Top Ten Reasons Why Super Mario Maker Is a Bad Idea

From the people who gave you Super Mario Galaxy, Star Fox, Pokemon, and etc. Gives you the new mario game coming soon to Wii U called...Mario Maker? Wha...?
The Top Ten
1 It's Unoriginal

It's not the first time an idea like that appears on a Nintendo game. Mario vs DK Miniland Mayhem for DS had acessible level designing and sharing tools. Since 2010. 5 years before Mario Maker. Give it the GotY. Oh, wait, 2010 is over.

And level building isn't a new idea, just realize that you can find DOOM editors since the 90's. They're not easy to build and install, I know, but it proves it's unoriginal.

"But SMM is easy to build and download! "

MvsDKMM also had easy level designing and even easier level sharing. You could search for categories, sort them or go through contests.

Mario editors aren't any new either, check Super Mario Brothers X (fangame), released in 2009. One year before MvsDKMM. To download levels, all you have to do is download a ".level" file from a forum and open it on SMBX. Easy, no? And designing isn't complicated, especially with a custom editor. Besides, to some degree it supports custom content, unlike ...more

Oh wow...you can create your own levels in a few different styles. How creative but no seriously, this is a terrible idea. Nintendo should already know that there are gamers out there creating their own video games that they dreamed of. Who wanna waste their time on this "new" game?

Well. Do You Have Any Other Ideas? Or Are You Just Trying To Be Another One Of Those Internet Trolls.

But it's really good. I think that redeems it!
It's also one of the only GOOD level creation games!

2 Troll Levels

Oh yes. You will never know when someone begs you to try out a level thry made only to expereince a horrible level where you cannot pass it because there are either too many enemies in a row, too many bottomless pits, and even the goal is completely blocked.

If you can't handle the challenge then make your own levels.

That's why they have a skip function for 100 Mario Challenge.

I don't hate the game but have you seen the courses 5 year olds make? seriously!

3 It's Lazy

Creative? Maybe to some but to others, HECK NO! If I wanna make my own levels, I go to school for it and do it the hard way not going the easy way.

4 It Can Make the Game Easy

Sure you can make your own "level" challenging to your desire but nah you will make it look hard but it will still be easy to YOU nonetheless.

Not necessarily. You can make a level that's too hard for yourself.

If you don't like easy levels play hard ones, its that simple

You've obviously never seen a Panga level.

5 The Fact That It's a Mario Game

Whoever added this should get off of the top tens and go sit on there dumbass xbox and never leave, if you don't like mario, don't play it

I can not denie Mario improves over the years but seeing this game just makes me sad. It's not a Mario game, it's just a game with Mario in it.

Just because sonic isn't in it.(I know sonic is, when Mario has the mushroom)But not like wherever you go you are sonic.

Dumbest reason ever. Stop acting like a retarded Call of Duty fan.

6 No Bosses

No bosses? Your creativity is a deep shame. Have you seen the crazy bosses people make?! Your knowledge about this game is a deep shame.

Hey Buddy! Do You Want To Know Why The Game Never Had Any Bosses?!? Because You Never Made Any! You Idiot!

There are many from what I've seen. A lot and your knowledge about this game is a deep shame.

There are none from what I've seen. None at all and that is a deep shame.

7 It's an Anniversary Title

No no please NO! Mario deserves better than this so called game. No please no...

What about super Mario all-stars? At least on the 3ds please! Nintendo! Please!

8 No Luigi

Ever heard of Mystery Mushrooms? Or you can use the skinny mushroom.

Luigi returns in its sequel

9 No Yoshi

NO YOSHI?! How dare they!

Actually their is

10 It Can Be Boring After a While

I don't agree with the list's title, but I do agree with this item. Unless you've got amazing ideas that pop up every now and then, you may get yourself with nothing to do.

Then don't play it, all games can be boring after playing for too long

YUP! This happy wheels for kids CAN be boring after a while.

I still can't come up with a course to make!

The Contenders
11 Deleting Courses due to Unpopularity

There are amazing levels out there, super challenging but not enemy spams, that actually require brainpower and precise timing, and take hours to create, only to be taken down maybe a week later because no one played it. It's bull.

If they didn't, the whole game would be filled with trash levels!

I honestly can't argue with that.

This is the only good listing on here. + Supra Mayro Makkr doesn't suck.

12 No Touhou Girls as Mario Costumes
13 It's the fanfiction.net of Super Mario level editing
14 Daisy made an appearance

Stupid Daisy haters screw you

15 The Beta is Better Than the Final Game
16 The Eraser with Eyes Was a Bad Idea

the eraser with eyes was a bad idea for Nintendo to put in the final game too. the eraser with an E in the demo is better then the new eraser which is garbage.

17 The Rocket Was a Bad Idea
18 The G Was a Bad Idea

the G was a bad idea for Nintendo to put in the final game too. the castle icon which moves you to the end of the level in the demo is better. the G which moves you to the goal is garbage too.

19 Making the Slider Gray Was a Bad Idea
20 Clueless Plot Lines

Have you ever heard of the 100 life challenge

What Is That Supposed To Mean?

This isn't a valid reason

21 As a creator, you will be bored due to the fault of tiles, which other free editors have.

What does this mean

22 No Ice Plants
23 Underwater Spike Levels

It's extremely annoying

24 Stupid sounds effects when placing blocks
25 You Can’t Erase Mario
8Load More
PSearch List