Top 10 Reasons Why Serena from the Pokemon Anime Should Not Follow Ash to the Alola Region

Since the fandom is incredibly salty and whiny about her leaving, let me explain how it's very petty of them to be like that. Especially wanting her to stay for a ship.

The Top Ten

1 Dropping everything such as your goals for a guy is a bad message to young girls

Hey it's Okacolaebola and there has been something wrong with the site, I have been trying to post the next chapter about Mercedes the Minchino girl and it wouldn't post and I'm sure all the other writers have had trouble and that's why everything is late. Anyway, here is the chapter. Also my computer is lagging like crazy. Thanks for the likes, by the way! Only 2 weeks and 2 days left of school, EE!

Chap 2: Mercedes point of view. I was trapped in that bear trap laid by Bruce's grunt. I was bleeding, in pain, and there was no way out. I was going to be caught, sold, and given away to strangers for money. AGAIN. I slowly turned back to my human form and looked up. Bruce's ugly grunt who I call Ugly smiled an evil smile. I slowly hung my head, sure of my fate. Suddenly I heard loud noises, GRUNTS of pain ( get it?) an OOF, then silence. Suddenly a Pikachu ran at me. I closed my eyes, scared. Suddenly it used Iron Tail and snapped the trap. I was free! I would've run but I ...more

If ash is going to get love interest I think that instead of being a useless charater like serena she should be a more of a romantic rivalry in my opinion

SoaPuffball thank you for your kind comment. I am happy you want to check out my fanfiction, and honored that you took time to comment on mine. That may not seem much to you, but to me... it was a lot. You could say I'm in a " Lillie " situation in my life. But sadly, I can't send you a link because the maker of this contest said NO ACCOUNTS so if you want to read it you must wait till I get 6 likes. Then I will post a chapter on this site and then have to wait for 6 likes and so on for every chapter. I'm sorry if you don't like this, but I didn't make the rules. I hope you stick around for the ride, though. Stay cute! Petra Doll :...)

Serena's voice actresses would end up being harassed by Serena/Amourshipping's haters. - LunaDude1996

V 19 Comments
2 She can't be infatuated with a guy who won't love her back forever

It really is baffling to me that Amourshippers actually think Ash likes her back. It's one thing to pretend/imagine it based on some subjective hints. It's another thing to adamantly believe it, claim it's the absolute truth and obnoxiously shove it in other people's faces, ridiculing people who criticize the ship. When there's not even that much interaction between these two ten year old KIDS! They're delusional. Are other shippers in the Pokemon community this bad?

I don't know. The concept of shipping is messed up in general and is one of the many reasons why I am ashamed of "fandoms" as wholes. - Anonymousxcxc

Ash is never going to like her back. He's too dense and will never realize it. If he does.. well I don't think he's going to try to get a girl when he'll stay ten forever. - RisingMoon

Ash will NOT love her back! Because this show is meant for kids! It's not a romance show - Unharmless

If Serena was in love with me I would take my pants and underwear off stick my penis in serena's vagina and knock her up and say will you marry me and put a ring on serena's left finger so Serena is off the market forever.

V 1 Comment
3 If she neglects her goal, she is proving to her mom that she can't commit to anything

I would laugh. Moms know best.

She can't commit to anything that's not Ash related

#serena

4 Serena has the right to her own direction.

SOOO TRUE

5 She is only valued for shipping and that's a bad existence for Serena

I value serena for her character development halfway throughout the show. at first, I thought she was a ridiculous characterâ€" only rooting for ash but I grew on to like her. and when [spoiler] she kissed ash, what made me accept amourshipping is the fact that ash accepted her feelings, not returned but accepted. - lowkeysavage

6 She wants to improve her performances and her overall goal

Hi what's sup its RFAP ( I'm on the why u should hate Serena site I listed like five ) and I SO agree. But, isn't performing only in Kalos? It makes NO sense for her to go on!

7 Wanting her to stay because she has a crush on Ash and for amourshipping is petty

I severely doubt Ash will ever date her - TwilightKitsune

If ash would date someone, it would be Lillie not Serena.
I prefer Serena with Conway #StalkerShipping

8 There is absolutely no reason to stop giving new female leads solely because of Serena's infatuation with Ash
9 It's a tradition to have newer friends and companions for Ash for every region

People are mad about this? Must be new to the show, I guess. Other than Misty, no female companion of Ash has stuck around for more than one region. I'm pretty sure Misty only stuck around because the games didn't have a female player character until Crystal. - Zach808

And that's a good thing. Mallow and Lillie will be a breath of fresh air. Serena has become horribly stagnant since her competition with Aria (if she wasn't before. yeah, she was).

Yes, bye bye Serena - TwilightKitsune

But misty and Brock keep on coming back

V 6 Comments
10 Amourshipping was nothing but bait to the XY series

I literally skipped this entire series after 30 episodes. There were some good ones, but this was my least favourite season. Heck I even enjoy black and white and sun and Moon more than this. - ItsDaWorldOfSNuGGLEZ

Take amourshippong out or keep it in. It doesn't matter. Xy/xyz is NY favorite series regardless. It did so many things right that I just can't understand any of the hate that it gets. Its what people have always been begging for the anime to have. A smarter sdh. A stronger ash. Better battles. A darker story. its only competition is the dp series. - HeavyDonkeyKong

I think the main reason why people rated the X/Y anime series is because of the amourshipping crap. I mean seriously, a MOTHERF-ING 7.5/10 over the original?! The original anime series got a 7.4/10! ARE YOU SERIOUS?!

Update:
The XY anime series has decreased its ratings with a 7.3/10 now! YAYY! Please, let's keep it there at least, or go lower.

Update 2 (12/10/2016):
Both the anime series has a 7.4/10 rating, we MUST drop the rating even more. IMO, I'd give it a 1/10 and that's only for Ash who has made it to a new region.

The Newcomers

? Serena's voice actresses would be harassed by her haters

Hope that sums it up because other fandoms are notorious for harassment towards actors and other people, usually 'til they're driven off the internet. - LunaDude1996

Serena's actress Hayden Paschall also Winx Club characters...

That just settles how overrated and stereotypical 4Kids is.

If only Ash Ketchum and Sky (although he is stereotypical boyfriend material, so BLEH! ) beat up Bloom and Serena like Chris Brown (TEAM BREEZY SHOULD NEVER EVEN EXIST! IT IS NOT GOOD OR HUMAN TO DELIBERAYELY BEAT UP GIRLS! ) and Charlie Sheen for abusing them for not winning their hearts

I don't want Serenas to come back in Alola or ever. - LunaDude1996

The Contenders

11 Ash is indifferent about romance and can't recognize a girl's romantic feelings to save his life
12 Amourshipping is one sided

Ash never blushes with Serena

As one sided as it gets.

All shipping is one-sided. - Anonymousxcxc

Ash will never love serena like I do.

V 3 Comments
13 If she returns and sees Ash kissing Lillie, she would regret not choosing Clemont

I agree with you

And lillie have much more reasons to be atracted to ash than serena, like, ash saved lillie, ash visited her home and so on. For me it's obvious she has some crush on Him-bernardo - Bernardo

I am a alolashipper, so I agree with you

14 Subplot romance will never go anywhere in the Pokemon Anime

Seriously. Amourshippers: If your only " evidence " is their " childhood friends", Serena looks and sound like Alia and ash " looks" like that guy in the xyz legend, them standing next to each other, and ash eating Serena's food is your only " evidence ", than that is pretty much going nowhere. Just because someone sounds like Serena and looks like her ( like Lillie ) and likes someone does not mean amour is " canon.". Quite the opposite.
Also school starts 2mrrw ( * sobs *)! :...(

15 Amourshipping ruined Serena's character

To be honest, I would've liked Serena more if she wasn't so infatuated with her childhood crush. Honestly, she can do better than that...

I agree, Serena would've and could've been a great character if people didn't worship Amourshipping so much. I actually would've been fine if it were just a small crush like Ash's past companions, but Serena's crush was nuts. Serena to me was fanservice, not entirely, but mostly. I just wish Serena had more character instead of the bland, lovesick character she is.

true

16 A shipping with Ash will never be canon so Serena traveling with Ash more than her welcome is pointless
17 Pokemon Sun and Moon already has a large cast of characters, there is no reason for Serena to fill a gap that isn't even there

Way too many episodes would be ripped off.

Who cares. People still watch the anime?

Why there are so many characters is that I think the animators are running out of ideas so they would fill it in with more "-focused" episodes. After all, we have seen more of these characters' families than any other companions. - IAMAMEME

18 Serena would not work well in Alola if Mallow is also traveling with Ash because Serena is possessive over Ash

What a nightmare that would be.

19 It's not surprising that she would leave

She's a stalker, like Yandere-chan. She follows Ash EVERYWHERE! - mayamanga

20 We should be open to new characters instead of wanting to keep a character in the show for shipping purposes

Clearly, they (Amourshippers, and probably most shippers in general) don't watch the anime because they love Pokemon. They watch it for nonexistent romance.

Yeah, nobody likes repetitivity. - TwilightKitsune

Preach - DWisawesomethe3rd

This is exactly why Serena should not go to Kalos! ( Besides being a total jerk and copycat and a FLIPPIN STALKER! ) What's the point of bringing a character back when we should get new ones? If the animie kept re - using characters, people would get bored and stop watching. Pokemon. Would. Shut. Down. And who wants that? ( * Down below is an OC idea of mine. You can check it out if you want ( don't know why you would ) but don't steal it ( very unlikely anyone would since it's probably dumb ) *. ). Drumroll please: dundundundundundundundundundundundundundundundundundundundun. Name : Alicia Sinister. Age : 12 1/2. Size : 5 foot. Looks : Long nose, messy dark " mouse poop " colored hair which is shoulder length, ice blue eyes, pink braces, a white t shirt that says BAKA, blue leggings, a black miniskirt, pink sneakers. Pokemon : Popplio, Litten, Rowlet, Evee, Fennikin, Achino. Backstory : Her parents hate her and are very mean to her but deny it and just tell relatives that ...more

21 Serena would not fit the school setting
22 Serena is a smoothing yandere.

Also serena is a possible yandere for ash

What

23 Pokemon will become a drama show

By that you mean the Sun and Moon anime would be a drama show. Then the ratings would be T.V.-PG,T.V.-14 or T.V.-G, whichever it is that the FCC would choose, and then the writers would screw it up and would probably have to cancel the ENTIRE anime.

24 Then Serena will try to kill everyone if ash likes someone and make it not for kids

No she won't. Either this is a joke (which wouldn't makes sense because this seems like a serious list) or an exaggeration in my opinion lolol. - HeavyDonkeyKong

25 She will try to kill the people there if Ash likes one of the girls

I believe that Serena would not kill anyone, just avoid letting ash have contact with the other girls. Especially if one of them likes him. Or even better. All three.

26 Dawn should return instead

So truee serena is a crab so I told shrek to eat her

Not dawn...misty should return and travel with ash again..
Because ash showed his feelings only for misty and no one else...

27 She will lose any respect people still have for her
28 She already met Calem, her new neighbor. So no reason to follow Ash in Alola
29 We already have 3 female main characters (Lillie, Mallow and Lana) in Sun & Moon series' cast. A 4th girl (Serena) would not only make females outnumber males, but would also be a bad message of sexism.
30 Serena already made her choice and she choose to go to Hoenn to keep performing

She might still make some appearances like May did for the Wallace cup

31 She already left for Hoenn
32 Serena doesn't fit in Alola. She's classy, so she needs to be in a city, not a beach.

I know Lillie's classy, but she's made to be out of place. If Serena came along it just wouldn't feel right. We already have a much better Serena (Lillie) so why bring her?

33 She already went to Hoenn
34 It's highly likely that they'll find a better way to please everyone
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Best Pokemon from Alola Region (Generation 7) Top Ten Best Final Evolution Pokemon in the Alola Region Top Ten Alola Region Legendary and Mythical Pokemon Top 10 Pokemon Characters from the Alola Region Top 10 Reasons Ash Should End with Misty Instead of Serena

List Stats

300 votes
35 listings
2 years, 5 days old

Top Remixes

1. Dropping everything such as your goals for a guy is a bad message to young girls
2. Serena has the right to her own direction.
3. If she neglects her goal, she is proving to her mom that she can't commit to anything
VegeBulYes

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P