Top 10 Reasons Why Psychedelic Rock is Better Than Heavy Metal/Hard RockRogerWatersfan1999 I'm a huge fan of Psychedelic Rock, so I figured I'd make a list about why I think it's better than Heavy Metal/Hard Rock. Although I do like Hard Rock as well, but just not as much. If you agree with this list don't be shy to add your own reasons if you want to. Remember this is just my opinion so don't get offended if you disagree, let's begin.
The Top Ten
Listen to both on acid in the woods. I was once an elitist metalhead. I thought there was no way anything could be better than metal. But as I grew older my mind opened wider. Psychedelic beats Non-Psychedelic. There's metal out there that's pretty psychedelic. But you can only get so psychedelic while keeping it metal. To be truly good music, its gotta touch on as many genres as possible. Metal elitists always go so far down that rabbit hole of metal bands until it's all they know and all they care about. The world of metal is a crowded one that will eventually wear you down if you don't get out and catch some rays once in a while.
Um, no. Currently metal is the most varied genre with about 30 major subgenres and many sub-subgenres. There are 2 big groups: extreme and non-extreme metal, and they offer different instrumentation, types of vocals, etc.
Psychedelic rock and hard rock don't have this scale of diversity. - Metal_Treasure
Yeh I think we can confirm that in general Metal is better :| - EliHbk
Agreed with MT here, metal has a lot more varieties than psych rock. For example,
fast metal - speed metal, thrash metal, death metal, black metal, power metal, neoclassical metal
mid-paced metal - heavy metal, symphonic metal, folk metal etc.
slow metal - doom metal, Sludge metal etc.
experimental metal/ more varied metal - progressive metal, djent, avant-garde etc. - zxm
I disagree because:
1) On average, metal has been creating one new subgenre every year since it was invented in 1970. This variety in metal is a result of constant experimentation and creativity;
2) Metal has evolved much more than psychedelic rock and hard rock. I mean, current metal sounds pretty different than metal in the 70s and even 80s;
3) I can't say psychedelic rock and hard rock have changed so much over time. - Metal_Treasure
... oh...umm ... no. Metal is the most experimental rock subgenre, starting with the fact that metal is extreme. - Metal_Treasure
No. Heavy metal is more demanding than hard rock and psychedelic rock. Your average metal player (guitarist, drummer, bassist) is more skillful than your average hard rock and psychedelic rock player. Metal is known for its musicianship that is higher than the average in rock. Many non-metal bands die to be labeled "metal" because among musicians the label "metal" is like a guarantee band members are players above the average. But when the band isn't metal, this may not be true. - Metal_Treasure
Wrong here, again agreed with MT. While he already explained metal I'd like explain that hard rock also demands a lot of talent along with metal. Steve Vai, Joe Satriani, Buckethead, Tom Morello, George Lynch etc are more hard rock than psych rock. And they're one of the most talented guitarists. Also, drummers like John Bonham, Keith Moon, Cozy Powell, Bill Ward are hard rock drummers. - zxm
Agree with this. Turns out, this item/claim is completely wrong because the required talent and skills are in this order: 1. Metal, 2. Hard rock, 3. Psych rock - Metal_Treasure
Um, no. No genre definitively takes more talent or skill than another. Talent is natural aptitude to do something. Talent and skill are different.
It's one thing to be talented, it's another to have your talent stand out better than the rest - cjWriter1997
Not really, psych rock and hard rock was invented almost at the same time. In mid 60s. Psych rock was more likely rock n' roll, blues played with high distortion. Hard rock was also invented from blues, garage rock but it had so many developments. Power chords were more popular in hard rock than psych rock. You "Really Got Me" by Kinks for example. There wouldn't be a lot of metal songs if Pete Townshend's hadn't popularized power chords. Hard rock was also the genre that for the first time had growling "Boris the Spider" the Who. And also, Led Zeppelin had legacies along with Jimi Hendrix for using marshall amps. - zxm
Well, psychedelic rock was created before metal and probably was very influential. However, hard rock influenced metal, which is a huge genre.
Also, many things that are typical for metal, are currently used in non-metal rock genres (guitar and drumming techniques, vocal techniques, etc.) - Metal_Treasure
Yes, it’s more influential than heavy metal, but heavy metal is an entirely different genre. Hard rock itself is what heavy metal stems from, and it’s basically what all rock music stems from. So, no.
In my opinion, the genre with the best lyricism is folk. Metal can be lyrical but it doesn't always need to be. Metal can just be fun too. - cjWriter1997
I think metal has the most meaningful lyrics - about society, history, politics, personal struggles, grief, etc.
"Nicotine, valium, vicodin, marijuana, ecstasy and alcohol
C-c-c-c-c-cocaine" (x10, or something like that)
[the entire lyrics to Feel Good Hit of the Summer by Queens of the Stone Age] - Metal_Treasure
That’s very debatable.
Pink Floyd: Shine On You Crazy Diamond
“You were caught on the crossfire of childhood and stardom,
Blown on the steel breeze.
Come on you target for faraway laughter,
Come on you stranger, you legend, you martyr, and shine!
You reached for the secret too soon, you cried for the moon.”
Iron Maiden - The Empire Of The Clouds
“To ride the storm, to an empire of the clouds,
To ride the storm, they climbed above their silver ghost.
To ride the storm, to a kingdom that will come,
To ride the storm, and damn the rest, oblivion.
Royalty and dignitaries, brandy and cigars,
Related giant of the skies, you hold them in your arms,
The millionth chance they laughed,
To take down his majesty’s graft,
To India they say, magic carpet float away.
An October fateful day...”
It seems like you only made this list because you like psychadelic rock more.
It depends on what kind of sound you are going for. Complexity doesn't always mean better, but simplicity can also get monotonous. - cjWriter1997
No, heavy metal has better and more complex instrumentation than both hard rock and psychedelic rock.
Give a listen to Wheel Of Time by Blind Guardian. How many psychedelic rock songs have its instrumentation and orchestration? And the complexity of its composition? - Metal_Treasure
Hard rock, yes. Heavy metal, no. I don’t think you’ve heard enough Megadeth.
"bad" and "good" are vague terms. Metal experiments more than any other music genre so it also takes bigger risks - as a result, more people may not like metal songs/bands, even when the song/band isn't bad for what it is (for example, a person that doesn't like extreme music wouldn't like a "good" death metal band). - Metal_Treasure
Because there are fewer psych rock bands in general. - zxm
That’s true, psychadelic rock doesn’t have anything even close to as bad as Cannibal Corpse or Six Feet Under.
This is one of the few points I agree with.
Give a listen to this song and you may change your mind: Feel Good Hit of the Summer by Queens of the Stone Age. Pay attention to the "meaningful" lyrics. - Metal_Treasure
That’s a matter of opinion.
Also, that’s not really a reason.
I have to say that there are pretty good album artworks in metal I truly enjoy. Check out these lists:
Top 10 Album Covers with a Nordic Charm
Top Ten Most Beautiful Blind Guardian Album Covers
Top 10 Metal Albums with Mythical Creatures on the Cover
Most Atmospheric Metal Album Covers - Metal_Treasure
Heavy metal? Sure I'll give you that. But there's loads of other metal subgenres that vary in lyrical themes as well. I have feeling when you say Heavy Metal you mean the actual subgenre and not metal in general for most of these points. - cjWriter1997
This doesn't sound convincing to me, especially without any reasoning and examples. - Metal_Treasure
Related ListsGreatest Heavy Metal/Hard Rock Vocalists Most Talented Heavy Metal/Hard Rock Vocalists Top Ten Best Metal/Hard Rock Bands of the 21st Century Best 70s Metal/Hard Rock Albums Best Metal/Hard Rock Fan Base Names
89 days old
2. Psychedelic rock is a more creative genre than hard rock/heavy metal
3. Psychedelic rock is more experimental than hard rock/heavy metal