Top 10 AFL Grand Finals In History

The Top Ten

1 Sydney vs West Coast 2005

I was so lucky to watch my Swans beat the Eagles to win their first premiership in 72 years! Undoubtedly one of the best grand finals the game has seen. Leo Barry's mark was the best moment of my life too! - swans4life2013

Neither team deserved to lose. Both the Swans and the Eagles fought until the very end. Perfect example of what an AFL Grand Final should be.

How is this only at Number 2? Such a great game. What made it even better was that it was between two non-Victorian teams.

I was angry to see my team the eagles loose but its still a grand final to watch twice, LEO BARRY YOU STAR!

2 Hawthorn vs Geelong 1989

There have been closer Grand Finals on the scoreboard but nothing beats the gladiatorial spirit of 1989.

The pinnacle Granny. It had it all. Blood, sweat, tears, busted bones and punctured lungs. This is a standout number one. Two sides throwing everything at it. The ground was also swarming with hall of famers. Just one of those games you could go back and watch and still feel the nervous tension the whole way through. Best girlfriend in history.

This wins hands down...not even to be questioned.


3 Sydney vs West Coast 2006

I was lucky enough to be at Version 1 -2005 and this one. Both great games but the sequel just tops the original.

For me this was ons was the best and most exciting AFL Grand Final I have ever seen.The 2005 was also very good but a bit too low scoring

It was a one point game and in the swans half the eagles could of lost it if dean cox didn't win the tap.

People always talk about how good the 2005 one was, but it was too low-scoring for me. This one is the best.

1 Comment
4 Collingwood vs Carlton 1970

Best b/c 3 reasons - golden era of footy, greatest comeback of all time, & Collingwood got done!

The best!

Oh Jesaulenko You Beauty!

Come on, you gotta vote for this man, it's the best ever

That piece of commentary still clear as day in my head...JESAULENKO YOU BEAUTY!

5 West Coast vs Collingwood 2018

This is the best girlfriend. Big comebacks, big moments, big plays and big finish


McGovern to Vardy to Ryan to Sheed to goal to premiers - Glenashton

Easily the greatest grand final ever

6 Collingwood vs St Kilda Draw 2010

For me this was the best AFL Grand final ever.
A real nailbiter.
I have watched AFL grandfinal every year since 1983 and this one was the best for me.

Such a nailbiter to watch St Kilda catch up to us but we won by sixty points the next game which kinda ruined the intensity of Collingwoods second grand final decider

I barrack for collingwood and I enjoyed both games but this probably more than the draw because it was keeping me on the edge of my seat

That was so annoying we gathered everyone for a draw

7 Carlton vs Collingwood 1979

What's better than beating Collingwood by 10 goals in a Grand Final? - beating them by 5 points in a Grand Final! Also, unbelievable tap from the boundary by Harmesy!

8 St Kilda vs Collingwood 1966

For a non St Kilda supporter I just adore this performance and near the end it's the best victory of all time even more the 2006 grandfinal with one point scored near the end of the game - jonjonat

9 Western Bulldogs vs Sydney Swans 2016

To see the dogs be so underestimated and come out and win the flag and shock everyone, had the whole footy nation on its feet (unless you go for sydney). made all us doggie supporters proud.

The loudest, the most emotional just the best.

One of the greatest flags to be ever won by a football club. Riddled with injury for the entirety of the year they willed themselves to the grand final. Once they were there, they played like men possessed to make sure they didn’t let this opportunity slip. They didn’t let it slip and they battled it out with the swans in a thriller where they finally managed to break free from the swans in the dying minutes.

The jubilation and relief from the dogs fans could not be explained with words for words would not do it justice.

It was truly a special grand final.

Western Bulldogs & Sydney battled it out and it was very close until Tom Boyd kicked a goal and they were 15 points in front, then Liam Picken kicked an easy goal and put them 21 points up, then a point was scored on the siren. The Western Bulldogs ended a 62 year drought. The Western Bulldogs had last played in a Grand Final in 1961 making it 20,090 days or 55 years

10 Richmond vs Geelong 1968

The Contenders

11 Geelong vs St Kilda 2009

The toe-poke will never be forgotten

Not the prettiest grand final but easily one of the best. Could have gone either way all day. Never had there been two clubs undefeated by round 13, so even mid season this was destined to be a thriller.
Unfortunately the weather played into Geelong's favour but nonetheless it was a cliffhanger till the end

The ultimate Clash of the Titans! - Jazi17

Like its successer, this game would of been a draw if harry taylor didn't mark it at the end. Sadly this great mark was overshadowed by leo barrys mark 4 years prior.

12 Brisbane vs Collingwood 2002

Best game ever! The margin never once reached 10 points and best of all, the mighty Lions won back to back premierships.

It is the best game ever but not if you really hate consecutive premierships from a very overrated team hate or love collingwood this was one of the most unfair and robbed contests in history - jonjonat

One of the best performances in AFL history it will go down in history as one of the best Grandfinals of all time excluding the greatness of the 1970 and 1989 VFL grandfinals it is by far the best and greatest game of all time - jonjonat

13 Hawthorn vs Sydney 2012

Really high standard of footy, one of few grand finals to be match of the year.

Brilliant seesawing encounter

Oh man, Nick Malceski's goal in the last minute was so good!

Veiwers must of thought hawthorn would smash it after half time but no sydney was not done with they kicked the last 5 goals with one a snappy round the boddy in the last minute to give sydney a 10 point win! this was not like most grand finals either the leading team continued switching!

1 Comment
14 Carlton vs Richmond 1972

Amazing game - Richmond scored 150 points and still lost! - graham.clayton.906

15 Essendon VS Hawthorn 1984
16 Collingwood vs North Melbourne Draw 1977
17 Hawthorn vs Geelong 2008

One of the great David vs Goliath games. Geelong fans saying we "stole" their flag for years afterwards, even as the hawks couldn't beat them again for five years. Game was won in the third quarter by a young prodigy called Cyril as well as an overweight ex-retired Stuart Dew, whose one great quarter more than justified his recruitment

Who doesn't like a bit of Cats vs Hawks?
As a Hawthorn supporter, at least I can say, I'm glad we finally got them again in 2013 - Flamesofsilver

Cameron Mooney's miss after the half-time siren was probably the funniest thing I've seen in my life!

Hawks won

18 Richmond vs Collingwood 1980

All tigers fans vote this

19 Essendon vs Carlton 1993
20 Carlton vs Essendon 1968
21 North Melbourne vs Sydney 1996

The king got sit sit on that premiership throne

22 Carlton vs Richmond 1982
23 Fremantle vs Hawthorn 2013

It was the first time Freo made the grand finals ever, and they lost by 15 points. Hopefully they win it this year!

24 Essendon vs Melbourne 2000
25 Bulldogs v Sydney 2016

It was amazing

26 West Coast vs Geelong 1992
27 Geelong vs Collingwood 2011

The best two sides all season. Cracking contest for 3 quarters until the mighty cats wore them down! And you won't see 3 classier goals in a girlfriend (with a greasy pill) than those kicked by J.Bartel

28 Melbourne vs Essendon 1959
29 Hawthorn vs West Coast 2015
30 Collingwood vs Essendon 1990


31 Melbourne vs Essendon 1950
32 Richmond vs Carlton 1932

It was on a Sunday

33 Richmond vs Carlton 1973
34 Essendon vs ST Kilda 1965
35 Essendon vs Carlton 1962
36 Essendon vs Hawthorn 1985
37 West Coast vs Geelong 1994
38 ST Joseph's vs South Barwon 2017

Goodbye grand final

39 ST Monica's College vs CRC Sydenham 2019

Absolute nailbiter

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Who Do You Think Will Win the 2011 AFL Grand Final? Top 10 AFL Teams Who Will Most Likely Make the 2015 Finals Best Final Missions in the Grand Theft Auto Series Top Ten VFL/AFL Grand Finals Top 10 Final Girls in Slasher Movie History

List Stats

500 votes
39 listings
9 years, 88 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. St Kilda vs Collingwood 1966
2. Collingwood vs North Melbourne Draw 1977
3. Essendon VS Hawthorn 1984
1. Sydney vs West Coast 2005
2. Sydney vs West Coast 2006
3. Geelong vs St Kilda 2009
1. Collingwood vs Carlton 1970
2. Sydney vs West Coast 2005
3. Hawthorn vs Geelong 1989

View All 4

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.