Most Successful WWE Tough Enough Contestants


The Top Ten

1 The Miz The Miz Michael Gregory "Mike" Mizanin is an American professional wrestler, reality television star, and actor. He is signed to WWE, where he performs on the SmackDown brand under the ring name The Miz. He is the current WWE Intercontinental Champion in his fifth reign.

Whether you like him or not, he's probably the most successful Tough Enough contestant. He's a former WWE, Intercontinental, United States and Tag Team Champion. That sounds like he's the most successful contestant, but he didn't win - RickyReeves

Really? REALLY? How could you disagree? He is the most MUST SEE WWE wrestler of all the ages! I mean, he's the full package! Great charisma, great technical wrestling, great gimmick. Hey, he even has his own stunt-double!

2 John Morrison John Morrison John Randall Hennigan is an American professional wrestler and actor, who is best known for his tenure with the WWE where he was better known by his ring names John Morrison and Johnny Nitro.
3 Melina

Won the WWE Womens and Divas Championships - RickyReeves

4 Josh Mathews

I never said only wrestlers can make the list. Managed to stay in WWE for 12 Years - RickyReeves

5 Cameron

Yes, she was on Tough Enough in 2011, now she's on Total Divas - RickyReeves

6 Matt Morgan
7 Maven Huffman

He eliminated Taker in the 2002 Royal Rumble - RickyReeves

8 Nidia Nidia

For those who don't remember, she managed Jamie Noble in 2002. And for those who don't remember Noble, he's currently with Seth Rollins - RickyReeves

9 Jackie Gayda
10 Chris Nowinski
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists