Top 10 Scariest Are You Afraid of the Dark? Characters

1 Doll (The Tale of the Dark Music)

2 Ghastly Grinner (The Tale of the Ghastly Grinner)

3 Mr. Olson (The Tale of the Pinball Wizard)

4 Beth (The Tale of the Lonely Ghost)

5 Ricky Hagerty (The Tale of the Shiny Red Bicycle)

6 Black Figures (The Tale of the Super Specs)

7 Madeline Koegel (The Tale of Apartment 214)

8 Creature of Darkness (The Tale of the Quicksilver)

9 Zeebo the Clown (The Tale of Laughing in the Dark)

The clown scared the hell out of me as a kid.

10 Frozen Ghost (The Tale of the Frozen Ghost)

The Contenders

11 Pool Spirit (The Tale of the Dead Man's Float)