Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters

The Contenders: Page 2

21 Pinkamena Diane Pie

This is my fear since I remember my little pony...she was my biggest pony watched cupcakes...SHE KILLED MY FAVORITE PONY! ugh...gonna have another sleepless night after this -.-

Oh no. We're all gonna get killed by a pink, kinda cute, horse with balloons on her butt. Run for the hills, pack your bags, cancel the milk delivery.

She is awesome because she loves to kill her own kind...

I used to love mlp and now I don't but she scared the bad poops out of me

V 11 Comments
22 Mother's Call

Some of the scariest creepy pastas let your mind do the work, a WONDERFUL example of this is Mothers Call. I have only read it once but I get chills from just thinking about it. What was in the kitchen? Was it a kidnapper? Was it a monster? Was it a spirit? We don't know and that's why it's so scary.

Now every time my mum calls me for dinner I am suspicious...

DEFINTELY top 10 worthy. I mean a little girls hears her mother call her name. As she walks down the steps a hand reaches out of a closet and grabs her. Its her mom and she says "Don't go I heard it too." I mean that's DEFINTELY scary.

23 Seed Eater

Oh, Eyeless Jack eats your kidneys? How about the Seed Eater eats your children.

Not only does it have a creepy story, this creature is a creepy looking fellow for sure he deserves to be on it

A bird-human hybrid that feeds on children. Definitely deserves to be in the top ten.

HE'S CUTE.Still I'm a part of the creepypasta family.

V 3 Comments
24 Ben Statue

If you play majora's mask and have read BEN DROWNED you will agree it should be in the top 10

Isn't it also known as the statue of Elegy?

BEN scared me mostly because of actual evidence on YouTube. But luckily Jadusable himself admitted it isn't real and even made a parody of it it's called hey I'm been I recommend it to you guys

Yes this is one of the scariest creepypastas the rest it's just the same murderous thing just with different stories

V 4 Comments
25 Sally Williams

Does NO ONE know about sally?!?!?! That makes me feel bad, her story was pretty sad, knowing she was just 8 years old, I felt bad for what happend to her, I told my friend about her, and she loves sally now. If you know slender, I'm surprised you don't know sally, she is like his daughter... kinda... in a way, I hope you read sally story... please say what you think about her because I really like her

I love Sally so much, she is so adorable.

I lover her. She is so cute!


V 2 Comments
26 The Sandman

I kind of felt sorry for the for mr. Sandman


27 Mr. Widemouth

This story honestly gave me nightmares!

Honestly he sounds pretty stupid

I think he's kinda cute.

28 Jason the Toymaker

The fact that Jason tricks his young victims into being their friend is rather terrifying. Not only that but the fact that Jason will do just about anything to get what he wants even if it means killing an entire family. His demonic form is down right horrifying as well, since his toys also change into their demonic forms makes it even more creepy. Above all, Jason has to be one of the scariest and yet, most interesting Creepypasta characters there is.

Jason, in my opinion, is a guy who looks like you can trust. Literally. The first time I saw him I immediately added him to my Creepypasta stories due yo the way he LOOKS. I find him really attracted, like Laughing Jack, Ben Drowned, and Jeff the killer.

I love Jason the toymaker as instead of just leaving the bodies he's very creative and makes them into wax dolls and makes them a piece of art

He kills in the most creative way

V 7 Comments
29 Masky

Deserves to be higher than 29. I mean come on in Marble Hornets he loses his friend as Tim, he suffers and more. Seriously people watch Marble Hornets you will understand

Masky is just plain awesome, nothing else to say. I like him but he'll probably kill me, not obsessed by the way

He may be in Marble hornets but he is in my top 10 I mean come on he's awesome, cool, calm and collected.

He deserves higher than 30

V 12 Comments
30 Clockwork

She is crazy in her own way, she is probably my favorite FEMALE characters, Jane is only crazy because of Jeff, but Clockwork is crazy on her own, and she is such a powerful character. I would really like to see more stories about her where she's NOT dating Toby, and where I could find out more about this character..

Clockwork is my favourite character because she has a very reasonably story she has one of the most violent transformation, shoving a clock up her eye and sewing a smile on her face one of the best killers ever

She is scary! I live with her. You do not want to see her attitude. But when we are alone she is AWESOME!

Love clockwork

V 15 Comments
31 W. D. Gaster

Gaster is the most mysterious man from undertale

Gaster is from Undertale. Undertale is awesome. Ergo, Gaster is awesome.

Wut gaster from undertale is he even a creepypasta


V 2 Comments
32 The Smiling Man
33 Puppeteer

He comes when you feel alone and makes it look like suicide then turns you into a puppet for some kid to play with.

Puppeteer is my personal favorite creepypasta, he is just... So cool!

Definitely my fave too

My baby I'm his dear puppet sohe should be higher than this! (;⌣̀_⌣́)

V 1 Comment
34 The Grieving
35 Red

This story is so Amazing 9000/10

As a Godzilla fan. He's the scariest character of the Creepypasta games. Infact scarier than Jeff. Put him on number one

BEST STORY AND MONSTER EVER! Put this guy on number one. - asantalo

He's really cool...and hot

36 Jane Everlasting

I don't think she is evil or creepy because she wants to kill Jeff The Killer.

Jane is my 2nd favourite female pasta, I respect her need to kill jeff and her in general

Jane is My Favorite Creepypasta Female ever! :3 I like her because she's a Amazing! :3

Jane is probably the only good creepy pasta. Although I think Sally W. is also a harmless creepy pasta.

V 7 Comments
37 Lavender Town Pokémon

Lavender Town is my jam. You can actually do a really good robot while dancing to it. =3

It's strange they it's part of pok'emon
But if you listin to it a lot it might give you nightmares when you think of it while your asleep

38 The Smiling Girl

Never heard bout her

39 Herobrine

Not even the slightest bit scary, but it was when I used to play Minecraft.

He's not too scary, but it is creepy for Minecraft fans.

It's funny I remember getting scare while playing mine craft it make it more excited

Really cool and I like him he is very amazing

V 9 Comments
40 Zero

The thought of zero was brilliant and I can relate to her so much! "It's time someone put some color in this chrome little world"

Not a creepy pasta idiots

Zero was a imagination of Alice but when she snapt at school zero become real zero locked alice away now she took alice hole body

She is my idol!

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Gaming Creepypasta Characters Top 10 Scariest Female Creepypasta Characters Top 10 Scariest Anime Characters Top Ten Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's 4 Characters Top 10 Creepypasta Characters

List Stats

3,000 votes
93 listings
4 years, 160 days old

Top Remixes (9)

1. Eyeless Jack
2. The Rake
3. Squidward (Squidward's Suicide)
1. BEN Drowned
2. Frank (Donnie Darko)
3. Hoodie
1. Slender Man
2. Smile Dog (Picture)
3. The Rake

View All 9


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.