.

16 Ivypool had to deal with discrimination

True! - Hawkfrost

17 Dovewing played with Bumblestripe's feelings

Douwing is the worst cat for mate.
(sorry dovewing fans)

18 Dovewing whined about pointless relationships.

Dovewing:Bumblestripe I'm breaking up with you cause I Have a kind mate that is related to me in Shadowclan Bumblestipe:What, that's pointless Dovewing:SHUT UP I'm joining Shadowclan because I don't get treated right here. I totally agree with this one.

19 Ivypool isn't a total jerk
20 She ditched thunderclan
21 Dovewing never told her sister anything

Dovepoop just told everything to Tigerstar 2.0, but never to her sister then demanded to know where Ivycool was going at night.

BAdd New Item