Most Underrated Creepypastas

The Top Ten

1 1999

Great story. Chilling.

True

You mean Disneyland 99?

This is one of my favorite pastas, A+

2 Penpal

Hideously long but if you've got a couple hours to spare it's worth the read. Plus it's in six parts anyway, but after reading one you'll want to binge read. Each part contains small clues that link to a bigger and disturbing picture.

3 Candle Cove

A little too well.known - AgentofAnarchy

4 Antran

Its creepy because it could actually happen imagine it

5 The Russian Sleep Experiment

This is true because one, it has a scary image two, it has a mix of scare and gore and three, HOLY GOD THIS IS A GOOD PASTA!

6 The Rake
7 Rap Rat

Even saying his name haunts me - DubstepLover

8 Count Down
9 The Red Crayon
10 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

You mean overrated

Do you even know what "underrated" means?! If anything, he's the MOST OVERRATED CREEPYPASTA EVER! And he's not even creepy, so he should be a Crappypasta, not a Creepypasta - XxDarkStorm_PhoenixMothxX

He's popular but also dumb.

The Contenders

11 The Cough
12 Gateway to the Mind
13 Drinking of Water
14 Barney the Dinosaur Barney The Dinosaur is a purple dinosaur from the TV series "Barney and Friends", as well as the VHS series before that known as "Barney and the Backyard Gang". He was created by Sheryl Leach in 1987, to entertain her 2 year old son. He is infamously known for his "I Love You" song, and his TV series ...read more.

I can’t dare to look at the hideous purple face...

A very sad story - DubstepLover

15 Ticci Toby

My favorite character, Tic-ing all around.. Abusive father, dead.. Mother, scared.. Sister, ran over.. I love the storyline, and backstory; Ticci Toby personally in my opinion, is the best creepypasta character.

Deserves more credit. I like Jeff the Killer and Clockwork, I really DO, but their stories are very flawed. But Toby's story is actually very well written. He was constantly picked on in school and he had an abusive father. He deserves more love.

My favorite CreepyPasta but nobody knows who he is

Nononononono this is a jeff the killer kind of story - DubstepLover

16 Psychosis

Wonderful story, great plot twist

My favorite

17 The TV Man
18 The Truth Behind My Little Pony

Made me cry a bit - DubstepLover

19 On a Hill

Long but worth the read, or listen

20 NoEnd House

Oh yes it scared me so much

I love the ending, one of the best creepypastas in my opinion

Very good story had me in suspense the whole time

21 Slenderman The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

Honestly, not that underrated. He already got enough attention - XxDarkStorm_PhoenixMothxX

22 The Showers

This one is legitimately terrifying. and so are others on this list. aside from 1999, jeff the killer and spongecry. - jayceaw

23 Happy Appy
24 Where the Bad Kids Go
25 The Love-Sick Animal
26 The Depths

As a gaming pasta, it's surprisingly well written compared to the others. It's my app time favorite. Here's the link to the CORRECT version: http://vidyadreemz.blogspot.com/2013/04/the-depths.html? m=1

27 Annie96 Is Typing
28 Spongebob bootleg
29 Borrasca

I love this story, and it needs,more attention.

30 Suicide Sadie
31 Zalgo Zalgo is an Internet legend about an ominous entity believed to cause insanity, death and destruction of the world, similar to the creature Cthulhu created by H.P. Lovecraft in the 1920s. Zalgo is often associated with scrambled text on webpages and photos of people whose eyes and mouth have been covered ...read more.
32 Hope Is Lost
33 Fuzzy

Great story

34 BOB
35 Spongecry.avi
36 Max and Ruby 0004
37 NES Godzilla

This is the best one of all. - asantalo

38 Come Follow Me
39 AntiChrist Superstar
40 The Purple Balloon
41 Gumball The Grieving
42 Stairs
43 Room Zero
44 The Harbinger Experiment
45 Squidward's Suicide
46 The Alice Killings

I love this creepypasta. I don't know why

47 Ted the Caver

Incredibly chilling, a masterpiece.

48 Eyeless Jack
49 Mario Kart Black

I HAD NIGHTMARES FOR WEEKS

50 Pokémon Lost Silver

A very unsettling and well written haunted game cartridge story. Kinda long, but worth the read.”

8Load More
PSearch List