Supernatural's Best Season

The Top Ten

1 Season 5

The concluding season of the greatest story arc in all of television. The ending of Azazel's fifty year old master plan comes to a head in season 5 and Swan Song is the best episode that Supernatural has ever produced. Phenomenal writing, acting, directing, and musical score. Season five is by far the best season of Supernatural.

This is my favourite season, it's a mixture of the best storyline of all the seasons and the best soundtrack and music to it. Dean and Sam are funny and Castiel is cool. There's more than one thing going on and I love the complexity in this season, but it's simple as well.
Best season. Over and out. - ILostMyShoe

Best season period!

2 Season 11

Best Season of this show yet. Overall the first and second half were masterpieces and the nice thing about this season is that it mostly avoided filler. Baby, Thin Lizzie, Our Little World, Plush, Just my Imagination, O brother Where Art Thou, Devil in the Details, Into the Mystics, Love Hurts, The Vessel, Into the Mat, Red Meat, Hells Angel, Don't Call Me Churley, All in the family, We Happy Few (the best episode) and Alpha and Omega) are example of masterpiece episodes. Out of the Darkness into the fire, Form and Void, The Bad Seed, don't you Forget About Me, and the Safe house were excellent episodes. The Chitters was an okay episode. This Season actually had a character that became my fan favourite the first minute I saw her, Amara. Became my second favourite character with Dean being Number 1 the first time I saw him. Season 5 is my second favourite season bit for me season 11 is still the best by an extremely far Margin for me.

Chuck revealed as God was by far the greatest moment on the show. I especially loved the scene when Sam and Dean first realized their neurotic novelist friend was the almighty. The whole dynamic between Chuck and the brothers completely changed. It was so interesting to see the respect from Dean and Sam showed to Chuck aka God. Oh, and I can't forget the Dr. Phil scene between Lucifer and God. Castiel as Lucifer was genius. You wouldn't even know the same character was playing him.

This Season is the second best season to me. This season pace moved at an excellent pace and did not include any episodes that were boring and or did not make the season flow. The Darkness Arch was very strong. Throughout the season, my favourite part of the season was Dean and Amara's relationship and it would have been even more sweet if Dean and Amara expanded their love even further. The only one thing I did not like about this Season was the introduction of the Men of Letters. They should have waited for Season 12 as the Darkness Arch was big and good enough. Waiting months to see how Sam was doing was disappointing as it makes people tired of waiting. However, bring back Mary was excellent.

This season is the best season with Season 5 being my second favourite season. This Season focuses on the main story rather than filler for most of the time. In fact, I would say that 22/23 episodes were not filler and that is pretty good for a season as filler sometimes is not great. However, Season 5 did have great filler. The only episode that was filler in Season 11 was the chitters.

V 2 Comments
3 Season 4

The gay trenchcoat-ed angel came, like really guys. Destiel shippers? Anyone?

4 Season 2
5 Season 1

It's the beginning of the season so they are funny and all that

V 1 Comment
6 Season 3

The season gathered momentum around the mystery spot episode, just in bello was exceptional too. After this season the show got a bit stuck up its own arse

7 Season 8
8 Season 6
9 Season 7

Currently watching this season. A bit dissapointe that there are hardly any Castiel episodes. And don't forget the most painful death of all happened in this season. - AnonymousChick

10 Season 12

So far, to me, Season 12 trumps Season 1, 2, 4, 7, 8, 9 and 10 so far and it is only half way through the season. 4th best season to me so far besides Season 3, which really intrigued me into the series with excellent quality episodes that are not so place. Season 5 which to me is a little better than Season 11 to me as the episodes were perfect. Season 6 which was a decent season despite too much plots thrown out at once, there was some intriguing episodes and it had so much potential for Supernatural. Season 11 to me was the best if not Season 5 as it also had perfect episodes and a God and Darkness Arch

Season 12 was a very strong Season. The first half was very strong with the second half being weaker. The Season finale was the second strongest season finale with Swan song being my favourite. The feel of the Season 12 Finale reminded me of the Season 5 Finale. Cas an Crowley dying (Bobby and Cas dying. A winchester traps lucifer in the alternate world (Sam putting Lucifer into the cage. Killing Crowley was not cool.

This Season had a very strong first half. The second half though hasn't been as strong though with the exceptions of a few episodes [First Blood 12x9, Regarding Dean 12x11, Stuck in the Middle with you 12x12, The raid 12x14 and the Future 12x19. Hopefully the Finale will be very strong. This Season is better than Season 1,7, and 9 overall though. I do not like that they killed Mick and Eileen as they were great characters. It was kind of disappointing to see the second half of Season 12 as Season 11 was my favorite season of this show. My favorite character order list of who is alive is 1. Dean 2. Amara 3. Crowley 4. Lady Bevel 5. Lucifer

The first half of this Season was the strongest part of this Season with the Second half being okay with a few episode exceptions[Episode 9, 11, 12, 14, 16, 19, 20, 21, 22 and 23]. The Season Finale was amazing. It reminded me of Swan Song a bit when Crowley and Castiel died and when Mary sacrificed herself to send Lucifer and her into an alternate dimension. It is just like Swan song, Bobby got killed by Lucifer[ie Cas and Crowley got killed by Lucifer], Sam sacrificed himself to save the world from Lucifer[ie Mary Sacrificed herself to save her sons and the world from Lucifer]. Swan Song is still my favourite Season Finale with All Along The Watch Tower being my Second favourite Season Finale of Supernatural. The penultimate episode was my third favourite penultimate episode with Season 2/11 being better. I was so sad to see Lady Bevel die. She was such a great character. I was happy to see Ketch die. I was a little sad to see Cas go. Very sad to see Crowley go. I can't wait for ...more

V 1 Comment

The Contenders

11 Season 9
12 Season 10

Honestly my least favorite season so far. So much angst, so little actual action trying to get good things done... Not to mention the completely unnecessary death of Charlie! Supernatural writers seem to have a thing with killing off any and all characters that are part of an under-represented group; in this case, female and LGBT+.

I loved this season too, mostly because of how hot Demon! Dean was

13 Season 13

Hype!

BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

P