Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas

The Contenders: Page 6

101 Back at the Barnyard

...¿What-the-ass? I know that it's supposed to be the last one, but I would like to know... ¡¡¿¿WICH USER PUT THIS THING IN THIS TOP, THINKING THAT IT HAS A PIECE OF SCARY?! not even in the last spot.

102 Mr. Fuzzy

This story is long, but well-worth the read! Very creepy and disturbing.

103 Rap Rat

Needs more ratings!

This sucks laugh out loud

V 1 Comment
104 Herobrine

I think I know this guy. So does My brother. One video game day he found a giant hole with diamond blocks & Power rails in it. He climbed down and mined the diamond blocks and made some armor and diamond stuff out of the diamonds.Then the next day he heard his friend say that Herobrine was under that hole and that your not supposed to mine the diamond blocks or else Herobrine will be after you. He eventually deleted the world.

One day in my Minecraft (single player) I go to the mineshaft I was mining the obsidian someone attack me when I mine that obsidian someone puts it again it creeped me out so I decided to deleted that world and go to the other world (which is my home in creative) and I decided to put some fermented spiders eye, poisonous potato, splash potion of poison, and some rotten flesh so that herobrine can be poisoned and spawned some iron golems and sleep and the next day in Minecraft all the things were gone I think he poisoned. that's I am going to say.

I heard a child just killed Herobrine in Minecraft PE and guess what he got... loads of diamonds! You can watch it in YouTube.

Who's ever heard of a player with glowing eyes?!

V 10 Comments
105 Spongecry.avi

An episode when Gary died, SpongeBob kept crying till he got so decayed a lot! The pic gave me nightmares...

This is not scary or disturbing. SpongeBob presses his face against the camera! That is hilarious!

V 1 Comment
106 The Autopsy of Cole Ryder
107 Deprivation
108 Emma by Chris Craft

Not a creepy pasta but a good story - JaysTop10List

V 1 Comment
109 Rock Motto

This Ceepypasta Is about a Guy who YouTube pooped SpongeBob and this YouTube poop is very disturbing! Do not watch!

110 Happy from McDonald's

Has a pasta ben made about this yet? - michaelthecritic

Happy from mcdonalds is NOT scary he is funny

This guy looks possessed. I hate it when he copied off of Sunset Shimmer. And the scariest part was... He did a creepy dance with a gogurt! I'm grossed out when I see him!
Pen from bfdi

111 Ed Edd Eddy "Lost Episode"

This ruins so many childhood moments on so many levels.

112 Happy Appy

The only other blog-pasta I like. It was great and creepy. - Daviddv0601

V 2 Comments
113 Thomas and the Children

By the way there is no narrator, there are murderous messages at the end, and the children are made of wood.

It is a Thomas lost episode not scary

You will have to look this up before laughing out loud and thinking it was a regular episode. It is a creepypasta. 1 spoiler warning: he [Thomas] did kill Bertie the bus.

114 He's Still Out There
115 The Mystery
116 ABC
117 Channel 10,000
118 The Grinning Man

Spooky yet interesting. I've listened to it on YouTube so many times and I still am. Definitely a Creepypasta.

119 The Smiling Man

I've listened to it so many times before and I still do. This never seems to bore me and it's one of my personal favorites. It's somewhat chilling so I think it deserves some credit.

How is this not higher this is way scarier Jeff the killer

This was a very disturbing read

V 1 Comment
120 Huntsville Camping Trip

Creepy, indeed. That's all there is to it. Another one I enjoy listening to.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Scariest Video Game Creepypastas Scariest Movies of All Time Best CreepyPastas Ever Top Ten Scariest Things Ever Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters

List Stats

2,000 votes
160 listings
4 years, 50 days old

Top Remixes (30)

1. Jeff the Killer
2. Slenderman
3. Eyeless Jack
1. Slenderman
2. Jeff the Killer
3. The Rake
1. Jeff the Killer
2. Slender Man
3. Eyeless Jack

View All 30


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.