Top Ten Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's 4 Characters


The Top Ten

1 Nightmare Fredbear Nightmare Fredbear

Creepy how he just comes at the last minute for the last night

Just look at that mouth... And he is all ripped.. Ugh... Also, his belly has a mouth! No thank you, Fredbear, but thanks anyway.. Just gonna back away slowly...

Hi. I am not what you think I am. I am obsessed with fnaf. Let me tell you a Fredbear theory, also known as theory 10. The fnaf 4 child did not get bitten by Fredbear's mouth, but from his endoskeleton teeth inside him. When you think about, how could his frontal lobe be the only thing that was damaged? His whole head would have been ripped off, but it didn't. At the end we could hear a heart monitor flat line, which means that yes he in fact did lose his frontal lobe.

I think that's a really good theory Jeffrey or whatever your name is! - coolgamert

I fthlnk nightmare Fred bear is the scariest because he has sharp teeth

V 12 Comments
2 Nightmare Nightmare

He isn't that scary when not lightened. But when he is, YOU CAN SEE A HUMAN BRAIN! He also shows his endoskeleton.

It's really creepy how you can see his endoskeleton when you brighten him up. And his endoskeleton head's a REAL HUMAN BRAIN! His jumpscare isn't loud but it lives up to his name...

God he is so scary when you go to the door and see him you just crap your pants


V 17 Comments
3 Nightmare Bonnie Nightmare Bonnie

Oh yes he's like oh sweet Jesus kill it with fire like every Bonnie except for the pink eyes that is nice

The eyes and whiskers though

Avoid Bonnie's door if you keep encountering him.

The whiskers though

V 8 Comments
4 Golden Freddy Plushie

The reason he is on here is because of his meanings. Why does he always follow you? Why does he help you? Why is his main phrase "Tomorrow is another day."? - seminolesinger2003

You people really think plushie is scary? Nightmare chica is the scariest.

He's here, He's there, He's everywhere! Who you gonna call? Psychic friend Fredbear! - Doge4lifeGaming

Yep! Always seekin help from good ol Physic Friend Fredbear, ain’t we?

V 18 Comments
5 Nightmare Foxy Nightmare Foxy

Nightmare foxy is my favorite because to me he's friendly but he can be annoying but give him credit he still has heart inside him

When he snaps I jump every time. - Coopetro

He is the super scary to me

Foxy has been my favorite fnaf and then my friend told me about the new fnaf so I had to look and again he is still my favorite - zombie187

V 6 Comments
6 Nightmare Cupcake

She is scary but people think no

No not this time

When I saw the cupcakes jumpscare,I was like:NOPE

The cupcake is the best. Cupcake and chica swag u haters.

V 5 Comments
7 Nightmare Chica Nightmare Chica

The fact that she is below a plush doll is a god damn disgrace!

Yeah she's scaring! I mean... The mouth, the teets, the eyes...

She is always like: I NOW STARE INTO YO SOUL! And her cupcake! WHAT HAPPENED!


V 2 Comments
8 Tiny Freddy

Are you serious

The freddles will tell nightmare freddy to kill u

They're officially called Freddles

The Freddles do form Nightmare Freddy and they are scary but they do not form a jumpscare so eh

V 2 Comments
9 Plushtrap Plushtrap

I don't find plushtrap scary at all I think he is adorable!

Just stares into your soul

Are you insane!

What.. I am just a plush toy! how could you have said that.. I wish I was not a plush toy so I can be free, and I will bite those haters ha ha

V 5 Comments
10 Nightmare Mangle Nightmare Mangle

Honestly, Mangle it pretty scary. She always gets me with the closet! Plus, I can't hear breathing with her radio! But still Mangle is best character!

Nightmare Mangle is annoying, not scary.

I want Nightmare Foxy back! At least he remained silent! - KennyRulz244444

Nightmare mangle is cool.!

Kill this maniac! Like as if a broken foxy that was a toy wasn’t enough! Now it’s just overkill it’s been mutated! 👹👺😡😠😢😭😤

V 1 Comment

The Contenders

11 Nightmare Freddy Nightmare Freddy

He's jumpscares not scary, its just creepy

I like it

Person before me, EXCUSE ME?!

Now that's out of the way, I think he is very scary and deserves to be before his children! I hope people realize that's he's scarier than his children

12 Nightmare Marionette

Well she is scary because she is bloody and slinky

That is something you don't want to meet in a dark alley, or a bad day or in your bedroom he is SPOOKAY

V 4 Comments
13 Spring Trap

He is scary the way you see him then you don't then jump scares you like nothing

Spring trap must be scary than other FNAF Characters!

Uh this is fnaf 4 not at all times

How is SpringTrap a Fnaf 4 charater? He is a Fnaf 3 charater.

V 2 Comments
14 Nightmare Balloon Boy Nightmare Balloon Boy

Not scary at all, Scott sadly won't change him so he will never be terrifying.

He's Plushtrap, he's shiny and pristine and doesn't look like a Nightmare animatronic at all. - KennyRulz244444

He is terrifying and I thought he was creepy in fanaf two

15 Nightmare Moon Nightmare Moon

Nightmare Moon is the Villain version of Princess Luna from My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic, NOTHING related to Five Nights At Freddy's. Though, when I first saw her in 2010, I was kinda freaked out by her.

That's not a FNAF animatronic, silly!

She is not scary but she is a pony with majik

Ok so this fnaf ok? And who cares about the stupid pony. It's a baby show ok? I'm 10 and even I know this. Wow I relly hate mlp. Ok and the fnaf verson not scary. Wut the heck pony lovers. Wut the heck.

V 2 Comments
16 Fun Time Freddy

This is FNAF 5, not 4

17 Ennard Ennard

This guy is mad scary. If you finish watching the T.V. after completing night 5 you will walk up to you. By the way he walks very scary. Anyway he is also a fusion of all of the other animatronic's endoskeletons. And his clown mask just freaks me out A LOT!

Fnaf 4 not sister location

Who the hell is this guy!?

When I got jumpscared by this guy I Actually fell off the chair

V 3 Comments
18 Purple Guy
19 Purple Chica

The plushtrap and cupcake are my favorites of fnaf 4

20 Nightmarionne Nightmarionne

This one is from an Easter egg I think, but this creeps me out, I mean look at his face. It looks like he wants to haunt you till the day you die. But his voice just wants me to turn off the computer and call 911.

Nightmarionette and Nightmare Marionette are the same thing

21 Foxy Foxy

sooo cute

22 Toy Chica Toy Chica

Not in fnaf 4... - ChuckLaunching

23 Nightmare Golden Freddy

Nightmare Golden freddy is literally a dead golden version of nightmare freddy

24 Spring Freddy

He always just pops out of nowhere for me... It's creepy.

V 3 Comments
25 Big Brother

He is probably the scariest thing about the game how he treats that little kid who by the way is HIS BROTHER

This is actually the host of big brother

Can I just say "who is Big brother? "

V 1 Comment
26 Spring Bonnie
27 Freddy Freddy Freddy Fazbear (originally known as Freddybear, as seen in the Kickstarter) is one of four main antagonists of Five Nights at Freddy's, who later appear as variations in the succeeding games. V 1 Comment
28 Crying Child
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location Characters Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's Characters The Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's 3 Characters Scariest Animatronics In Five Night's at Freddy's Top 10 Scariest Animatronics In Five Nights at Freddy's 2

List Stats

200 votes
28 listings
2 years, 272 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Nightmare Foxy
2. Nightmare Chica
3. Nightmare Freddy
1. Nightmare Fredbear
2. Nightmare Chica
3. Nightmare Mangle
1. Golden Freddy Plushie
2. Nightmare Cupcake
3. Tiny Freddy

View All 4

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.