Top Ten Cincinnati Reds Players

The Top Ten

1 Pete Rose, IF/OF Pete Rose, IF/OF

So what if he gambled, you can't argue with his numbers.

MOST HITS! Ya'll should know that! It's quite obvious to tell you the truth! Most hits! DUH!

Best Reds player all time. Too bad he makes poor decisions from time to time.

I love Eric Davis but as long as Charlie hustle is any list he’s got my vote

2 Johnny Bench, C

No player ever owned his position like Bench. His 1976 World Series was legendary. Also a great ambassador for the team.

Johnny is my idol. because in a softball catcher. I love the reds. I also love catching. Everyone I know is wishing the best of luck to the reds.

Greatest catcher ever! Greatest Red ever! And pure class all the way. Let's don't forget homered final at bat also

Greatest catcher of all time and greatest Red

1 Comment
3 Ken Griffey Jr. Ken Griffey Jr. George Kenneth Griffey Jr. nicknamed "Junior" and "The Kid", is an American former professional baseball outfielder who played 22 years in Major League Baseball.

Pitch, crack, gone

More of a Mariner, but still great for the list - aman28

Arguably greatest player ever, but had his share of injuries with the Reds, that is why he is not higher on the list

4 Frank Robinson, OF

I was wrong, you're right. I looked at the stats, and his ten years with the Reds clearly included better years than his six years with the Orioles. He made a Triple Crown (for whatever that's worth) in his first year with the Orioles at age 30, but he had three consecutive great years in his mid-20s. I guess I'm guilty of being nostalgic about my own childhood years when Frank was part of a dominant Orioles team.

Had his best years with the Orioles but was a great Red too

Not true. Robbie actually had a slightly better career with the Reds. Look at the stats.

5 Barry Larkin, SS

its a crime if he is left out of the Hall of Fame

Maybe not the "Greatest SS of All Time" but I wouldn't have a worry in the world with #11 playing SS, with it all on the line!

Can you say "MVP"

6 Joe Morgan, 2B

arguably the greatest second baseman ever

7 Tony Perez 1B

Heart of the big red machine. 1967 thru 1977 eleven straight years of 90+ rbi's. Unheard of in the 60's and 70's. Not Mays, Aaron, McCovey, Killebrew, Mantle, Robinson, or Jackson accomplished this.

Heart of the big red machine. 90+ rbi's from 1967 thru 1977 no other player of his era did this, not Mays, Aaron, McCovey, Killebrew, Mantle, Robinson, or Jackson. eleven straight years of 90+ rbi's unheard of in the 60's and 70's.

Probably one of the best "team" players of all time. Great at keeping the newer players on a more even keel.

Hall of Famer, first baseman on Big Red Machine

8 George Foster

great Reds career especially in 1977 when he hit. 320 with 52 bombs

9 Joey Votto, 1B

One of the greatest guarantees to take first base with each plate appearance. No. 11 all -time in OBP. And one of the greatest all around hitters in Reds history

Already one of the best pure hitters in Reds history, and he's still cementing his legacy. He should already be in the top 10.

Joey Votto is AWESOME!

If Votto is still wearing a Reds uniform in 2021, he will be near the top of this list.

1 Comment
10 Jim Maloney

Gene Alley, Pittsburgh shortstop to me that Maloney was as good as anybody in the 60s. Koufax, Gibson or any others. He batted against all of them so I take his word on it. If healthy and pitching in the 70s Maloney would be in the Hall of Fame

The Contenders

11 Tom Browning
12 Vada Pinson
13 Eric Davis

Could do it all. Nobody played at such a high level of defense while smoking homers and grabbing bases. His reckless abandon shortened his amazing career

14 Dave Concepción

Best short stop in his day

15 Ernie Lombardi
16 Brandon Phillips
17 Edd Roush
18 Ted Kluzuszki

Greatest slugger of his era!

19 Shin Soo Choo

What? One solid season with the Reds and then grabs the big $$$ in free agency.

20 Paul Derringer
21 Adam Duvall

Great Hr Hitter

22 Billy Hamilton

Couse I said

23 Sean Casey
24 Edwin Encarnación
25 Bronson Arroyo
26 Cesar Geronimo
27 Dan Driessen
28 Joe Nuxhall

By far the best

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Best Cincinnati Reds Players of the 2013-2014 Season Top Ten Best Cincinnati Reds Players of 2016 Top Ten Cincinnati Bengals Players of the 2015-2016 Season Best Cincinnati Bengals Players of 2016 Top Ten Cincinnati Bengals Players of the 2016-2017 Season

List Stats

200 votes
28 listings
11 years, 149 days old

Top Remixes

1. Pete Rose, IF/OF
2. Ken Griffey Jr.
3. Johnny Bench, C
1. Pete Rose, IF/OF
2. Johnny Bench, C
3. Frank Robinson, OF


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.