Top Ten Thomas & Friends Characters That Need to Return


The Top Ten

1 Duke Duke

Duke is a great character, with untapped potential. Ditch Freddie and bring back one of the most loved characters. And if Duke doesn't reach the Number One spot, well, that would never suit his grace!

Duke is a Perfect character. They need to bring him back. Best Narrow Gauge engine ever.

Somebody needs to get Duke out of the contenders now! He's gotta go straight to the top!


V 5 Comments
2 Elizabeth Elizabeth


3 Boco Boco

Kick BoCo out of the contenders! Get him to the top of the list right now! - FinnsWorld

He is ma favorite one and I'm 10

Bring Boco back NOW!

Boco was used be my favorite ttte character of all time so I voted for it

V 2 Comments
4 Molly Molly

She hasn't been explained enough but really captures our hearts! She would be perfectly explained if she returned to the series!

One of the only HIT characters that I care about.

Yes yes yes yes yes

That's her prototype face

5 Terence Terence

And make his face less ugly.

He is actually coming back in the 21st season - BowserKoopa22

6 Madge Madge

Madge need to return in season 22 with her red livery.

7 Dennis Dennis
8 George George

George is better than Buster.

He has potential.

9 Smudger

He should definitely return

I wonder what happened to him when the MSR closed.

He died...

Listen dukie

10 Lady

She is one of the cutest characters that I ever seen

She is the main train not shown much but she gave them life she is islands of sodors mother nature

She’s my favorite tank. HIT. Y U NO BRING HER BACK?!

The Contenders

11 Ned Ned

Clumsy but lovable.

He was replaced by Marion

12 Neville Neville

If he does return, make him less ugly. His face and design make me want to puke.

This might seem wired but neville is one of my favorite characters

I remember watching this when I was little - KingFab

13 Stepney

The blue bell engine

14 Kelly Kelly

The Pack are some of the only HIT characters that I care about.

Kelly is the Pack's leader. He needs to return.

15 Fergus Fergus

Of course Fergus should return. If they could bring back Daisy then surely they can bring back Fergus.

He was my favourite and I hated the fact he didn’t return

16 Class 40
17 Freddie Freddie

Ripped off both Ivo Hugh and Duke. I hate him.

He should never return.

Freddie is not number 7 on the Skarloey Railway. Ivo Hugh is.

18 Mighty Mac Mighty Mac

Mighty mac is a two face character and I like him

One of the only HIT characters that I care about.

The Chang and Eng of Thomas and Friends.

Mighty Mac is better than Freddie.

V 1 Comment
19 Trevor

Don't Tell anyone who has Trevor the traction engine

He is returning in season 20.

I'm glad that the traction engine (Trevor) had returned to T&F in CGI.

Nigel Pilkington/ Chris Ragland do an excellent voice for him, but I was expecting Enn Reitel to be Trevor's voice!

20 Lady
21 Buster Buster

And make his face less ugly.

22 Murdoch Murdoch

One of the only HIT characters that I care about.

Sodor needs more goods engines.

23 Sixteen

I think sixteen is a good character he dos not suck

He doesn't count. He never appeared in the television series, moron.
And by the way, he sucks.

Wilbert is boring, go Sixteen!

I dunno, Wilbert just seemed sort of generic from what I read about him. *shrugs*

V 1 Comment
24 Bulgy

Ya! Boo! Snubs! Haha!

He returned in the 21st Season

25 The Spiteful Brakevan

He died. Disagree? Watch "Donald & Douglas/Brake Van" again, and think common sense.

He's essential!

26 Arthur
27 Billy

Dear God I hate him.

I don't really like
if they made him maybe NICER then he might get some love

The fact that Billy is in the top 10000000000000000000 is bewilderingly awful. He is the 2nd worst character after *cringes* Lady.

28 Derek
29 Hank

He is a big steam engine and he's blue and strong

30 Isobella Isobella

I Think IsaBella Will Come back In CGI In Season 22 Called Max OR Monty The Upcoming

31 Bulstrode Bulstrode
32 Nelson Nelson
33 Bertram Bertram

This guy needs to return!

I don't know how his nickname is old warrior


34 Byron

He has potential.

35 Harvey

Pretty much, Rocky's now doing his work. But they both are really useful. The last season Harvey appeared in was season 12. Rocky shouldn't be doing all the work now, that puts Harvey out of a job. Although unlike Rocky, Harvey can move on his own. Harvey can't lift everything Rocky can, but he can do a fair amount of lifting. If he ever does come back to the show, I do predict he'll be working at the "Sodor Search and Rescue Center"

He already returned. But I hate him.

36 Bill

Not much to say about these guys. It is a shame that only Ben was in season 12. They should be everywhere together like Michael Angelis and Alec Baldwin say in "Buffer Bother" in their respective country's version. But both are not on the show now, and they should come back.

37 Duncan

Season 16 was suppose to bring back all the original narrow-gauge engines. And they did, all except two. Duke who we'll get to later, and Duncan. I've read some sources that the reason Duncan didn't appear in season 16 or "Blue Mountain Mystery" was because at the time Nitrogen Studios went to the Talyllyn railway to get details on the real life basis's, Duncan's twin, Douglas was under repairs. So Nitrogen couldn't be made at that point. But hopefully by now Douglas has been repaired and Arc Productions will animate him for season 17.

He already returned.

38 Donald

These twins were awesome. They were a couple of characters that didn't make many appearances by the time we got into the season 8 era. I do predict that if they did come back, the same guy would voice them both in the UK and US considering they are Scottish.

39 Oliver

Oliver was an awesome character. And he still is. The problem is, he's not with us now. MissOliverandBlossom was, as his username applies, missed him a lot at the time he joined YouTube. Since at that time were just got into the new model series and Oliver didn't make a comeback until season 12, and then he disappears again.

He already returned.

40 Duck

Now, looking at the picture that I used, you'll have already guessed that Duck is going to come back. Thank you Mr. Brenner! A lot of people thought that Emily had replaced him along with Donald, Douglas and Oliver, but we all know that's not true. Duck never made any huge roles and he hardly was part of the steam team. But he's coming back, thank goodness, everybody rejoice. Let's hope he stays this time and not just disappear again after 1 season.

He's already returned.

41 Ben

He and Bill have already returned.

42 Douglas

I love Douglas, he's my favorite character!

He and Donald have already returned.

43 Hector

I hate him.

44 Flora

I hate her.

45 Old Slow Coach

I hate her.

46 Caroline

She and Stepney should return together.

47 Jeremy
48 Colin
49 Toad

He already returned.

50 Jock

Jock is not coming back

He doesn't count.

PSearch List