Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths


The Top Ten

1 Bluestar Bluestar Bluestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. She one of the leaders of ThunderClan. She is mates with Oakheart of RiverClan and her kits, Stonefur and Mistyfoot, live in RiverClan

Bluestar was an amazing cat, one that didn't deserve to be killed. She taught Firestar the ways of the Clan and showed him how to show mercy while still doing what's best for his Clan. Never once did Bluestar put herself before her Clan. Just look at her kits who didn't know her as their own mother until the last minute, or how she died to protect Firestar from the evil wolf pack. Sure, Bluestar had her insane spell, but she still did more for the Clan than any other leader ThunderClan could ever have could ever do. I agree that Firestar was a phenomenal leader, but no cat can show more loyalty and compassion than Bluestar.

Bluestar protected her Clan well,
Even up 'til the moment she fell.
She always did what was best,
For her Clan and all the rest.
No one at all can ever compare,
To all the hardship Bluestar had to bare.
There isn't a doubt at all to me
That Bluestar led her Clan brave and free.
She loved Oakheart but it lead to sadness,
And ...more

We will all have sorrow for Bluestar and we will remember the great things she did for the clan

It was so sad. She saved firehearts life and her clan from the dog pack. Bluestar was so warm hearted she never should have died. And I hate you tigerclaw/star. She was truly the most loyal cat ever. She still looks down on us from star clan

I was in piles of tears! This was sadder than Titanic! It was not really Bluestar's fault she was at war with Starclan. And her children forgave her just as she was about to die. Why couldn't Bluestar's kits believe Firestar! ;-(

I agree, but I think it's still a good death. She died bravely for her clan, right? - Hollymint

V 367 Comments
2 Firestar Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He's mates with Sandstorm and has 2 kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. He was formerly a kittypet

Firestar- We met him as Rusty. We followed him into the heart of the forest. Together, side-by-side, we learned the ways of the warrior code. We fought bravely to protect our clan. We stalked through the depths of the forest. We grew with him, we learned with him, we followed in his pawsteps. From Rusty, to Firepaw, to Fireheart, to Firestar- we became a Warrior through his eyes. The first stories, THE stories, the ones that made us who we are, the ones that gave us Warriors- they are his stories. To see him die is to watch our link die- to watch ourselves die. Rusty was, and still is, and always will be- part of ME. Part of YOU. Part of everything that is Warriors. Such a sad and noble death- may Firestar live forever in the hearts of young Warriors, his memory never fade, his soul forever hunt in Starclan.

Aw. Firestar was so brave and loyal, he doesn't deserve to be voted in 15th place! He should be in first! He saved all the Clans' tails more than once, and then he just dies! Are you kidding me? How can Erin Hunter make Firestar, the greatest cat and leader of all, just die? Two words people... GO FIRESTAR!

I agree, but Firestar wasn't immortal. And it was a noble way to die. - Attuna

I don't want it! Why he died? I love him. He's a hero. He saved the clans.

Tears streaming outta my eyea

V 614 Comments
3 Silverstream

She died HAVING KITS! Also Graystripe and Crookedstar were swept with grief, she didn't even name them! Graystripe was so sad!

It was so sad! I cried so much! Silverstream and Graystripe were perfect for each other!

When I read about silver stream, I was like "what the hell blad, she's from a different clan!
When she died, I was like "why her! " and then I burst into tears.

It was sad that Silverstream died, because she was so happy when she found out that she would have kits, when really that's what had killed her! - Pebblepaw

V 277 Comments
4 Feathertail

She had an extremely hard life up to the point of receiving her vision. And then, when she died to save her friends and the Tribe of Rushing Water, she showed that they were more important to her than her own life. How much more of a warrior could she have been?

she didn't deserve to die so young... and she loved crowpaw/crowfeather! (he chose his own warrior name in her memmory) I always score her on quizzes if shes in it. she didn't have to save crowfeather!, but she did it for love.

How is Darkstripe above her?!?!?! she was such a kind hearted warrior... She never caused any problems only tried to mend them... And her love for Crowfeather showed she tried to find the best in every cat... she was such a brave and noble warrior :(

First, her mother dies, then her father leaves riverclan, she falls in love with crowpaw, and before she can express her feelings for him she dies saving him! how is that not the saddest?

V 166 Comments
5 Spottedleaf

Spottedleaf was the best medicine cat ThunderClan ever had. Not only did she die unfairly, but she died trying to protect helpless kits from being kidnapped from the evil ShadowClan cat Clawface! She deserved to die better, because she was always loyal to her clan.

WHEN SHE DIED FOR THE SECOND TIME :( That was so, so, sad. I cried my eyes out. She was in StarClan and then had to die again for a second time... She never was reunited with Firestar. Ever. But I guess it would have caused problems if Spottedleaf, Firestar, and Sandstorm were all in StarClan together haha.

Why did you die spottedleaf well at least she died a noble death protecting kits but still 😢😥😢😢😢

Spottedleaf will always be my favorite cat and best medicine cat the Clans have ever seen. Though, in Firestars Quest, I cried when Rainfur died. He was a noble cat. (But not as noble as Spottedleaf. ) Spottedleaf sill helps her clanmates today. RIP!

The first time Spottedleaf died, I didn't care because we never really got to meet her. But when she sacrifices herself for Sandstorm I cried! I remember some book saying that she did it a one last gift to her, "beloved Firestar". - Pebblepaw

V 263 Comments
6 Yellowfang Yellowfang

She loved her adopted clan and clanmates such an incredible amount, that she chose to die for them. She should be honoured beyond any other cat, for her unwavering loyalty to Thunder Clan and the amazing skills she passed on to her loved apprentice Cinder Paw(Pelt). YellowFang chose good over evil when BrokenTail drove her out. Instead of vowing revenge, YellowFang decided to take a more subtle yet nonetheless powerful means of revenge. She chose to rid the forest of BrokenStar and become good at the same time.

She was a grouchy cat, withan easy temper, but at the same time, loving, loyal, caring and sweeter than any cat I can think of.

Go YellowFang!

A beautiful she-cat- not in a appearance, but in nature. Sure, she was cranky, but also caring and wise. She took such good care of Cinderpaw/pelt. I love her. Even after being turned out by her own Clan -by her own SON for StarClan's sake! - she was a good little cat and didn't vow revenge like most ShadowClan cats would, but was quietly harbouring her secret. You know what, I wouldn't be surprised if she did have some ThunderClan blood, the way she acted! And when she killed Brokenstar.. Well, she did what she had to. At least she told her son who his mother was.
And Finally, she died for her new Clan. A medicine cat right to the end.
"A medicine cat have no time for doubt. Put your energy into today and stop worrying about the past. You have a duty to your Clan. Stop dithering and get on with it! " Yellowfang to Cinderpaw
"Thank you for bringing me to ThunderClan. Tell Bluestar I have always been grateful for the home she gave me. This is a good place to die. I only regret ...more

She died trying to save pachpelt I think she gets a thmumbs up

She may have a bad temper, but her nature is very beautiful. She loved raggedstar, despite the fact she cannot be together with him. She also loved brokenstar too, but he was too blinded and stupid to see that. I have to agree with fire star, she did not deserve that death, brokenstar got himself into the mess. She was just doing what anyone would do. She made great scarification, and should be remembered of a hero and kind medicine cat, may star clan light your path yellow fang.

V 222 Comments
7 Mosskit Mosskit

So sad! I was bursting into tears, Poor Mosskit, She never lived life to what she wanted to be. I Mosskit lived I would have called her Mossdapple, it is such a pretty name.

I cried when Mosskit died! It was so sad, and she was so lovable! She shouldn't have died because of Thistleclaw - it was his fault! I'd have named her Mossheart if she'd lived.

I loved Mosskit! It was so sad how he died and that he had to die so young. When I read it, and when I think about it, I break down and cry every time. Warriors is so- I don't know how to explain it, but it some how makes me think that these are real cats who are dying, and- It's just so sad. I LOVE YOU MOSSKIT, WHY DID YOU HAVE TO DIE!?

Just trying to make sure: Mosskit's a girl, right? Because I remember something saying that she was a boy. - Pebblepaw

V 190 Comments
8 Hollyleaf Hollyleaf Hollyleaf was one of the rare, strictly loyal cats of ThunderClan. She cherished the warrior code as a kit and came back to her clan in a time of need to fight-- even though she was cast out for killing Ashfur.

Hollyleaf was amazing. She honored the warrior code more than other cat could have done. She was brave, I mean, if it weren't for Hollyleaf, how else would they get rid of Sol for the second time? She didn't deserve her death, stupid Hawkfrost! She had the same personality as me, with all her regret and sadness. Obviously, Hollyleaf's death is the worst tear dropper, for me anyway. R.I.P. Holly

RIP Hollyleaf. She was amazing. Best funeral. And hey, random visitor. She is not a noob, and she could probably beat you in a fight. And she was amazing. Seriously, study your Warriors, boi. - TrueBlueHeroes

I absolutely LOVE Hollyleaf. She is my favorite character. WHY DID SHE HAVE TO DIE! She should have lived longer than that. She honored the warrior code more than any other cat and was completely loyal to her clan. Some people think she is an evil cat because she killed Ashfur, but she was doing it to keep her CLAN safe. And when she was trapped in the tunnels she still helped her clan. She fought off a fox that could have killed Cerrypaw and Molepaw, she gave the clan herbs, she helped Ivypool and Blossomfall out of the tunnels and gave the clan underground battle training. I know she told all the clans the big secret about her birth, but she did it because she knew it was against the warrior code and HAD to tell everyone else. I think Hollyleaf deserved more than being back for a book and three quarters(ish). Hollyleaf is so awesome and I cried three times. In Sunrise, Hollyleaf's Story and The Last Hope. At least in StarClan she'll have Fallen Leaves. HollyxFallen FOREVER

Yeah I personally think Dovewing should've died instead of Hollyleaf. - Anonymousxcxc

She was a wonderful character! She deserved to be Bramblestar's deputy it if wasn't for Hawkfrost. Plus, it's obvious Bramble was going to choose her if she lived. Besides, she showed the Warrior Code and StarClan more respect and was one of the most forgiving and loyal cats I have read about in the series. When she found out she was replaced, she didn't fuss like her replacement probably would've, she forgave her biological mother as well as her foster one, as well as both her fathers (Crow and Bramble) and tried to make amends even though there were big downs. She never gave up, and she came back. She did all of those things that I said above, as well as did EVERYTHING in her will and power to help. She trained cats in the tunnels and rescued them when they fell in. She even saved Ivypool from Hawkfrost, causing her undoing. She did all of those things, went through so much to return to ThunderClan to see her friends and family again...only to die a second time.

Murder but strongest hearted she-cat I have ever seen before

V 266 Comments
9 Cinderpelt Cinderpelt A medicine cat from the book series Warriors by Erin Hunter. She heals other cats in her Clan, ThunderClan, and is reincarnated into Cinderheart.

She had a near death expirience as an apprentice, causing her to have to be a medicine cat. All of her hardwork to prevent deaths, when she had possibly one of the worst ones herself. I mean, a badger storming in on Sorreltail's KITTING, and litteraly shaking her life away.

Her death wasn't sad. It meant she would get to have a Warrior life! It was happy but sad for the rest of us - Catsarah123

It was so sad.. I know she knew she was gonna die, but technically she saved her brother's mate from those badger so she risked her life to save someone else.

I don't know how that comment got ten likes, because its wrong. First off, she died saving Sorreltail. Poppyfrost wasn't even born yet. But I can see how you would think that, but in the books, I believe that the kits weren't born just yet, I remember Leafpool helping with that. I apologize if I prove to be wrong. Second, you're hating on Cinderheart, the cat who has the spirit of Cinderpelt. So saying that Cinderheart is stupid, that's technically dissing your favorite character. Remember, Cinderpelt didn't have the skills to be a medicine cat. Not being mean at all, just stating that she was never destined to be a medicine cat. She got a few signs wrong here and there, but she knew the herbs and taught Leafpool, so she was a good mentor, but not necessarily the best medicine cat. She also wanted to be a warrior, and Tigerclaw just had to rip that out form under her.

Sad death, being killed by a Badger after your apprentice ran off with a warrior of a different Clan because ...more

She died saving Sorrelstripe! SO SAD AND SO DEEP! - Pebblepaw

V 171 Comments
10 Snowfur

Snowfur's death was SO sad! She wanted to go into the forest so bad, but she also didn't want to leave Whitekit. She went out and ended up getting hit by the monster, defending her territory. Bluefur was torn up, and poor poor Whitekit! This broke my heart...

Snowfur so pretty in white why couldn't the driver see her in the light. Loyal to thunderclan to her very last breath now she is loyal to starclan as well as thunderclan still on this very day.

WHY is this not higher up on the list?! Snowfur's death was sadder than Firestar's, in my opinion (don't wanna start a flame war here, guys ). Oh my gosh... I'm listening to a sad song right now while thinking of Snowfur... :'( Thistleclaw and Bluestar finally had something in common- grief. Oh my gosh.. *cries a lake*

Wait...she get's killed by a car, right? - Pebblepaw

V 110 Comments

The Newcomers

? Gorsekit

The Contenders

11 Swiftpaw

Poor swiftpaw! This part made me cry because he didn't deserve to die! )':

Killed by dogs. Sucha promising apprentice to die so young. -

@fuzzystarblazeclan brightpaw didn't love swiftpaw, they were brother and sister.. And yes I do agree swiftpaw's death was sad and uncalled for

"He fought like LionClan"
I'm sure he did. He was that brave. - Pebblepaw

V 137 Comments
12 Stonefur

How is he NOT saddest?! I mean, he was killed for not killing his own apprentice! He had a choice! He could've lived, but he chose not to because he wouldn't do what wasn't right! He was all starved and stuff when he had to fight Darkstripe, but he STILL beat him up, so then NO NO NO, that wasn't the end, Tigerstar ordered Blackfoot to help kill him! And this was in front of everyone, even Leopardstar, and no one did anything! Firestar and Graystripe couldn't do anything, or else they would've been killed too! And with Blackfoot's help, they held him down and killed him! They cut open his throat in front everyone, including two skinny, scared apprentices! And no one even mourned his death, except that Leopardstar did quickly so no one would see, and Mistyfoot saw her dead brother and ran to mourn him while they were trying to get away! SAD! - Splashstorm

I think Stonefur's death is the reason I really don't like Leopardstar. She was only trying to do good for her Clan, but really, why couldn't she see that this was slowly destroying her Clan?! And Stonefur was so brave, really, giving his life for two apprentices. It was so sad! Leopardstar should have tried to stop it... But I don't blame her, I blame Tigerstar.

I think Stonefur's death was quite harsh yet sad. He risked his life to save two apprentices who were going to be killed instead. I think its horrible how Leopardstar would just kill her deputy like that, and watching. I really think this is why I ended up disliking Leopardstar so much, due to how she acted in the early part of warriors. Poor Stonefur, he died a heroic death.

Stonefur died saving Feathertail! Okay, why isn't Blackstar in Dark Forest? - Pebblepaw

V 117 Comments
13 Honeyfern

This noble she-cat was walking into camp when she saw a snake slithering up to the kits. At the last moment, she knocked the kit out of the way, but died from a snake bite. Berrynose was in terrible grief. - addisyn00

Stupid Snake! Honeyfern should of totally lived!

It was so sad because Honeyfern and berrynose were talking about having kits!

Honeyfern is too good for Berrynose! Hmph!
I wouldn't say that if he hadn't hit on Poppyfrost right after. Her sister? Why!? - Pebblepaw

V 132 Comments
14 Whitestorm

Whitestorm was my favorite character, and if I remember right he was killed by Bone, Scourge's deputy, when they had to drive Bloodclan from the forest (after Tigerbutt brought them there). He was going to retire to the elders den after that battle, they should have let him retire. :(

When he died, I ran out of my room and started screaming in front of my brother about how Whitestorm died. He gave me this weird look and I ran into my room and started crying. WHY ERIN HUNTER? Why could she kill such a sweet and wise deputy? He was my favorite character ever.

What about Whitestorm? He was so awesome! And smart, too!

Go apprentices! - Pebblepaw

V 92 Comments
15 Ferncloud

Stupid Brokenstar. He stayed behind after the Dark Forest Battle in the Last Hope was over and grabbed Ferncloud (sweet, gentle Ferncloud) by the neck, snapping her neck and killing her. Yellowfang bit down into his own neck, killing him, because she was so mad her own son could do that. But Dustpelt and her full grown kits were crushed. May the heavens guide your spirit across the stars forever, Ferncloud. Rest. Your life's work is done.

I am so sad! The last hope made me cry so hard! Poor Spottedleaf, Firestar, Mousefur, Hollyleaf, AND FERNCLOUD! Those are the saddest warrior deaths in the last hope. And I agree with you, Dustpelt. You could have saved her. Now, because of those stupid Dark Forest cats, she's dead. STUPID DARK FOREST! I HATE YOU SO MUCH! WHY DID YOU HAVE TO KILL FERNCLOUD? SHES LIKE MY favorite CAT! I am so mad!

Okay, people, this might not be right, but rumor has it that Ferncloud was murdered off because fans said that she had to many kits. - Pebblepaw

Stupid Brokenstar. She didn't deserve to die! Dustpelt was devastated!

I actually cried

V 51 Comments
16 Moonflower Moonflower

I was reading Bluestar's Prophecy in the car on my way to camping and I just started bawling and my brother just looks at me like in a freak. But it was so sad when Bluepaw was trying to wake her up but she was dead...

She didn't deserve to die! She was only following orders!... And she still had kits to raise... D':

She said the next day she was going to take blue paw and snow paw to collect the softest moss and she slept with blue paw and snow paw the night before the battle

She did not deserve what she got. Hakheart, I'll get my revenge, you unworthy cat! - Swiftdawn

V 75 Comments
17 Brindleface

Shouldn't have died because of stupid Tigerstar.

It was so sad reading about greiving 4 his foster mother, she was probly the sweetest in the clan, and that stupid, no good, evil, furball Tigerstar killed her - bteamer34

I thought this death was so sad. Cloudtail had just said goodbye to her and she ended up dying before he got to see her again. The saddest thing in the world...

TigerStar be like

Oh, I’m the best, now, to destroy that clan of innocent cats, let’s make dogs destroy their camp! Oh no.. I ran out of rabbits, I guess I should use innocent she cats instead! Anyway, it will give the dogs a taste of cat blood!

Yeah... no..

V 54 Comments
18 Scourge Scourge Scourge is a villain the Warrior Cats series . He's the leader of BloodClan . He was bullied by his siblings, Socks and Ruby, in the past because he was the smallest out of his kin . One of his most notable features is his collar of dog teeth .

I agree villians are not born but created and thanks to socks ruby and tigerpaw/tigerclaw/tigerstar scourge is a cold hearted cat.

Must I repeat myself? Yes, his childhood was sad. But if a murderer kills your family and friends, are you gonna think,"Well, he had a sad past, so it's perfectly acceptable for him to kill people! " No. Unless you're weird. Who here was sad when Tigerstar died? How about Darkstripe? Hawkfrost? Brokenstar? Hm? Almost no one, I see.

You can't blame him for it he had a sad kit hood but the he became powerful and evil so truth be told power does corrupt and he's was to corrupt to live but read the manga warrior series and you will understand why like the saying goes don't judge a book by its cover

TWISLECLAW SHOULD HAVE DIED INSTEAD OF SPOTTEDLEAF. HE SHOULD HAVE FADED! He made scourge and Tigerstar evil. If it were not for him Firestar,Scourge and Whitestorm would still be alive and after Firestar died Whitestorm would be leader. Twisleclaw is my second least favorite character!

V 142 Comments
19 Longtail

I loved Longtail. I hated how he died. SOMEONE SHOULD HAVE SAVED HIM I hate that everyone was caring for Briarpaw but there was only one sentance of Longtail's death. That's how much he was liked.
The reason I like him is because he's a minor cat, but his personality's so similar to mine, it's like seeing myself die in a book.

It was so sad when Longtail got hit by the tree. Dovepaw should have saved him. He was such a great cat...

He respected firestar after he saw tigerclaws real colors. STUPID TREE! SoMEbody should had saved him. Really why did anyone not jump in there grabbed him and got out. Instead they worry about briarpaw and IGNORE THAT A CAT JUST DIED! BUT I want to say that was a great stunt briarpaw pulled there... Risking her life for longtail. Longtail was my favorate!,!

Longtail is life

V 61 Comments
20 Lionheart

Lionheart's death isn't the saddest one, but its very depressing how he was killed because Graystripe was very attached to him along with the rest of the clan. He was a great warrior in my opinion

Lionheart is a great warrior, he was perfect, he could never be doubted and always followed the warrior code like a real warrior should, he was a very fine temporary mentor to Firestar, and Bluestar was so sad when he died, so was Greystripe, Lionheart, I cried when you died, I would have lied, for you, Lionheart. And even worse, replacing Lionheart was that evil Tigerstar!

Lionheart beloved father and warrior


V 49 Comments
21 Mousefur Mousefur

Stupid dark forest.
I think I recall myself cursing them when I finished the book.

I love Mousefur. Please don't tell me she dies. I haven't gotten that far yet.

It was so sad when she died 😪 she lived for like 10 years and even though she was grumpy I still really liked her character.


V 16 Comments
22 Flametail

Poor thing didn't deserve to drown stupid Rock

Flametail was a great medicine cat! He was just having some fun on the ice and he drowned! It was so sad! His last thought was for his fellow medicine cat, Jayfeather, to know that everything was going to be alright! I was like crying!

I think that this is the saddest death because flametail accepted that he was going to die, and when he saw Rock, he thought "is that a cat from starclan coming to get me? " I cried and cried

Jayfeather could never save him. - Pebblepaw

V 27 Comments
23 Fallen Leaves

Dear jaypaw must of cried when he saw poor Fallen Leaves die. He was there, but not even a cat more powerful than starclan can change the past in the present. Fallen Leaves was only to ready to be a sharpclaw, and even though it was cloudy, went into the tunnels that took his life, not knowing that his own excitement and fear would kill him, as he struggled. He was so close, but his mark on rock's stick is left unscratched.

Fallen Leaves' impatience lead him to his own death, but I still think his death was very sad and should not be all the way down at 24! Vote Fallen Leaves!

At least now I THINK he can reunite with his family in the place where dead Ancient Tribe cats go. His mother was devastated when they had to leave the lake (Long Shadows)

He didn't die completely, he's both alive and dead. I love him. His destiny was to live in alone and abandoned in dark tunnels. Poor him! - Swiftdawn

V 26 Comments
24 Willowbreeze

Stupid mapleshade it's all her fault poor crookedstar he loved her and 2 of their kits die

I love this cat! That's all I have to say really because that sums it up

This was so sad I cried and said she should have lived poor crookedstar it broke his heart

Willowbreeze was an amazing cat and she definitely didn’t deserve to die the way she did... if only Silverbutt had died instead.

V 35 Comments
25 Tallstar

Tallstar made the wrong choice for deputy... (mudclaw) it was a very sad time when he died... But trying to cling on to his last life he said that the rightful deputy.. Is Onewhisker... Tallstar was a great leader.. Even when he knew he had made mistakes he tried to correct them... He deserves to be higher on this list.

I would say Tallstar because he is just flat out amazing. He was a way better leader then Onestar. I thought Onestar would be a good leader but NO! He turned out to be a butthole. I mean, for crying out loud! Onewhisker and Fireheart were really good friends!

He was such a great cat. He was noble, kindhearted, and awesome. I agree he has to be higher on the list. love you tallstar

Tallstar was such a sad death after going all that way just to die at least he changed his deputy to onewisker

V 26 Comments
26 Ashfur Ashfur

I was all like Ashfur NOO! My mum came in my room wondering what was wrong. She was like, whats wrong? And I was like They killed Ashfur! Then she just walked off.

No doubt when Squirrelflight picked Brambleclaw over him he turned twisted and evil, but I still had tears in my eyes when he left ThunderClan for StarClan. -

Ashfur was not very good at coping with his emotions. Unlike Thrushpelt, he overreacted and went to extremes for revenge of his "beloved". Squirrelflight was very important to him, of course, that does not excuse him from his attempts on killing her family. I wouldn't call hima "psycho", he was driven by grief and humility. He felt betrayed. Squirrelflight also has fault in that. But, Ashfur is most remembered with his complicated feelings for Squirrelflight. We should focus on what's most important. Above all, he was a great warrior. Loyal and hard-working. Yes, it wasn't very "loyal" to attempt to kill his own leader, but if you forget about his mistakes and forgive him, you'll see that he was a worthy cat.

I never really liked Ashfur I didn't like how he wasn't rlly a good mentor to Lionpaw (Lionblaze) and Hollyleaf is my favorite character so good job 👏 Hollyleaf (sorry Ashfur lovers)

V 64 Comments
27 Ravenpaw

The ultimate guide said that he's dead (he gave Bramblestar one of his nine lives). I really liked him, and when I read Bramblestar's nine lives and I said that he was dead I yelled NO right in the middle of silent reading and everyone stared at me. - Sparkwhisper

You don't really know how he died, but he was such a sweet cat. He never had a mate, but he never complained. He didn't get a warrior name because of the powerful fear of dying before he'd ever even get one. Plus, he became confident in his own time, he could've been a medicine cat. If he got a better mentor, he could've became a well remembered warrior. Maybe even deputy and leader.

Yes I know he didn't die but he was so sweet if only tiger star would have not kiled redtail he would be in the the I remember him as the awesome cat and him and barley are awesome in the manga series

He died of liver cancer at Barley's paws... READ RAVENPAW'S NOVELLA! (I forgot what it was called)

V 59 Comments
28 Badgerpaw

His death was so unfair and when he started speaking to Flintfang and telling him how good a mentor he was it broke my heart. It was not the saddest death but he should be in the top 20. Badgerpaw was to young to die!

HOW IS THIS NOT THE TOP ONE? I KNOW A LOT OF WARRIORS OUT THERE DON'T KNOW WHO HE IS BUT HE'S THE ONLY ONE I EVER CRIED ABOUT! EVER! It's so sad. But so sweet because he got his warrior name right before he died. But it's not fair! I read his whole life in one sitting! He was my favorite character in Yellowfang's Secret besides Yellowfang and the other medicine cats! HE DIED BEFORE HE EVEN SHOULD HAVE BEEN AN APPRENTICE! I HATE YOU BROKENTAIL! I feel like Badgerclaw is my son almost! It's not fair! I love you like a son, Badgerfang.

DUMB BROKENSTAR! It was his fault that Badgerpaw died. BAD BROKENSTAR! BAD BROKENSTAR! If Brokenstar haven't been evil, Badgerpaw would had been alive!

IT'S BADGERFANG. - Swiftdawn

V 58 Comments
29 Sweetpaw

She was so awesome! She should have lived - she was so nice and lovable! Personally, I think it was her brother Thistleclaw who should have died. If she'd lived, I'd have named her Sweetflower! It's so sad!

She died of eating a bad mouse, which was sad.

In Bluestar's prophecy, she dies of a really bad stomacheache. She was a sweet, gentle she-cat who should've lived -

If Sweetpaw please don't go
You must stay for tomorrow
Please don't leave us now!
They can't show you now!

Why must you leave so soon
for you are six-moon
Oh please stay with us!
Just hang on to that life!

Curse the bad mouse.

V 25 Comments
30 Snowkit Snowkit

He was so small and helpless and it was so sad when brackenfur didn't give up and continued to run after him when no other cats did. He didn't deserve to die even if every one was right when that said he couldn't be a warrior

Poor little snowkit I cried when he was taken by the hawk I like to think he didn't die but was taken somewhere where he was happy but I felt so bad for brindleface! She loved them so much!

Was killed by a bird, and was deaf and white.

I feel so bad for snowkit he was so small so he could be prey to any predators that have wings that are flying over the clan territory when he was taken I way I cried (but I don’t usually do that beacause to me it is not sad) just like badger paw he was to young to die R.I.P snow kit

V 76 Comments
31 Storm

I had so many mixed feeling for storm, when she left gray wing and when she died I still can't believe she choose clear sky over GRAY WING! He loved her and she was like what ever why would she choose clear sky, like he is the worst cat!

Stop stealing all the girls from Gray Wing, Clear Sky! Did you know that Gray Wing like Bright Stream, too?

I prefer Turtle Tail to be Gray Wing's mate than Storm but Storm didn't even have a chance to name her kit Thunder. Stupid Clear Sky!

Storm didn't deserve to die

V 18 Comments
32 Sandstorm

NO guys Sandstorm didn't die, but I feel so sorry for her now Firestar is dead.

She shouldn't have lost firestar

What!?! Sandstorm does NOT (Mark my words) NOT die! But she was crushed when Firestar died ;(

She dies in The Apprentices Quest it was so sad too!

V 68 Comments
33 Sootfur

I cried so much when he died he was such a loyal warrior and no one could help him because a stupid badger broke his back legs :'(
It was even sadder when sorreltail found out because she was so upset

I liked him! He was so awesome. And he was killed by a stupid badger - just like he lost his mom!

I cried so hard, I just pictured it in my head.. Sootfur's back legs were broken and then squirrelflight.. D:

DAM BADGERS. I actualy JUST finished this book, and in Sunset it kinda starts with the elders carrying Cinderpelt and Sootfur out of camp to be buried. - pepperfrost

V 15 Comments
34 Redtail

He died in the prologue, not even getting to know him. We barely even met him in Bluestar's Prophecy, if you're wondering about that. I think that Redtail should've lived longer, or maybe even have more info on him, like a short story or something like that.

The first person who did the rockfall comment is WRONG! Stupid Tigerclaw killed him in the first place!

Has this rockfall person even read the books?


V 41 Comments
35 Thunder

So sad he died but I don't know how so ERIN HUNTER MAKE MORE OF THOSE NEW CAT WARRIOR BOOKS

If you didn't read Dawn of The Clans you wouldn't know. I didn't know how he died but I would've cried!

Stop making this up. Grey wing died!

It wasn't Thunder who died, it was Grey wing

V 16 Comments
36 Badgerfang Badgerfang

Badgerfang never should have died he was only four moons old he should have still been in the nursery all because of Brokenstar's bloody leadership more cats died because of Brokenstar

Scourge is above him on this list? How? Badgerfang's death was depressing to read. I mean, he was so damn young! - Stormskies

HE WAS ONLY 4 MOONS OLD! And he was so cute! He didn't deserve to die so young!

He was a kit! STUPID BROKENSTAR! I wanted broken star to DIE IN A HOLE! *tear* I cried. *tear*

V 11 Comments
37 Fireheart

Um... Isn't Fireheart The same as Firestar? Seriously!

Fireheart didn't did die firestar did

Firestar ( or fireheart ) was very brave honest and kind he died in unexpected death after he had defeated tigerstar.

Really dude - Ajdv

V 29 Comments
38 Gorsepaw

That one was sad. TigerClan just decides to show up and attack wind clan. I don't remember who killed Gorsepaw but it was sad how morningflower was all sad and stuff

It was Tigerstar who killed him. :'( He set it as an example of what would happen to those who refused to join TigerClan ;'(


Damn you tigerstar - Leafstar12

V 26 Comments
39 Dustpaw

He was only an apprentice! He died in Hawkwing's Journey. By the way, this is NOT the Dustpaw that becomes Dustpelt. - Penguinstar

It is duskpaw

You mean Duskpaw - Frogjaw1996

40 Sorreltail Sorreltail

Even though she was just a side character she had an actual personality that set her apart. She was also very loyal to her clan and had many friendships with main characters. Brambleclaw even said that she would make a dangerous and respected warrior.

Sorreltail may have been considered a "minor" character, but it broke my heart when she died. I felt really bad for all of her kits and her mate, Brackenfur. I loved every single one of her kits, and I wish that there was a story on her that let us see inside her heart.

She. Is. Awesome. She was Leafpool's friend and I really liked her! She died AFTER the last hope, by the way people. Read Dovewing's silence.

Am I the only one the think this picture of Sorreltail looks like Sol?

V 29 Comments
41 Fernshade

I know this is completely stupid, but I want to put my own cat up here. Just to see the reaction of everyone who finds this little paragraph. I want you all to know how respectful of Fernshade I was and still am. She was a noble warrior that died like the brilliant cat she was. Still, I feel as though she died for nothing, and her death was the one that wrenched my heart the most. She had gone through so much... Losing her tail as an apprentice thanks to her patrol finding a mountain lion on the edge of their territory, watching her own brother die at her paws, being told by the medicine cat that her mother had been hit by a monster on the thunderpath, and seeing her own life flash before her eyes when the killing blow was struck. As a kit, Fernshade was a kind, caring soul that took care of her weak little brother no matter what the older kits in the nursery said or did to her. When she became an apprentice, she was determined to be the best she could be in service of her Clan. She ...more

Who's fernshade

FernShade is an actual cat dude, but this person said they made them up. READ THE BOOKS! There is an actual FernShade

Aww I love the detailed back story and I am so sad right now

V 14 Comments
42 Waterdrop

Who exactly is Waterdrop? - Skybreeze

Thanks, but we aren't really here for fanfic. Is there one for fanfics? We should really suggest one.

He died in my FanFiction. He was a leader, and then became a warrior, and then died at the paws of Fluffypants. - Penguinstar

43 Graystripe

He never really died he was injured but never really died.


Wha? Graystripe never actully died if anyone didn't notice at all.

Graystripe must be broken knowing his childhood best friend died - pepperfrost

V 62 Comments
44 Oakheart

Poor Oakheart, why can't all the clans get along! It's so terrible that he died. He did not deserve to die, especially before Firestar ( Rusty at the time )could meet him!

I think his death was the saddest (besides Whitestorm and Mosskit. ) Poor Bluestar. She lost her mom, her sister, her kit, and her mate. I didn't read Bluestar's Prophecy until I finished the first series. So I was like NOO! His love for Bluestar was so sweet.

When I first read about Oakheart, I didn't think much of him and just thought he was mean and crazy but when I read Bluestar's prophesy I thought he was among the best characters in the book and hate Tigerstar for lying about his death when he claimed that he murdered him because apparently he broke the warrior code by killing Redtail when he didn't! Tigerstar deserved his brutal death!

People were getting Oakheart mixed up with Redtail. See #34 - pepperfrost

V 21 Comments
45 Nightstar

It's bad enough that he got rejected by starclan to be the new leader of shadow clan, but then getting killed in w so knees that was thought to have claimed mall of his lives. That's just mean!

Don't think it is fair, and that tiger star the butthole replaced him

He went crazy when he became leader but I like the name nightstar

"Night star got roasted by star clan," said running nose

V 8 Comments
46 Rainwhisker

Rainwhisker was awesome! How DARE any tree kill him. he loyal, smart, awesome, young, awesome, ect.

Rainwhisker deserves to be in the top ten! He was really loyal to his clan and it was so sad when he died just by a stupid tree!

I was so annoyed when rainwhisker died. He was so nice and awesome and he deserved a more dramatic, memorable death. Instead it was just mentioned at the start of the book
I cried when I found out rainwhisker died even though it said next to nothing about it

His death is so sad.

V 19 Comments
47 Hollykit

It was sad when hollykit (ferncloud's kit and birchfall's littermate) died. But it wasn't that sad.

Is hollykit like hollyleaf? If not then I have no idea who he/she is... :/

Excuse me? Hollykit and many other great cats are LOWER Tigerstar and Brokenstar?

Uhhh, hollykit-hollyleaf didn't die. If she had died as a kit how would she be hollyleaf? It was one of Fernclouds kits that died of starvation. There was Larkkit, Hollykit, and Birchkit. Birchkit was the only one to survive, and I beieve he is made Birchfall in the Power Of Three.
(I think it was larkkit tell me if I'm wrong. ik the others are right) - pepperfrost

V 14 Comments
48 Frecklewish

Are you talking about the freckle wish from sky clan or from the novella because if it's from the novella her death it's not that's sad I hate the novella I mean I don't hate the novella I hate freckle wish from it

Guys this is Frecklewish from Mapleshade's Vengeance. Mapleshade was about to kill her when a snake came and bit Frecklewish, and Mapleshade left her to die. - GoldenTemmie

I was so sad to see Frecklewish die.

49 Brokenstar Brokenstar

I don't think Erin Hunter shoudn't have discribed his suffering. Hey! Don't judge me I'm young!

I know he's evil but in forest of secrets if that's what you're talking about I almost cried

Why is broken star above sol broken star broke the warrior code 100 times while sol a rouge broke the warrior code like 5 times

Well I know he was a menacing cat but when I read how he died I cried. I am now as I’m typing this.
Like, HE DIED AND WAS LIKE AH and he faded away. In front of Fireheart. And those deathberries...I CAN’T STAND THIS. Well there you go Brokenstar you deserved to die like that. And you won’t believe who actually had this smart plan to...naah I’m gonna cry again. ~Bluefang of FireClan

V 19 Comments
50 Dustpelt

Dustpelt had the most tragic life, but he was one of the most loyal warriors. He was the one that always disagreed with Firestar, the one who kept him on his toes, but he was still loyal to the end and so hard working. His life was so full of tragedy, and once Ferncloud died, his life basically ended. By the time he died, he wanted to die, and that just makes it all the worse. It also doesn't help that he had enough dead kits that they made a point about them all visiting him when he died.

Yes, it was very sad when dustpelt died even his last words and his final words to ferncloud made me miserable

It was so sad when he died in Bramblestar's Storm, I cried forever

This death was actually kind of happy...
I mean think about it dustpelt lost almost all his kits (except birchfall) and he lost his mate 😭😫.Then he had to live in depression and was so sad 😢.Think about it when he died he got to see all his kits (larchkit,hollykit,icecloud,foxleap,shrewpaw,
And spiderleg)and he gets to see ferncloud.If he would have lived he would’ve had to suffer even more.please be happy that he is now with his family

V 10 Comments
PSearch List

Related Lists

Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Apprentice Deaths The Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths (My Opinion) Saddest Warrior Cat She-Cat Deaths Top Ten Warrior Cats With the Saddest Lives Saddest Warrior Cat MAPs

List Stats

6,000 votes
271 listings
8 years, 68 days old

Top Remixes (49)

1. Bluestar
2. Firestar
3. Moonflower
1. Hollyleaf
2. Feathertail
3. Willowbreeze
1. Tigerstar
2. Scourge
3. Brokenstar

View All 49

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.