Top 10 Most Underrated Albums from Great Rock and Metal Bands


The Top Ten

1 Jugulator - Judas Priest

It has some great tracks on it plus Tim The Ripper Owens is a great vocalist - christangrant

Honestly, this album was pretty good. It was much better than it's crappy follow up Demolition. - MegaSlayerDeath

2 The Great Southern Trendkill - Pantera

Oh yes this is so Underrated as this album In My Opinion is better than Far Beyond Driven plus it has my favorite Pantera song "Floods" on it - christangrant

Far Beyond Driven is actually my favorite Pantera album. But I agree that this album is definitely overlooked, mainly because Pantera released 3 metal classics right before it. Hard to top them all off don't you think? - cjWriter1997

3 Power Metal - Pantera

This was a good and underrated album. Cowboys from Hell was just overrated considering their later albums after Cowboys from Hell were better such as Vulgar Display of Power but Power Metal was a pretty good album. - MegaSlayerDeath

Yes this was a good album its underrated only because it was before Cowboys from Hell - christangrant

Some pretty good songs especially "We'll meet again" with a beautiful solo

4 Alice in Chains - Alice in Chains

It's personally my second favorite AiC album only to be behind Dirt. Don't hear a lot of appreciation for this album. It was the last album they had with Layne too. - cjWriter1997

5 The X Factor - Iron Maiden

It is long but that does not mean it is a bad album. Please do not listen to all your haters, and guys, it is nowhere near as bad as Virtual XI or No Prayer for the Dying. - MegaSlayerDeath

This album has gotten undeserved hate just because Blaze is the singer. If Bruce sang it, people would regard it as a good album. - kempokid

Although it does feel a bit too long this was still a good album - christangrant

6 Undertow - Tool

As much as their other albums are really great. This one goes a little unappreciated. - cjWriter1997

7 Meddle - Pink Floyd
8 Dehumanizer - Black Sabbath
9 Waiting for the Sun - The Doors
10 Thunder and Lightning - Thin Lizzy

The Contenders

11 Divine Intervention - Slayer
12 Deftones - Deftones
13 Flick of the Switch - AC/DC

I love this album by AC/DC in fact I like it more than For Those About to Rock - christangrant

AC/DC hasn't even released a bad record - MegaSlayerDeath

14 A Matter of Life and Death - Iron Maiden

This album gets undeserving hate - christangrant

15 Maladroit - Weezer
16 Sound of White Noise - Anthrax

This was a great metal/grunge album yet it's so low on the best Anthrax albums list when it's better than most of the albums above it - christangrant

Great album. Preferable over half their discography. Too bad the rest of John Bush's albums were bad. - MegaSlayerDeath

17 Leprosy - Death
18 Spiritual Healing - Death

Surprisingly this is actually one of my favorite Death albums. - MegaSlayerDeath

All Death albums are amazing but this one is my favourite - gravy

19 So Far, So Good... So What - Megadeth

Also really underrated, one of my favorite albums of theirs. - Metalfan2112

Hook in Mouth is my favorite Megadeth song.

A pretty solid album. - MegaSlayerDeath

20 Nine Lives - Aerosmith
21 Volume 8 - The Threat is Real - Anthrax

Its not as bad as everyone says it is it's better than Stomp 442 - christangrant

22 St. Anger - Metallica

It may be not the greatest Album by Metallica but at least it was better than Lulu - christangrant

That really is not saying much, Lulu was the literal worst piece of music I have ever heard, I would rather listen to Justin Bieber simply because his music isn't heavy. Awful music gets translated worse into metal because it is so much louder and in general less structured. - kempokid

St.Anger was "meh" at best. The song St.Anger sounded a lot like rap-speed metal (ish)
and the rest were "whatever" - EliHbk

23 Rubber Soul - The Beatles
24 Steal This Album - System of a Down
25 Done with Mirrors - Aerosmith
26 Nostradamus - Judas Priest
27 Diabolus in Musica - Slayer

This was seriously not in the Top 10. It just gets so much undeserved hate. - MegaSlayerDeath

28 Riot Act - Pearl Jam
29 The Endless River - Pink Floyd
30 Fly on the Wall - AC/DC
31 Sounding the Seventh Trumpet - Avenged Sevenfold
32 Verschwende Deine Zeit - Silbermond
33 Evanescence - Evanescence
34 Life Starts Now - Three Days Grace
35 Wave of Popular Feeling - Groundswell
36 Transit of Venus - Three Days Grace
37 Human - Three Days Grace
38 Dark Before Dawn - Breaking Benjamin
39 We are Not Alone - Breaking Benjamin
40 Phobia - Breaking Benjamin
41 Dear Agony - Breaking Benjamin
42 Evans Blue - Evans Blue
43 The Open Door - Evanescence
44 Saint Asonia - Saint Asonia
45 Blow Up Your Video - AC/DC
46 Stomp 442 - Anthrax
47 Rock 'n' Roll - Motorhead

This is better than Overkill and Ace of Spades - christangrant

Actually not really I prefer those other two albums but this one is vert underrated - christangrant

48 Reload - Metallica
49 High Voltage - AC/DC
50 The Golden Age of Grotesque - Marilyn Manson
PSearch List

Related Lists

Top Ten Classic Rock Album Covers that Would Be Great Metal Album Covers Most Underrated Hard Rock and Metal Bands of the 90s Most Underrated Rock and Metal Bands Top 10 Most Underrated Albums by Good Metal Bands Greatest Classic Rock Songs by Great Bands

List Stats

51 listings
1 year, 221 days old

Top Remixes

1. Dehumanizer - Black Sabbath
2. Thunder and Lightning - Thin Lizzy
3. Jugulator - Judas Priest
1. Alice in Chains - Alice in Chains
2. Undertow - Tool
3. Meddle - Pink Floyd


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.